64 episodes

Season 6: ‘Sweethearts’ examines the unsolved cases of three teenage girls who were murdered in Victoria, Canada between 1990 and 1991.

Season 5: ‘Whiskey Creek’ is the untold story of a Halloween night massacre. Season 4: ‘Finding Amber’ follows the case of a Port Alberni woman who disappeared on July 8, 2022. Season 3: ‘Missing Michael’ is the story of Michael Dunahee, a little boy from Victoria, BC, who vanished from a playground in 1991 at the age of 4. Season 2: ‘Gone Boys’ follows the mystery of men who have gone missing in recent years on Vancouver Island. Season 1: ‘Where is Lisa?’ digs into the disappearance of 21-year-old Lisa Marie Young.

Island Crime Island Crime+

    • True Crime
    • 4.7 • 3 Ratings

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Requires subscription and macOS 11.4 or higher

Season 6: ‘Sweethearts’ examines the unsolved cases of three teenage girls who were murdered in Victoria, Canada between 1990 and 1991.

Season 5: ‘Whiskey Creek’ is the untold story of a Halloween night massacre. Season 4: ‘Finding Amber’ follows the case of a Port Alberni woman who disappeared on July 8, 2022. Season 3: ‘Missing Michael’ is the story of Michael Dunahee, a little boy from Victoria, BC, who vanished from a playground in 1991 at the age of 4. Season 2: ‘Gone Boys’ follows the mystery of men who have gone missing in recent years on Vancouver Island. Season 1: ‘Where is Lisa?’ digs into the disappearance of 21-year-old Lisa Marie Young.

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Requires subscription and macOS 11.4 or higher

    S6 E1 Soft

    S6 E1 Soft

    For three decades, Rhonda has wondered why someone killed her high school friend Kimberly Gallup. Kimberly was a young girl who loved the Kansas City Chiefs and Bon Jovi. Her death has a lasting impact on all who knew her.

    • 46 min
    S6 E2 After the Fair

    S6 E2 After the Fair

    Cheri Lynn Smith spends her days reading the bible and writing to her parents. Before she's killed, Cheri is lured away from her Regina home by a sex trafficker posing as her boyfriend. Not long after, a horseback rider finds her body in the underbrush outside of Victoria, B.C., Canada.

    • 40 min
    S6 E3 The Girl in Polka Dot Tights

    S6 E3 The Girl in Polka Dot Tights

    Melissa Nicholson’s badly beaten body is found on the side of the road.  Newspapers at the time describe her as "teen hooker #3", but her family only remembers her big smile, sparkly personality, and honey-coloured hair. The 17-year-old is last seen on the Victoria stroll.

    • 41 min
    S6 E4 The Stroll

    S6 E4 The Stroll

    Cheri, Kimberly and Melissa were all last seen on the stroll in downtown Victoria. The activities of the area starkly contrast the elegant image Victoria is trying to sell tourists. It becomes a fertile hunting ground for predators.

    • 43 min
    S6 E5 Boyfriends

    S6 E5 Boyfriends

    The men close to Cheri, Melissa and Kimberly, at the time of their deaths, are all potential suspects. Boyfriends, pimps, and sex traffickers, could any of them have wanted the girls gone?

    Subscribe to Island Crime Plus for early access to episodes, all ad-free.

    Coming Soon: Season Six, Sweethearts

    Coming Soon: Season Six, Sweethearts

    The year is 1990 and within about 12 months three teenage girls will be murdered in Victoria, B.C., Canada. Before they were found dead, all three girls were lured into sex trafficking with promises of love and money. Today, it's been more than thirty years since they were killed, and their killer, or killers, have never been found.

    • 2 min

Customer Reviews

4.7 out of 5
3 Ratings

3 Ratings

rsgthree ,

Addictive, enthralling, startling and profoundly sad

This is a well produced, captivating and empathetically thought out series of podcasts about unsolved cases of missing people on Vancouver Island. If you are interested in justice, you’ll be disappointed, as these cases are still open. However these stories need to be told, and the missing themselves deserve a better natural end, as do their families.

What this podcast does though, shocks me about what I now see as a small insidious underbelly of reckless human behaviour in a small area, which has allowed injustices. This has happened despite the vast majority of kind, compassionate neighbours, friends and families and good people on the island. How can the minority negative have such a hold over the majority of positives in such a beautiful place?

It’s all very thought provoking, and soul destroying when you take on the emotional impact of the huge life sentences handed out to the families of the missing. It’s time that those with information about the missing spoke up and did the right thing. How would you feel if this happened one of your family members and you got no justice?

Thank you Laura Palmer.

Top Podcasts In True Crime

The Price of Paradise
Wondery
Crime World
Sunday World
The Mushroom Cook
True Crime Australia
The Magdalenes and I
Steven O'Riordan
Red Room
Jenny Claffey
Intrigue
BBC Radio 4

You Might Also Like

Crime Beat
Curiouscast
True North True Crime
truenorthtruecrime
Uncover
CBC
Canadian True Crime
Kristi Lee | Canadian True Crime
The Burden
Orbit Media
Murder in the Hollywood Hills
NBC News

More by Frequency Podcast Network

The Big Story
Frequency Podcast Network
Parkdale Haunt
Emily Kellogg & Alex Nursall / Frequency Podcast Network
The Biggs & Barr Show
Chris Biggs, Jason Barr & Pastey Jamie / Frequency Podcast Network
Roz & Mocha
Frequency Podcast Network
Possibilities with Hina Khan
Frequency Podcast Network
Canada is Boring
Jesse Harley, Rhys Waters