153 episodes

Which Murderer talks about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer we would pick to kill us if we HAD to choose.
Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Gemma (the Scot) from Edinburgh, Scotland.
Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/)
Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer)
Explicit content and subject matter.

Which Murderer‪?‬ Which Murderer

    • True Crime
    • 5.0 • 45 Ratings

Which Murderer talks about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer we would pick to kill us if we HAD to choose.
Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Gemma (the Scot) from Edinburgh, Scotland.
Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/)
Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer)
Explicit content and subject matter.

    S3 EPISODE 40: Chainsaw Murders

    S3 EPISODE 40: Chainsaw Murders

    In Season 3 Episode 40 the girls talk about Chainsaw Murders – happens more than you’d think. Gemma starts you off with the gruesome murderer Jonathan Stasiuk before Holly tells you all about the sad story of Teri Lea Zenner and her brutal murder.

    Shoutouts for the fabulous band @Battalionofflies who are dropping their EP TODAY so go check them out, Dave who recommended us (including a minor dig at the Canadian co-host – watching you Dave, watching you) and Super Fan Natalie whose children have traumatized Holly with the passing of time. HI KIDS.

    Holly forgets how to podcast for the 194th time in a row, Gemma’s murderer had no regretsies, there are some amazing sound effects in the roundup and once again cookies are being eaten by someone who shall remain unnamed.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who once again has had his glory thwarted by the girls. NO GLORY FOR YOU PC.

    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who has been listening to Glory Days by The Boss for days now with tears in his little eyes. 0

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 24 min
    S3 EPISODE 39: Murderers Who Communicated with Police & Press

    S3 EPISODE 39: Murderers Who Communicated with Police & Press

    In Season 3 Episode 39 the girls talk about Murderers Who Communicated with Police & Press. Holly starts us off with the Lipstick Killer and Gemma then goes over the Smiley Face Killer.

    Holly tells tales of murder in the local zoo, Scottish weather is the worst, Gemmas insults Holly RIGHT BEFORE HER BIRTHDAY about her age, we all learn Holly has tried to get her fist in her mouth and Gemma has a pretty severe apple injury.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who is trying to burn the image of Holly putting her fist in her mouth out of his brain.

    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who is trying to figure out how to use a blow torch without it hurting.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 33 min
    S3 EPISODE 38: Ax Murders

    S3 EPISODE 38: Ax Murders

    In Season 3 Episode 38 the girls talk about Ax Murders – can you believe it’s taken 3 seasons to get here? – with Gemma kicking it off by telling us the tale of the Ax Man of New Orleans and Holly then going on to chat us through the South African murderer Henri Van Breda.

    Shoutout for Superfan Mel who is having a very busy apocalypse.

    A translator is brought in for Holly’s case but she totally ignores it and changes the first name pronunciation repeatedly throughout the story….as per usual, the girls share a brain when it comes to New Orleans, Gemma doesn’t understand Jumaji, Holly delays the start of segment two due to cookie crumbs and congratulations are given. To themselves. Well deserved.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who has given up on timers because nobody looks at them and why does he bother and like, do they even know how to tell time or have any idea what a timeframe is OMG.

    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who is now suffering PTSD symptoms from ticking clocks.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 33 min
    S3 EPISODE 37: Cruise Ship Murders

    S3 EPISODE 37: Cruise Ship Murders

    In Season 3 Episode 37 the girls talk about Cruise Ship Murders suggested by listener Jared Muppet (thanks JM!!!). Holly tells us about Tamara Tucker then Gemma covers the death of Kristy Manzanares.

    Shoutout for Sarah from the Facebook page/group.

    The girls become a TV Guide…you’re welcome, a scene from Titanic is reenacted (obvious reasons but also completely by accident), fines for Murder are introduced by the girls and cruise ships will not cancel holidays for your death. Just in case you were feeling important.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who probably won’t be booking a room with a balcony if he ever cruises. Just to be safe.

    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who also now wears a life vest and a helmet when leaving the house with Gemma.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 23 min
    S3 EPISODE 36: Bodies in Wells

    S3 EPISODE 36: Bodies in Wells

    In Season 3 Episode 36 the girls talk about murders which involved Bodies in Wells suggested by all three of Holly’s personalities. Gemma kicks things off with the story of Jessie McMahon who waited a long time to be found and Holly goes over the murder of David King.

    Shoutouts for Helen, Dave, Kev – much love to you all!

    Holly is missing Craigs hand-feeding methods, the girls give themselves bonus points for remembering their own episode, Gemma thinks babies drive forklifts, the French police prove absolutely useless beyond uselessness, Holly gets confused about secret police and motorways and there is some good energy.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who has ordered bite proof gloves for when Holly is allowed to record in the podcast studio again.

    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who has written to the maker of Percy Pigs and asked for a 5 year supply.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 26 min
    S3 EPISODE 35: Tinder Murders

    S3 EPISODE 35: Tinder Murders

    In Season 3 Episode 35 the girls talk about Tinder Murders – which does not help Holly’s reluctance to rejoin. Holly starts off with the sad tale of Grace Millane who died on her birthday, then Gemma talks about Sidney Loofe.

    Shoutouts for Jomya1989 who left a lovely iTunes review, Kyla on the Facebook page and Superfan Caitriona.

    The girls give their Christmas reviews (and a life update from Holly – send chocolate), science proves once again that pissed off or curious women make the best online Sherlocks, birds make a very strange appearance, everything is fine-fine-fine, Holly is avoiding penises and there is an update on the Michael Alig case.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Producer Craig who is one of the good penises.

    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who is changing the title of his autobiography on the horrors of working with the girls to ‘The Good Penis’.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 26 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
45 Ratings

45 Ratings

Davefaescotland ,

Murder most podcast

Started listening to Holly and Gem few months ago when I was quite ill and stuck in bed, and now every Friday is a little treat, the cases are so strangely engrossing, the girls wit also shines through, there are some strange people about and some truly gruesome murders going on, the hosts go into great detail about each case , how who and what , and then the girls pick which one they would rather have done to them..

Brilliant keep up the great podcast 👍👍

SazaB23 ,

My favourite podcast

Hey girls,

I love your podcast. I found your business card in PFG a while ago and now I’m obsessed. I love true crime and binge watch documentaries so your podcast is perfect.

My hubby and I used to listen to it on long journeys but when Covid hit we started listening in the house to make sure we didn’t fall behind lol.

Your sense of humour is right up my street. I reckon we would be 100% besties 😂

I’ recommend you guys to everyone who’ll listen!

Dani the Canuck ,

Road trip entertainment

Thanks Gemma and Holly for making mine and my husband’s long road trip fly by! Great podcast! You both gel so well ☺️

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Listeners Also Subscribed To