38 min

Counter-banditry, or Narratives of Otherness Paper Arrows

    • Social Sciences

Episode III: Counter-banditry, or Narratives of Otherness
In today’s podcast, we travel together to Olancho to hear campesinos’ tales of the Robin Hood of Honduras, Canuto. As villagers tell it - both those who knew him and those who did not, but who build upon his legend and legacy - Canuto was a magical trickster and a powerful ally of the poor. If we listen to these stories with a careful ear, we can hear the strains of a song of resistance, sung by folks across the Olancho countryside, that tacitly reject the dominant narratives projected upon everyday Olanchanos by dominant-society actors and framings. These stories, and the circumstances surrounding their production, swirl with complexities and contradictions, and they bespeak a power imbalance perhaps too great to be overcome with mere words. But these are fighting words, invoked by a spirited people, and they signal that community lands and livelihoods will not so easily be surrendered.
--
I owe a great intellectual debt to my research participants as well as to many journalists, historians, and social-science researchers. In the podcast, I sometimes shorthand the fuller citations contained in the written version of my master's thesis. Here, however, are the works I cite in that volume:
Works Cited
Acker, Alison. 1988. Honduras: the making of a banana republic. Boston: South End Press.
"Agitadores que reciben dólares del exterior causaron disturbios: Gautama." 2001. Tiempo, July 20, http://www.tiempo.hn/edicante/2001/julio/20%20julio/nacion~1/nacio5.htm.
Amaya, Miriam. 2000. "Honduras, el eslabón más débil de la integración." La Prensa, September 5, http://www.laprensahn.com/economarc/0009/e05001.htm.
Anderson, Benedict R. O'G. 1983. Imagined communities: reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism. London: Verso.
Arnold, David. 1996. The problem of nature: environment, culture and European expansion, New perspectives on the past. Oxford, Eng.; Cambridge, Mass.: Blackwell.
"Banco Centroamericano congela préstamo para proyectos hidroeléctricos." 2001. La Prensa, July 30, http://www.laprensahn.com/natarc/0107/n30004.htm.
Blok, Anton. 1988 [1974]. The mafia of a Sicilian village, 1860-1960: a study of violent peasant entrepreneurs. Prospect Heights, Illinois: Waveland Press.
Bonner, Raymond. 1981. "Green Berets step up Honduras role." New York Times, August 9: 16.
Bonta, Mark Andrew. 2001. "Mapping enredos of complex spaces: a regional geography of Olancho, Honduras." PhD dissertation, Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College.
"'Canuto' fue víctima de una venganza." 1992. La Tribuna, October 1: 50.
"'Canuto' había sembrado el terror en Olancho." 1992. Tiempo, October 1: 19.
"Cardenal Oscar Rodríguez: Si siguen las huelgas no vamos a tener inversión: El purpurado recibe homenaje de la Policía Nacional." 2001. Diario Tiempo, September 1, URL not functioning.
Cardona Solís, Oscar Manuel. 2001. Unpublished letter to Mary Flake de Flores, First Lady of Honduras, July 26.
Castillo, Hugo, and Victoria Asfura de Díaz. 2000. Letter, May 31, 2000.
"Centroamérica iniciará interconexión eléctrica en 1998." 1998. La Prensa, January 5, http://www.laprensahn.com/natarc/9801/n05002.htm.
"Ceremonia en el Congreso Nacional: embajador de Taiwan y periodista hondureña homenajeados." 2001. Tiempo, July 20, : http://www.tiempo.hn/edicante/2001/julio/20%20julio/nacion~1/nacional.htm.
Clastres, Pierre. 1987. Society against the state: essays in political anthropology. Translated by Abe Stein. New York: Zone Books; Cambridge: Distributed by the MIT Press.
COFADEH. 2001. "Voces contra el olvido." In Voces contra el olvido, edited by Bertha Oliva de Guifarro. Tegucigalpa.
Consejo Central para la Protección del Ambiente de Gualaco, Olancho. 2001. "Propuesta de organización del Concejo [sic] para la Protección del...

Episode III: Counter-banditry, or Narratives of Otherness
In today’s podcast, we travel together to Olancho to hear campesinos’ tales of the Robin Hood of Honduras, Canuto. As villagers tell it - both those who knew him and those who did not, but who build upon his legend and legacy - Canuto was a magical trickster and a powerful ally of the poor. If we listen to these stories with a careful ear, we can hear the strains of a song of resistance, sung by folks across the Olancho countryside, that tacitly reject the dominant narratives projected upon everyday Olanchanos by dominant-society actors and framings. These stories, and the circumstances surrounding their production, swirl with complexities and contradictions, and they bespeak a power imbalance perhaps too great to be overcome with mere words. But these are fighting words, invoked by a spirited people, and they signal that community lands and livelihoods will not so easily be surrendered.
--
I owe a great intellectual debt to my research participants as well as to many journalists, historians, and social-science researchers. In the podcast, I sometimes shorthand the fuller citations contained in the written version of my master's thesis. Here, however, are the works I cite in that volume:
Works Cited
Acker, Alison. 1988. Honduras: the making of a banana republic. Boston: South End Press.
"Agitadores que reciben dólares del exterior causaron disturbios: Gautama." 2001. Tiempo, July 20, http://www.tiempo.hn/edicante/2001/julio/20%20julio/nacion~1/nacio5.htm.
Amaya, Miriam. 2000. "Honduras, el eslabón más débil de la integración." La Prensa, September 5, http://www.laprensahn.com/economarc/0009/e05001.htm.
Anderson, Benedict R. O'G. 1983. Imagined communities: reflections on the origin and spread of nationalism. London: Verso.
Arnold, David. 1996. The problem of nature: environment, culture and European expansion, New perspectives on the past. Oxford, Eng.; Cambridge, Mass.: Blackwell.
"Banco Centroamericano congela préstamo para proyectos hidroeléctricos." 2001. La Prensa, July 30, http://www.laprensahn.com/natarc/0107/n30004.htm.
Blok, Anton. 1988 [1974]. The mafia of a Sicilian village, 1860-1960: a study of violent peasant entrepreneurs. Prospect Heights, Illinois: Waveland Press.
Bonner, Raymond. 1981. "Green Berets step up Honduras role." New York Times, August 9: 16.
Bonta, Mark Andrew. 2001. "Mapping enredos of complex spaces: a regional geography of Olancho, Honduras." PhD dissertation, Louisiana State University and Agricultural and Mechanical College.
"'Canuto' fue víctima de una venganza." 1992. La Tribuna, October 1: 50.
"'Canuto' había sembrado el terror en Olancho." 1992. Tiempo, October 1: 19.
"Cardenal Oscar Rodríguez: Si siguen las huelgas no vamos a tener inversión: El purpurado recibe homenaje de la Policía Nacional." 2001. Diario Tiempo, September 1, URL not functioning.
Cardona Solís, Oscar Manuel. 2001. Unpublished letter to Mary Flake de Flores, First Lady of Honduras, July 26.
Castillo, Hugo, and Victoria Asfura de Díaz. 2000. Letter, May 31, 2000.
"Centroamérica iniciará interconexión eléctrica en 1998." 1998. La Prensa, January 5, http://www.laprensahn.com/natarc/9801/n05002.htm.
"Ceremonia en el Congreso Nacional: embajador de Taiwan y periodista hondureña homenajeados." 2001. Tiempo, July 20, : http://www.tiempo.hn/edicante/2001/julio/20%20julio/nacion~1/nacional.htm.
Clastres, Pierre. 1987. Society against the state: essays in political anthropology. Translated by Abe Stein. New York: Zone Books; Cambridge: Distributed by the MIT Press.
COFADEH. 2001. "Voces contra el olvido." In Voces contra el olvido, edited by Bertha Oliva de Guifarro. Tegucigalpa.
Consejo Central para la Protección del Ambiente de Gualaco, Olancho. 2001. "Propuesta de organización del Concejo [sic] para la Protección del...

38 min