318 episodes

Which Murderer brings together two hosts who talk about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer they would pick to kill them if they HAD to choose.

Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Melanie aka Mel (the Scot) from Scotland.

Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/)
Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer)

Explicit content and subject matter.

Which Murderer‪?‬ Which Murderer

    • True Crime
    • 5.0 • 61 Ratings

Which Murderer brings together two hosts who talk about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer they would pick to kill them if they HAD to choose.

Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Melanie aka Mel (the Scot) from Scotland.

Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/)
Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer)

Explicit content and subject matter.

    S6 EPISODE 41: The Devil Made Me Do It

    S6 EPISODE 41: The Devil Made Me Do It

    In Which Murderer’s 41st episode of Season 6, the girls cover The Devil Made Me Do It Murders. Holly starts us off with the gruesome story of Michael Taylor, before Mel goes over the famous Arne Cheyenne Johnson case.

    Dr. Demi suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!

    In this week’s episode Mel is back from her own personal Disneyland - aka Liverpool - after almost killing her husband with cringe, there are graveyard tales from Holly and Rosie the podcast dog and there is a tongue mystery that needs solving.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who will be making Consulting Producer Craig fill in all graves before her future dog walks.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig wonders how he became a grave filler inner being ruled by a confused tyrant.

    Big thank you to all our listeners for subscribing, leaving fantastic reviews and sending in great theme suggestions.

    WE HAVE MERCH!  www.whichmurderer.com - CLICK ON THE MERCHANDISE TAB FOR A LINK!

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally).

    All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 27 min
    S6 EPISODE 40: Supermarket Murders

    S6 EPISODE 40: Supermarket Murders

    In Which Murderer’s 40th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Supermarket Murders. Mel starts us off with the story of Payton Gendron, before Holly goes over the Zane Michael Floyd case. . 

    Kirsty suggested this week’s topic - thanks so much!

    In this week’s episode the chiropractor finally gets some love and more work than he anticipated from Mel, the girls have some concerns about America, we learn a new word (cheeple) and special guest star Rosie gives her two cents.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who is putting Consulting Producer Craig up for President of the USA.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig figures out how to escape from the white house.

    Big thank you to all our listeners for subscribing, leaving fantastic reviews and sending in great theme suggestions.

    WE HAVE MERCH!  www.whichmurderer.com - CLICK ON THE MERCHANDISE TAB FOR A LINK!

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally).

    All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm. Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 34 min
    S6 EPISODE 39: Hitmen - They Murder

    S6 EPISODE 39: Hitmen - They Murder

    In Which Murderer’s 39th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Hitmen - They Murder. Holly starts us off with the old timey french assassin Charlotte Corday, before Mel goes gangster with the crimes of Jimmy Moody.

    Dave suggested this week's episode - we think because of TV but maybe just cause he’s a super smart guy. THANKS DAVE!

    In this week’s episode there is a bit of confusion at the start (on how to start), there are some more TV recommendations, turns out old timey French people liked a long name, Mel gets a but hangry and some heads are annoyed.  

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who has informed Consulting Producer Craig that he must now change his name to Consulting Producer Holly Melanie Rosie von Craig for a more professional feel.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig debates the ethics of having Holly sent back to the French revolution so she can get her head chopped off,

    Big thank you to all our listeners for subscribing, leaving fantastic reviews and sending in great theme suggestions.

    WE HAVE MERCH!  www.whichmurderer.com - CLICK ON THE MERCHANDISE TAB FOR A LINK!

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 26 min
    S6 EPISODE 38: Manhunt Murders

    S6 EPISODE 38: Manhunt Murders

    In Which Murderer’s 38th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Manhunt Murders. Mel starts us off with the manhunt for Raoul Moat, before Holly fills you in on the crimes and chasing of Christopher Dorner. 

    Holly suggested this week's episode - but she can’t remember why. And we can’t remember why.

    In this week’s episode there is head on car rage with technical difficulties, rogue sheep, royal rumours, very confused celebrity footballers and hostage fees are discussed. Both girls are not going to take much negotiation. Also there is an amazing blooper of Mel followed by her absolute panic which we have left in for your listening pleasure. And her rage.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who is holding herself hostage and demanding that Consulting Producer Craig bring her a Big Mac and do the editing before she will release herself.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig waits for Holly’s two brain cells to connect again.

    Big thank you to all our listeners for subscribing, leaving fantastic reviews and sending in great theme suggestions.

    WE HAVE MERCH!  www.whichmurderer.com - CLICK ON THE MERCHANDISE TAB FOR A LINK!

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally).

    All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 39 min
    S6 EPISODE 37: LGBTQ+ Murders

    S6 EPISODE 37: LGBTQ+ Murders

    In Which Murderer’s 37th episode of Season 6, the girls cover LGBTQ+ Murders. Holly starts us off with the case of Scott Johnson the genius mathematician, before Mel fills you in on the sad story of Daniel Zamudio. 

    Karen suggested this week's episode - thanks so much!

    In this week’s episode spring has sprung and the Easter Bunny is on his way….to be promptly eaten by Mel. The country of Switzerland is no longer safe either as she has learned of a special chocolate factory waiting for her….Holly meanwhile sounds like she is playing the bongos as she is hitting her mic so often (apologies - rest assured Consulting Producer Craig is rolling in his grave at the moment. He isn’t dead. It’s just the place to role when you are absolutely disgusted with someone.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who is waiting for Consulting Producer Craig to stop rolling in his grave and fix the sound issue.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig roles and roles and roles….

    Big thank you to all our listeners for subscribing, leaving fantastic reviews and sending in great theme suggestions.

    WE HAVE MERCH!  www.whichmurderer.com - CLICK ON THE MERCHANDISE TAB FOR A LINK!

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 25 min
    S6 EPISODE 36: Paranormal Murders

    S6 EPISODE 36: Paranormal Murders

    In Which Murderer’s 36th episode of Season 6, the girls cover Paranormal Murders. Mel starts us off with a story about the Hammersmith Ghost, before Holly terrifies you with the Greenbrier Ghost story.

    Emma Jo suggested this week's episode - thanks so much! It was a blast to research.

    In this week’s episode you find out that Holly quote, ‘loves paranormal shit!’, Jesus is claimed, there are some excellent TV recommendations, you are advised not to wear white and Holly wants to name your babies please.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who has asked Consulting Producer Craig to wear a white sheet to all future podcast recordings.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig puts a white sheet on the closest stranger and makes a run for it.

    Big thank you to all our listeners for subscribing, leaving fantastic reviews and sending in great theme suggestions.

    WE HAVE MERCH! www.whichmurderer.com - CLICK ON THE MERCHANDISE TAB FOR A LINK!

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 26 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
61 Ratings

61 Ratings

Reece212223 ,

So good

I struggle to get to sleep and this is so interesting I concentrate so much it makes me tired

What is…? ,

Light hearted

Which Murder? is such a good podcast, I could genuinely listen all day to this fun, lighthearted show!

Fee :)) ,

Great hosts

Great hosts and really interesting show!

Top Podcasts In True Crime

The Mushroom Cook
True Crime Australia
The Price of Paradise
Wondery
Intrigue
BBC Radio 4
RedHanded
Wondery | RedHanded
They Walk Among Us - UK True Crime
They Walk Among Us
Casefile True Crime
Casefile Presents

You Might Also Like

Our True Crime Podcast
Our True Crime Podcast
Crime Salad
Weird Salad Media | QCODE
MURDERISH
Cloud10
Crime Weekly
Audioboom Studios
Detective Perspective
Derrick Levasseur
The Murder Diaries
Cloud10