True Terror on Tap

Joseph Behill, Gabriel Behill, Michael Behill
True Terror on Tap

Welcome to True Terror on Tap, the ultimate podcast for fans of the eerie and the macabre. Join us as we delve into the chilling realms of true crime, horror, creepypasta, lore, myth, and the paranormal. Each episode, we serve up spine-tingling tales and bone-chilling stories, all while enjoying a few beers to keep things lively.Whether you’re here for the darkest true crime cases, the most terrifying horror stories, or the spookiest paranormal encounters, True Terror on Tap has something for every fan of the frightful. Grab a drink, sit back, and let us take you on a journey through the shadows, where the only thing scarier than the stories we tell might be the next round we order. Cheers to the terror!New show from The Behill Network!

  1. 1 DAY AGO

    Phoenix Coldon and the Car Left Running

    Send us a text December 18th, 2011. A car’s left running in the middle of East St. Louis. Door open. Shoes on the floor. ID still sitting pretty. Local cops showed up, yawned, and said, "Meh, probably nothing." Spoiler: it wasn’t nothing. This week on True Terror on Tap, we cover the case of Phoenix Coldon—where lazy police work, a running SUV, and two missing hours turned into a mystery no one bothered to solve. We don't make fun of the victims. But the clowns who fumbled this case? Fair gam...

    57 min

  2. 17 APR

    Nature, Mistakes, and Missing Pieces

    Send us a text Tonight, True Terror on Tap takes you into battles no one planned for — and no one won. In Western Australia, soldiers armed with machine guns lost to a swarm of flightless birds. In Boston, a steel tank gave way, drowning a city block in a wall of molasses. In Sweden, the harvest season brought drunken moose staggering through towns, wrecking everything in their path. And finally In Toronto, engineers spent millions trying to outsmart raccoons — and failed spectacu...

    49 min

  3. 10 APR

    Maps, Myths, and the Hollow Earth

    Send us a text Tonight on True Terror on Tap, we take a hard look at the official story of Earth — and all the parts they quietly left blank. The maps were drawn. The flags were planted. History books were closed. But somehow, expeditions went missing. Flight paths disappeared. Entire regions blurred out, locked down, or just "forgotten" like a bad secret. Turns out, planting a flag doesn’t mean you actually know what’s under your boots — or what’s still moving u...

    58 min

  4. 3 APR

    Elisa Lam and the Cecil Hotel Part 2

    Send us a text Elisa Lam’s body had been found. The autopsy was signed. The headlines had already started to fade. But the questions? They were only just beginning. In Part 2 of our deep dive into the Elisa Lam case, we follow the investigation’s unraveling path — the missed searches, the rooftop access, the inconsistencies no one could explain. We explore the internet’s growing obsession with the case, from online sleuths crawling through hotel blueprints to travelers sneaking into the Cecil...

    59 min

  5. 27 MAR

    Elisa Lam and the Cecil Hotel Part 1

    Send us a text She checked into the Cecil Hotel and never checked out. In Part One, we head deep into the shadows of Los Angeles, where 21-year-old Elisa Lam vanished without a trace. Her last known moments — caught on an elevator camera — are disturbing, confusing, and unforgettable. Was it paranoia? Possession? Or something stalking her in that hotel? The Cecil has secrets, and Elisa’s story is just the beginning. https://www.instagram.com/trueterrorontap/

    55 min

  6. 20 MAR

    The Green Children of Woolpit – A Medieval Mystery

    Send us a text In the heart of 12th-century England, a bizarre tale emerged from the small village of Woolpit—one that still puzzles historians and paranormal enthusiasts to this day. Two children, with skin as green as fresh spring leaves, appeared seemingly out of nowhere, speaking an unknown language and refusing all food except for raw beans. Were they lost souls from an underground world, fae folk who wandered too far, or something even stranger? In this episode of True Terror on Tap, we...

    1 hr

  7. 14 MAR

    "Secrets, Scandals, and Star-Studded Chaos!"

    Send us a text You’ve seen the headlines. You’ve wondered, Who believes this stuff? Well… we do. And now, so do you. In this episode hear our take on those gloriously trashy tabloids you pretend not to read. Think of it as a loving homage to the Daria classic Sick, Sad World—just with more scandals, more conspiracies, and way more questionable journalism. (La la la la la! 🎶) This week? Power players in trouble. Hollywood’s burning—maybe literally. Secret societies? Oh, they’re here. And love?...

    1h 9m

  8. 6 MAR

    Inside the Life of Israel Keyes Part 2

    Send us a text Israel Keyes was unlike any serial killer we’ve ever seen—methodical, patient, and terrifyingly precise. In Part 2 of our deep dive, we pick up where we left off: Vermont, June 2011. Keyes had just arrived, retrieving a kill kit he had buried a year earlier, and searching for his next victims. What followed was an execution of a double murder that would later become the key to understanding his nationwide crimes. But the Curriers weren’t his only victims. We take you step by st...

    48 min
See All (33)

About

Welcome to True Terror on Tap, the ultimate podcast for fans of the eerie and the macabre. Join us as we delve into the chilling realms of true crime, horror, creepypasta, lore, myth, and the paranormal. Each episode, we serve up spine-tingling tales and bone-chilling stories, all while enjoying a few beers to keep things lively.Whether you’re here for the darkest true crime cases, the most terrifying horror stories, or the spookiest paranormal encounters, True Terror on Tap has something for every fan of the frightful. Grab a drink, sit back, and let us take you on a journey through the shadows, where the only thing scarier than the stories we tell might be the next round we order. Cheers to the terror!New show from The Behill Network!

Information

  • Creator
    Joseph Behill, Gabriel Behill, Michael Behill
  • Years Active
    2022 - 2025
  • Episodes
    33
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2025 True Terror on Tap
  • Show Website
    True Terror on Tap

You Might Also Like

To listen to explicit episodes, sign in.

Stay up to date with this show

Sign in or sign up to follow shows, save episodes and get the latest updates.
Select a country or region

Africa, Middle East, and India

Asia Pacific

Europe

Latin America and the Caribbean

The United States and Canada