217 episodes

Which Murderer talks about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer we would pick to kill us if we HAD to choose.
Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Melanie aka Mel (the Scot) from Scotland.
Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/)
Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer)
Explicit content and subject matter.

Which Murderer‪?‬ Which Murderer

    • True Crime
    • 5.0 • 50 Ratings

Which Murderer talks about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer we would pick to kill us if we HAD to choose.
Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Melanie aka Mel (the Scot) from Scotland.
Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/)
Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer)
Explicit content and subject matter.

    S4 EPISODE 49: Honeymoon Murders

    S4 EPISODE 49: Honeymoon Murders

    In Season 4 Episode 49 the girls talk about Honeymoon Murders courtesy of the soon to be honeymooning Mel. Holly kicks things off with a very sad story about Welsh couple Ben & Catherine Mullany before Mel tells you about Scott Robin Rolston.

    Shoutouts to Kirsty (and Kristy of course) for a podcast recommendation and topic suggestion and Cheryl for the great laughs.

    Holly starts off by dying from not sleeping to which Mel quickly follows with her own fatigue, the English language is challenged in this episode (RIP listeners), a new word is invented, in Mel’s case people can apparently be blown off ships and the jury is out on how Mel's honeymoon will end.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who has taken a break from trying to steal Consulting Producer Craig’s brain to catch up on some much needed sleep.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig wonders why it’s so quiet and loses his mind waiting for Holly’s next master plan.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 38 min
    S4 EPISODE 48: Hospital Murders

    S4 EPISODE 48: Hospital Murders

    In Season 4 Episode 48 the girls cover cases of Hospital Murders which is a pretty terrifying thought! Even for them. Mel starts you off with the case of a very busy man named Charles Cullen before Holly tells you the French tale of Romain Dupuy.

    Shoutout to Kirsty (and by default Kristy) for this week’s theme suggestion as well as Cheryl and Kenda.

    This episode is full of pigeon apologies, detective puppies (with a legend of a Homicide Hunter shoutout), a firm rule that no tummies should be in the palms of hands, a chocolate factory recap and of course the usual gruesome details of the cases.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who is in the process of legally changing her name to ‘Consulting Producer Craig’ in order to create a bond with him.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig looks into changing his name to ‘Please Stop Contacting Me Holly’ immediately.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm. Talk of suicide and mental health issues in this episode.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 36 min
    S4 EPISODE 47: Murdered on a Night Out

    S4 EPISODE 47: Murdered on a Night Out

    In Season 4 Episode 47 the girls cover cases of Murder on a Night Out. Holly tells you the sad tale of a young woman named Jennifer Moore before Mel chats through the strange case of Lorraine Cox.

    Shoutout to Mel - by Mel - for her own suggestion.

    The girls start off teaching you about light before Holly lays down a highly scrutinised earth sciences fact complete with hand gestures, Mel laments her lack of interest in school, Holly fills you in on an Edinburgh icon she is emotionally invested in and names continue to trick the girls.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who met with Consulting Producer Craig (and Gemma) last week to explain the mystery of the disappearing segments to him.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig practices his shoulder shrugs in an attempt to communicate with Holly effectively.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 31 min
    S4 EPISODE 46: Kidnapped & Murdered

    S4 EPISODE 46: Kidnapped & Murdered

    In Season 4 Episode 46 the girls cover cases of Kidnap and Murder. Mel starts us off this week with the infamous and tragic story of Polly Klaas before Holly tells you about a murderer who inspired on of the greatest thrillers of all times - Gary Heidnik.

    Shoutout to Michelle for the topic suggestion and adorable puppy photos!

    Mel comes to you in her professional podcasting onesie with added distracting pom-poms, Holly fills you in on her new hobby which of course includes animals, Mel flat out refuses Holly’s inspired theme suggestion, Mel is distracted by stickers while Holly is trying to recount framing her Garry for murder and Silence of the Lambs is on this week’s viewing list.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who has an elaborate plan in place to kidnap but not murder Consulting Producer Craig to assist with the editing.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig tries to figure out why there is a chocolate bar with a rope attached to it outside of his front door.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm. Talk of suicide and mental health issues in this episode.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 35 min
    S4 EPISODE 45: Lockdown Murders

    S4 EPISODE 45: Lockdown Murders

    In Season 4 Episode 45 the girls talk about Lockdown Murders. Holly starts you off with the sad case of Kelly Fitzgibbons before Mel tells you about the story of Penelope Jackson and her rather unapologetic murder story.

    Shoutout to Caitlin for another great suggestion, Terry for the great feedback and the country of Kenya.

    Technical difficulties plague the girls from the start, Mel gets a happy surprise field trip, gun safety issues set off a small Melnado, the audacity of Mel’s murderer gives Holly the giggles and Mel fails on her research assignment concerning Wacky Races. Holly is oblivious.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who thinks Consulting Producer Craig should definitely be handcuffed to her for the next recording session.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig cuts off his hands for no apparent reason.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm. Talk of suicide and mental health issues in this episode.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 40 min
    S4 EPISODE 44: Solved Cold Cases

    S4 EPISODE 44: Solved Cold Cases

    In Season 4 Episode 44 the girls talk about Solved Cold Case Murders. Mel starts you off with the difficult to research story of Sara Lynn Wineski before Holly tells you about the murder of Krystal Beslanowitch.

    Shoutout to Jordan for another great suggestion - we did them all!

    The girls provide you with a comprehensive review of the Scottish Midge phenomenon - 0/10 do not recommend - before Holly offends Mel. With good cause. Geography strikes again and ruins Mels life, conclusions bring back the good old days for the girls and there is a very important debrief about a certain international incident.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who is perfecting her Consulting Producer Craig branded Midge Repellent.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Mel while Consulting Producer Craig finds out whether or not restraining orders cover product branding and marketing. His legal bills are astronomical.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 35 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
50 Ratings

50 Ratings

LorelieLee ,

Fantastic

Brilliantly gripping podcast, delving into murders by theme, with two fantastically witty and entertaining ladies ultimately deciding which of the ways they’d rather ‘go’. Hobson’s choice, certainly, but very entertaining. If you are slightly warped, like I, it’s a must!

loobylou91 ,

Which Murderer No.1 ❤️

I had never really listened to podcasts before starting with Which Murderer and now I love this podcast! The chat between Mel and Holly at the beginning is like having a catch up with friends, with a good bit of banter thrown in. Really interesting topics every week and well approached considering the gruesome subject matter. This has opened up the world of podcasts to me, but Which Murderer will always be my number 1 😁. Keep up the good work ladies!

clip go ,

My Favourite Podcast - Which Murderer

Mel had shared a link to the podcast from facebook - I thought I would give it a whirl - my first podcast I have ever listened too - just love it . Thanks ladies like your casual chat at the start - I like the fact you shout out to those that suggest themes (when it is me 🤣) Well done done 😄

Top Podcasts In True Crime

iHeartPodcasts and Glass Podcasts
Casefile Presents
Exactly Right
audiochuck
RedHanded
audiochuck

You Might Also Like

The Minds of Madness | Wondery
Erica Kelley
11:59 Media
Reach Freaks | Kast Media
PodcastOne with Law & Crime
Wondery