24 episodes

A podcast where we tell some lesser known stories of the past and present.

The Mysterious, Missing, and Murdered Matt and Mel

    • Society & Culture
    • 3.8 • 8 Ratings

A podcast where we tell some lesser known stories of the past and present.

    The Circleville Letters and Paul Freshour

    The Circleville Letters and Paul Freshour

    In the 1970’s a small manufacturing town in Ohio started to be plagued by an upsetting and mysterious series of letters. On this episode, we talk about the well known case of the Circleville Letters and the story of a man who went to prison for a crime he may not have committed.

    • 1 hr 2 min
    The Cowden Family Murders - Part 2

    The Cowden Family Murders - Part 2

    In the finale of this two-part serie, we take a look at the disappearance of the Cowden family. On Labor Day weekend in 1974, Richard and Belinda June Cowden and their two young children went camping in the Pacific Northwest and were never seen alive again. This case has been described as one of Oregon’s most haunting and baffling mysteries in the state’s history. What happened to the Cowden family?

    • 1 hr 22 min
    The Cowden Family Murders

    The Cowden Family Murders

    In this two-part series, we take a look at the disappearance of the Cowden family. On Labor Day weekend in 1974, Richard and Belinda June Cowden and their two young children went camping in the Pacific Northwest and were never seen alive again. This case has been described as one of Oregon’s most haunting and baffling mysteries in the state’s history. What happened to the Cowden family?

    • 48 min
    The Disappearance of Nicole and Arianna Fitts

    The Disappearance of Nicole and Arianna Fitts

    In early 2016, Nicole Fitts and her 2-year old daughter Arianna went missing in the San Francisco. In this episode, we discuss the tragic disappearance of these two and what’s known about the fate of Arianna and her mother.

    • 1 hr 9 min
    The Disappearance of Paula Weldon

    The Disappearance of Paula Weldon

    On December 1st, 1946, Paul Jean Weldon went for a walk in the college town of Bennington, VA and was never heard from again. The mystery of her disappearance would spark legislative change in Vermont that persists to present day. But her disappearance was neither the first nor the last in this small town.

    • 45 min
    The Life and Legacy of Ettore Majorana

    The Life and Legacy of Ettore Majorana

    This week on The Mysterious, Missing, and Murdered we divert from our usual formula and take a deep dive into the life and achievements of one of the early 1900's most influential physicists.

    • 54 min

Customer Reviews

3.8 out of 5
8 Ratings

8 Ratings

Drew Mittermayr ,

Super enjoyable!

I really enjoy listening to this podcast. I love both the hosts and I think they work very well together! I also like that you guys say where you’re getting your information from. I find that this podcast provides a lot more context then some of the other true crime podcasts I have listened to before. My only critics are that I wish Mel’s microphone was a little clearer and that some of the story formatting was stronger.

nicnec88 ,

The MOST enjoyable

Great listen. Like hanging out with buddies who happen to be conveniently super knowledgeable about interesting mysteries, missing persons cases and murder stories. 🙏

wahsekonesse ,

one of my new favourite podcasts

great personalities, great banter, and always an in-depth look into the most mysterious true crimes!!

Top Podcasts In Society & Culture

Stuff You Should Know
iHeartPodcasts
This American Life
This American Life
Soul Boom
Rainn Wilson
The Poison Detectives
Canada's National Observer
Roz & Mocha
Frequency Podcast Network
Inconceivable Truth
Wavland