58 episodes

Sisters Mary and Deirdre have always been obsessed with true crime. With Deirdre's background in criminal justice and Mary's degree in mental health, these sisters give a unique perspective on each case.

Not Your Normal Murder notyournormalmurder

    • True Crime
    • 4.4 • 12 Ratings

Sisters Mary and Deirdre have always been obsessed with true crime. With Deirdre's background in criminal justice and Mary's degree in mental health, these sisters give a unique perspective on each case.

    The Mysterious Death of Sarah Widmer and the Case Against Ryan Widmer

    The Mysterious Death of Sarah Widmer and the Case Against Ryan Widmer

    Episode #55 // The Mysterious Death of Sarah Widmer and the Case Against Ryan Widmer In 2008, Sarah Widmer would tell her husband she was taking a bath before bed. Over an hour later, a 911 call would be placed by Ryan Widmer. Sarah had drowned in the bathtub. Since that day, the question has been asked, was Sarah's drowning an accident, or murder? We are proudly sponsored by Why Do We Own This DVD? Husband and wife team discuss, evaluate, and justify their DVD collection. From no-brainers, to "someone's got some 'splaining to do" Diane and Sean will go through nearly 300 DVDs over the course of this podcast. We are also proudly sponsored by The Everyday Style School Podcast. The Everyday Style School is a show that shares the knowledge, experience, and stories that can only be gained after dressing women for almost two decades. With each episode, they aim to inspire women to love the way they look right now, and equip them with the tools to make style easy and fun. Head over to youreverydaystyle.com and use code normal15 to take $15 off of one of their Style Masterclasses, or your first month’s membership.  We are also proudly sponsored by The Pop Culture Show!  The Pop Culture Show is a weekly deep dive into the world of popular culture complete with celebrity interviews. Join award winning hosts Barnes, Leslie, and Cubby to fly through the latest TV, music, movies, celebrity sleaze, and general observations from the crazy world around us. New episodes every Monday at 10 am est. wherever you get your podcasts. And we are also proudly sponsored by The Fireside Crime Podcast.  Do you love true crime? Do you love beer? Then you are in the right spot. Grab a beer and join them by the fire. It’s time for some Fireside Crime. Find them wherever you listens to podcasts! National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233  This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised. Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact. Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page, Instagram, TikTok and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future! We are proudly part of the Oracl3 Network. Find their website here. Patreon: Patreon.com/NYNM TikTok: NYNMPod Facebook: @NYNMPodcast Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder Email: Notyournormalmurder@gmail.com Twitter: @NYNMPodcast Youtube: Not Your Normal Murder For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here. This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved. Not Your Normal Murder is partnered with the Oracl3 Network. 

    • 1 hr
    The Attempted Murder of Greg Mulvahill and the Case Against Diana Lovejoy

    The Attempted Murder of Greg Mulvahill and the Case Against Diana Lovejoy

    Episode #54 // The Attempted Murder of Greg Mulvahill and the Case Against Diana LovejoyIn 2016, Greg and Diana were in a bitter divorce and custody battle. One day, Greg would get a strange phone call directing him to go to a secluded area. Once there, he would be shot at. He would survive, and an investigation would pursue. Diana would admit she and her lover had set up the situation, but had no intention of hurting Greg. What really happened? We are proudly sponsored by Why Do We Own This DVD? Husband and wife team discuss, evaluate, and justify their DVD collection. From no-brainers, to "someone's got some 'splaining to do" Diane and Sean will go through nearly 300 DVDs over the course of this podcast. We are also proudly sponsored by The Everyday Style School Podcast. The Everyday Style School is a show that shares the knowledge, experience, and stories that can only be gained after dressing women for almost two decades. With each episode, they aim to inspire women to love the way they look right now, and equip them with the tools to make style easy and fun. Head over to youreverydaystyle.com and use code normal15 to take $15 off of one of their Style Masterclasses, or your first month’s membership.  We are also proudly sponsored by The Pop Culture Show!  The Pop Culture Show is a weekly deep dive into the world of popular culture complete with celebrity interviews. Join award winning hosts Barnes, Leslie, and Cubby to fly through the latest TV, music, movies, celebrity sleaze, and general observations from the crazy world around us. New episodes every Monday at 10 am est. wherever you get your podcasts. And we are also proudly sponsored by The Fireside Crime Podcast.  Do you love true crime? Do you love beer? Then you are in the right spot. Grab a beer and join them by the fire. It’s time for some Fireside Crime. Find them wherever you listens to podcasts! National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233 This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised. Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact. Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page, Instagram, TikTok and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future! We are proudly part of the Oracl3 Network. Find their website here. Patreon: Patreon.com/NYNM TikTok: NYNMPod Facebook: @NYNMPodcast Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder Email: Notyournormalmurder@gmail.com Twitter: @NYNMPodcast Youtube: Not Your Normal Murder For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here. This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved. Not Your Normal Murder is partnered with the Oracl3 Network. 

    • 46 min
    The Murder of Yhoana Arteaga

    The Murder of Yhoana Arteaga

    Episode #54 // The Murder of Yhoana Arteaga In 2017, 12-year-old Yhoana Artegea would stay home from school for a sports injury. She would text her mother that someone was at the door. A few minutes later, she would send another text that the man had left, and he looked like the man who had mowed the lawn. When her mother got home, Yhoana had been brutally beaten and strangled. Who was the mysterious man, and did he have anything to do with this vicious crime? We are proudly sponsored by Why Do We Own This DVD? Husband and wife team discuss, evaluate, and justify their DVD collection. From no-brainers, to "someone's got some 'splaining to do" Diane and Sean will go through nearly 300 DVDs over the course of this podcast. We are also proudly sponsored by The Everyday Style School Podcast. The Everyday Style School is a show that shares the knowledge, experience, and stories that can only be gained after dressing women for almost two decades. With each episode, they aim to inspire women to love the way they look right now, and equip them with the tools to make style easy and fun. Head over to youreverydaystyle.com and use code normal15 to take $15 off of one of their Style Masterclasses, or your first month’s membership.  We are also proudly sponsored by The Pop Culture Show!  The Pop Culture Show is a weekly deep dive into the world of popular culture complete with celebrity interviews. Join award winning hosts Barnes, Leslie, and Cubby to fly through the latest TV, music, movies, celebrity sleaze, and general observations from the crazy world around us. New episodes every Monday at 10 am est. wherever you get your podcasts. And we are also proudly sponsored by The Fireside Crime Podcast.  Do you love true crime? Do you love beer? Then you are in the right spot. Grab a beer and join them by the fire. It’s time for some Fireside Crime. Find them wherever you listens to podcasts! National Suicide Hotline # 1800-273-8255 National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233 This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised. Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact. Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page, Instagram, TikTok and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future! We are proudly part of the Oracl3 Network. Find their website here. Patreon: Patreon.com/NYNM TikTok: NYNMPod Facebook: @NYNMPodcast Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder Email: Notyournormalmurder@gmail.com Twitter: @NYNMPodcast For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here. This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved. Not Your Normal Murder is partnered with the Oracl3 Network. 

    • 51 min
    The Murder of Noreen Boyle

    The Murder of Noreen Boyle

    Episode #53 // The Murder of Noreen BoyleOn New Years Day, 1990, police received a missing persons report for Noreen Boyle. Her husband claimed they had been fighting the night before, and she walked out of the house, and didn't come back. Days later, the husband would move into a new house with his new girlfriend who was pregnant with his child. Soon, a body would be discovered in the basement of the new home. Was this Noreen Boyle, and how did she get there? We are proudly sponsored by Two Beards Trading Post. Introducing high quality hand made beard oil and butter with 100% all natural ingredients, a light heart, and a bit of the novelty. Made in the USA! Click here to shop now, and remember: Don't shave it, shape it!We are also proudly sponsored by Thousand Fell, the better sneaker for tomorrow. Their sneakers are not only zero waste but are stain proof, odor free, water resistant, offer long lasting durability, and yoga-mat levels of comfort. When you're done with your shoes, simply mail them back for a free and your shoes will be recycled. New customers before January 1st can enter WELCOME10 for 10% off you purchase, and be sure to mention NYNM in your post purchase survey. Go to Thousandfell.com now! National Suicide Hotline # 1800-273-8255National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233  This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised. Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact. Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page, Instagram, TikTok and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future! We are proudly part of the Oracl3 Network. Find their website here. Patreon: Patreon.com/NYNM Facebook: @NYNMPodcast Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder Email: Notyournormalmurder@gmail.com Twitter: @NYNMPodcast For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here. This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved. Not Your Normal Murder is partnered with the Oracl3 Network. 

    • 49 min
    The Wholaver Family Massacre

    The Wholaver Family Massacre

    Episode #52 // The Wholaver Family Massacre In 2002, a mother and her 2 daughters would be found executed in their family home, having been murdered on Christmas Eve. The prime suspect was the estranged husband and father, who had been accused of sexually assaulting his daughters. But he would claim his innocence and had an alibi. Soon, his story would fall apart, and he would be arrested. In jail, he would be accused of placing a hit on his daughter's ex-boyfriend, and attempting to frame the ex-boyfriend for murder. Who really murdered the Wholaver family? We are proudly sponsored by Podcorn, a marketplace that helps podcasters connect with advertisers. If you are interested in advertising with podcasts, or are a podcaster looking for advertisers, go to Podcorn.com today!We are also proudly sponsored by Free Lunch Coffee. They offer coffee, mugs and tumblers. Half of the cost goes towards ending child hunger. Click the link here or search for Free Lunch Coffee, and use our discount code NYNM10 for 10% of your order now! Credit for the music during the ad goes to Ashamaluev Music. National Suicide Hotline # 1800-273-8255National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233 This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised. Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact. Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page, Instagram, TikTok and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future! We are proudly part of the Oracl3 Network. Find their website here. Patreon: Patreon.com/NYNM Facebook: @NYNMPodcast Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder Email: Notyournormalmurder@gmail.com Twitter: @NYNMPodcast For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here. This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved. Not Your Normal Murder is partnered with the Oracl3 Network. 

    • 49 min
    The Murder of Denita Smith

    The Murder of Denita Smith

    Episode #51 // The Murder of Denita Smith In 2007, Denita Smith was engaged to her dream man. But just a few days after her engagement, she would be shot, execution style, in her own apartment building. A maintenance worker would see a woman fleeing the scene. The woman would be identified as the lover of Denita's fiance. This woman would accuse the fiance of being the true killer. Who really murdered Denita Smith? Promo by Anxious and AfraidA podcast hosted by Abby and Shawna, two long-time best friends from the Pacific Northwest who love to talk about true crime, the paranormal, conspiracies, and everything in-between. Listen in as the girls switch off each week, telling each other a story that makes them feel especially anxious and afraid. We are proudly sponsored by Free Lunch Coffee. 50% of every order goes towards ending child hunger. Click here or visit FreeLunchCoffee.com and put in code NYNM10 for 10% off your first order! We are also proudly sponsored by Podcorn, a marketplace that helps podcasters connect with advertisers. If you are interested in advertising with podcasts, or are a podcaster looking for advertisers, go to Podcorn.com today! National Domestic Violence Hotline | Get Help Today | 1-800-799-7233 This episode may contain graphic details and strong language and may not be suitable for all listeners. Listener discretion is advised. Disclaimer: Any verbal opinion by the hosts of any person’s involvement with a crime who has not been found guilty by a jury of peers is pure speculation and should not be considered as fact. Make sure to comment and leave a review! Check out our Facebook page, Instagram, TikTok and Twitter and let us know what you thought of the episode. Also let us know what cases you would like us to cover in the future! We are proudly part of the Oracl3 Network. Find their website here. Patreon: Patreon.com/NYNM Facebook: @NYNMPodcast Instagram: Not Your Normal Murder Email: Notyournormalmurder@gmail.com Twitter: @NYNMPodcast For a full list of sources used for this episode please visit here. This episode was researched, written, and recorded by Mary Kiesewetter and Deirdre Teichman. Editing by Kevin Kiesewetter. Music credits to DanoSongs and Rob Chrisman. All rights reserved. Not Your Normal Murder is partnered with the Oracl3 Network. 

    • 45 min

Customer Reviews

4.4 out of 5
12 Ratings

12 Ratings

Tessa1109 ,

So happy to have found you both!!

Hi my name is Teresa, and I have a true crime addiction!! 🤣 I’m so thankful to have found your podcast to help feed my addiction!! While we all know the market of podcasts for true crime are bursting, with new ones popping up almost daily. That doesn’t always mean they are good quality and worth the listen. That’s definitely not the case here!! You ladies are great and I would recommend you to anyone looking for a new listen!!

RychJL ,

Great podcast

Mary and Deidra provide a great insight into the cases they cover. I listen to a lot of true crime podcasts and some overlap but these women have covered some I hadn’t heard before and with their educational backgrounds make this podcast like a documentary without picture. Keep up the great work ladies!

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Listeners Also Subscribed To