Batman at Bat Chris Geiger, Sean Rose, Stephen Winchell

Just as things begin to look up for Gotham City, a villain returns to put his own spin on the proceedings. It’s Joker Baseball, baby! The unlikeliest of heroes emerges to save the day.

As things look their darkest, a new dawn begins. The baseball signal lights up in the sky, and a true hero rises to bring calm to the crowd. He may not be the hero we wanted, but he’s the hero we needed. He is … Joltin’ Joe.

The Scarecrow forces the Big Shots to face what they fear most. And one man in the booth begins a dark spiritual journey he’ll never forget. Special guest star: Black Canary!

Fred takes a break and it’s Jimmy’s time to shine in the booth. Joker springs into action but is replaced by a relief pitcher who strikes terror into the crowd and strikes out the side. The booth wrestles with their greatest fears.

Picking up the pieces after a brief glimpse of the end of the world in the fourth inning, our intrepid commentators face their most terrifying foe yet. Also, Superman wows the crowd once again!

The heroes and villains are having a hard time playing ball, strangely enough. And to make matters worse, grudges on the field take a deadly turn as a few of the players clear the benches for an not-so-typical baseball brawl.