85 episodes

Bringing light to the long standing and baffling cold cases in the state of Maine, as well as digging into the creepy and crime-y stories from Vacationland and beyond state lines.

Cold in Maine Kylie Low LLC

    • True Crime
    • 5.0 • 2 Ratings

Bringing light to the long standing and baffling cold cases in the state of Maine, as well as digging into the creepy and crime-y stories from Vacationland and beyond state lines.

    Missing & Endangered: The Cathy Marie Moulton Case, Part Two

    Missing & Endangered: The Cathy Marie Moulton Case, Part Two

    The narrative of Cathy Marie Moulton's story for over two decades was that she simply disappeared, that no one had any idea where she might be. Her case received minimal attention by law enforcement in the years immediately following her disappearance. It would remain ice cold until November 12, 1995, when Kevin Cady was assigned to the case.
    Kevin Cady literally wrote the book on this case, and I read it. One thing was crystal clear after reading his book -- Cathy did not disappear without a trace. Someone DID have an idea where she might be. Kevin Cady is on Cold in Maine to dig into the longest standing missing persons case in the state of Maine, and what happened to her after she stepped out onto Forest Avenue that September evening in 1971.
    This is part two of Missing & Endangered: The Cathy Marie Moulton Case. If you haven't tuned into part one yet, go back one episode for the full story.
    Get Kevin Cady's Book, "Cathy Moulton Missing Endangered" on Amazon.
    All sources for this case and others featured on Cold in Maine are listed in the episode show notes at coldinmaine.com. Follow @coldinmaine on Instagram for key photos for this episode.

    • 41 min
    Missing & Endangered: The Cathy Marie Moulton Case, Part One

    Missing & Endangered: The Cathy Marie Moulton Case, Part One

    Cold in Maine launched with a mission to shed a light on Maine’s most baffling cold cases, but this isn’t just a long-standing cold case in Maine. This is one of the oldest missing persons cases in the country. It’s been 49 years this week since September 24, 1971, the day 16-year old Cathy Marie Moulton went missing from Portland, Maine.
    The Portland Police Department dismissed her as a runaway in 1971. Nearly 200 teens had runaway from home that year in Portland, Maine alone, but that didn't fit the daughter that Lyman "Roy" Moulton and his wife Claire knew and loved. 25 years after her disappearance, a new detective was assigned to the case, and he uncovered new details that no one bothered to look into when Cathy first disappeared. 
    This is Part One of Missing & Endangered: The Cathy Marie Moulton Case.
    All sources for this case and others featured on Cold in Maine are listed in the episode show notes at coldinmaine.com. Follow @coldinmaine on Instagram for key photos for this episode.

    • 22 min
    Lottie Cote Couldn't Stop Killing Her Husbands

    Lottie Cote Couldn't Stop Killing Her Husbands

    Kylie takes Cold in Maine back over 100 years for a look at the case of Lottie Cote, perhaps the most sensational murder cases in Maine's history that made national headlines. In 1910, Lottie Freeman's first husband, William Sanborn, turns up missing. She suspected he fled to Canada after forging her name on some notes he couldn't pay. The beautiful Lottie's story is taken as fact, and the disappearance is never investigated. 
    But in 1924, when her second husband is reported missing by Lottie, it doesn't pass the sniff test for the Sheriff in North Gorham. What happened to William Sanborn and Alphonse Cote? Was Lottie truly the unlucky widow, or did she mastermind the murders of two men who believed they'd won her heart?
    All sources for this case and others featured on Cold in Maine are listed in the episode show notes at coldinmaine.com. 
    A special thanks to the newspaper.com archives for the Boston Globe, Bangor Daily News, Tuscaloosa Times, and St. Albans Daily Messenger.
    Follow @coldinmaine on Instagram for key photos for this case.

    • 35 min
    Her Bloodstained Cutlass Supreme: The Shirley McAvoy Murder

    Her Bloodstained Cutlass Supreme: The Shirley McAvoy Murder

    In October 1990, Brian McAvoy arrives at his ex-wife’s small home they used to share in Pittsfield, Maine, and makes a horrifying discovery. His former wife Shirley had been missing since August, and was last seen with a mystery man that nobody can identify. Now, police know they have a murder on their hands, and a person of interest to find. Press play now to hear all the details of this tangled mystery, and put your sleuth skills to use to help us bring this case justice.
    Who murdered Shirley McAvoy?
    Submit a Tip
    More from Our Sources
    Bangor Daily News, Car Found, April 1991
    Fox Bangor, 2019
    Bangor Daily News, Investigation continues, October 1991
    Bangor Daily News, October 1990
    Got a story to share? Visit us at coldinmaine.com or email us at coldinmainepodcast@gmail.com to submit your stories and ideas, or to just say hi. Follow us on Instagram for the latest updates @ColdInMaine.

    • 45 min
    SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT: Welcome to Cold in Maine

    SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT: Welcome to Cold in Maine

    We're thrilled to announce that Little Stories Podcast is now Cold in Maine. With the incredible success of the mini-series and overwhelming excitement you've shown for the true crime direction of the show these last six weeks, we've renamed and refocused the podcast to Cold in Maine. Full-time, true crime. 
    Press play to hear how the podcast has evolved since its launch in early 2019, why we changed course now, and what's to come from the new format. 
    Cold in Maine covers Maine's unsolved murders, true crime cases, and stories from away. We're bringing to light the longstanding and baffling cold cases in the state of Maine, as well as digging into the creepy and crime-y stories from Vacationland and beyond state lines.
    Find us at coldinmaine.com and on Instagram @coldinmaine.

    • 18 min
    A Killer in Common? The Janet Brochu and Geraldine Anne Finn Cases

    A Killer in Common? The Janet Brochu and Geraldine Anne Finn Cases

    After a night out with friends at a Waterville bar in 1987, 20-year old Janet Brochu was never seen alive again. When you hear the details of Janet Brochu’s case, and how it intertwines with the murder of another young Maine woman around the same time and place, you’ll be demanding to know how it’s possible Janet Brochu’s case is still without answers. 
    Note from the Show: Gerald Goodale has never been publicly or formally named a suspect in the unsolved Janet Brochu homicide case and all commentary by hosts is speculation and narration for entertainment purposes only.
    Connect with us at ColdinMaine.com and coldinmainepodcast@gmail.com.
    More from Our Sources
    Maine State Prison Inmate Records for Gerald Goodale
    Legacy.com Obituary for Geraldine Brochu
    Landowner discovers body... Bangor Daily News, August 1988
    Waterville man to be arraigned... Bangor Daily News, August 1988
    Just denies bail... Bangor Daily News, September 1988
    Man accused in killing... Bangor Daily News, August 1988
    Waterville man given 75... Bangor Daily News, June 1989
    Police continue investigation... Bangor Daily News, March 1988
    Cases of unsolved deaths... Bangor Daily News, February 1990
    Body of Winslow woman... Bangor Daily News by Brenda Seekins, March 1988
     

    • 32 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
2 Ratings

2 Ratings

Madie.H ,

LOVE the quality and storytelling

My usual podcast listening is in a totally different genre, but I love tuning in to these stories as a change of pace. They’re so interesting and somehow soothing to listen to at the same time. Such a fan of the passion behind it!

Shelli Warren ,

Chills, Spills, and Thrills

What a riot! Love the randomness of the stories you and your guests share. Seriously good stuff ladies! Keep ‘em coming. BTW sharing the photos on IG takes your podcast over the top!

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Listeners Also Subscribed To