- I Ain’t a Killa Podcast
- I Am A Killer
- I am a victim
- I Am The Defendant... Case Stories by Trial Lawyer Marques A. Ivey
- I Barely Got Here Podcast
- I Can Has True Crime?
- I Can Steal That!
- I Cant Make This Sh!t Up podcast
- I Care When You Do
- I Catch Killers with Gary Jubelin
- I Could Murder a Cocktail
- I Could Murder A Podcast
- I digress
- I Don't Care If You Find It Boring
- I Don't Like Mondays
- I don’t know tho
- I dossier del mistero
- I Felt Evil
- I gialli di Roma
- I Have a Hunch! A True Crime Podcast
- I Heart Jet Lynn
- I Heart Murder
- I Just Don't Have Time For
- I Know What You Did Last Podcast
- I Love You I Kill You
- I mean it's murder...but I like it.
- I Need Blue
- I Promise To Shoot You... If You Become A Zombie
- I Said God Damn! A True Crime Podcast
- I Should Totally Be Dead Right Now Podcast
- I Spy, Season 2 - Coming Jun 28
- I Survived
- I Swear Im Not A Serial Killer
- I Think My Fridge Is Haunted
- I Want All The Smoke
- I was HACKED!
- I Witness I.D.
- I Work With A Nightmare
- I Would Never Murder You
- I'd Kill to Quit
- I'll Tell You What...
- I'm David 1 2 And 3
- I'm Sorry...What?! The Podcast
- I-Real PodCast
- I-Scream
- I. GHOST
- IAFCI Presents... The Protectors
- IBLO ~ True Crime
- Ibrahim Crime
- Ice Crime
- Icelandic True Crimes
- Icepets Queen's CAMACOW podcast
- Icepets Queen's Maura Murray Podcast
- Ich habe überlebt
- Ich krieg Dich! - Verbrechen besprechen
- Ich sehe was, was du nicht siehst!
- ID ME
- ID Taylor
- Identity X
- Idk
- If I Go Missing
- If It Bleeds, It Leads
- If The Magnolias Could Speak
- If the Shoe Fits
- If the Walls Could Talk
- If You Catch My Grift
- If you go out in the woods today ...
- IfritCast
- Igor
- Igor El Ruso
- Ihmissyöjä
- Ill-Gotten Gains
- Illegal Tender
- Illuminatea
- Illuminaten & Zechpreller | True Crime
- Illuminati conspiracy
- Im Dunkeln – Der Fall Rebecca Reusch
- Im Schatten der Alpen
- Im Visier – Verbrecherjagd in Berlin und Brandenburg
- Im Zweifel für den Angeklagten
- Im Zweifel für den Angeklagten | Ein Podimo Podcast
- Imago Mortis
- Immortal Stories
- Imperfect Clarity
- Importancia De La Fotografía Forense.
- Improvável Podcast
- In A Nutshell Podcast
- In Casu
- In Cold Blood
- In Defense of Liberty
- In extremen Köpfen
- In Gruesome Color
- In het hart geraakt: wie vermoordde Els Slurink?
- In Justice We Trust?
- In Life and Death
- In Light of the Conspiracy
- In Memory of Mo
- In Our Thoughts
- In Plain Sight
- In Plain Sight Podcast
- In Reference To...
- IN SEARCH OF: MISSING IN AMERICA
- In Search of: Truth and Justice
- In Sight
- In The Car Podcast
- In The Dark
- In The Dead Of Night
- In The Hills Of
- In the Memory of the Goldfish
- In the Mood for Macabre
- In the Red Clay
- In The Shadows
- In The Slammer with Noel Razor Smith
- Inadaptados A Media Noche
- Incidental or Intentional
- Incognito Society Investigations
- Incorrectly Incarcerated
- INCRIMINASIAN
- Incriminated
- Incrimination
- Indelicates
- India Classified
- Indian Crime Story
- Indian Murder Curry
- Indian Murder Mystery
- Indian Podcast Company
- Indiana Appellate Opinion Summaries
- Indices
- Indicted
- Indieabrados
- Indigenous Injustice
- INDIGHOST PODCAST
- Indulge In Fear
- Indy Conspiracy & True Crimes Podcast
- Indy Justice
- Inequality in America
- Inevitability of conflict
- INfamous
- Infamous America
- Infamous Cases
- Infamous criminal
- Infamous Criminals
- Infamous Criminals 2021
- Infamous Individuals
- Infamous Indy
- Infamous Minds
- Infamous: Stories of True Crime and Urban Legend
- Infamy: Scandals REVEALED
- INFATUATED WITH BEING PARANOID
- Infernal souls and eternal arseholes
- Infierno Vacío
- Infinite Hope
- Infraction: A True Crime Podcast
- InHuman
- Inhuman: A True Crime Podcast
- Inhuman: The Monster of Cleveland
- Iniquitous Podcast
- Injusticias Contadas
- Inner Darkness
- Innocence Reclaimed
- Innocent Til Tipsy
- Inocente
- Inquirers into the Strange
- Insanely Criminal
- Insanity Defense
- Insanity in a modern time
- Insanus Podcast
- Inside a Wrongful Conviction
- Inside Crime with Angeline Hartmann
- Inside Crime+Investigation
- Inside Forensic Science
- Inside Homicide Podcast
- Inside Out
- Inside Stories
- Inside the Crime Files with Anne Marie Schubert
- Inside the Crime with Jenny
- Inside the Criminal Mind
- Inside The Criminal Mind
- Inside the Criminal Mind with Former FBI Profiler Andrew Bringuel
- Inside the Criminal Mind: The Whole Story
- Inside the Files
- Inside The Mind Of a Certified Psychopath
- Inside the People’s Mind
- Inside the Prison World
- Inside the Promo
- Inside The Wicked
- Insidious and Bizarre
- INSIDIUOUS
- Insolito - Nur ein weiterer TrueCrime-Podcast
- Insomnia Friends
- Insomnio
- Insomnio y terror
- Inspectie SZW
- Instead of Sleeping
- Instinto Criminal
- Insólito
- Intelligence Leak
- Intentional Ruckus
- Interesting If True
- Interestingly Random
- Intermountain PI
- International Infamy with Ashley Flowers
- International Unsub
- Internet Freakshow - Stories of Internet Mysteries, Trolls, Weirdos, and Freaks
- Internet Sleuths Podcast
- Internet's CreepyPasta & Dramatic Stories
- Interrogation
- Interrompida: o caso Araceli
- Interview With Evil: Ted Bundy's FBI Confessions
- Into The Abyss
- Into the Bullpen
- Into The Darkness
- Into The Deep
- Into The Fog
- Into the Hornets Nest
- Into The Lawful Mind
- Into the night murder mysteries
- Into the paranormal
- Into The Thick of It ~ Murder, Mystery, and Metaphysical Podcast ~
- Into the Unknown
- Into Thin Air
- Intothecrime
- Intramuros Podcast
- INTRIGA REAL - Felipe Garcia
- Intrigue
- INTRIGUES
- Intro to Crime and Mystery with Rachel & Company
- Intro: Mysteries (Un)Explained
- Introducción a mi 🌍
- Introduction 🙈
- Intruder Green Podcast
- Inuartoq by Sikkerninnguaq
- Invasion
- Investigates
- Investigating Gals
- Investigation and Evidence: True Crime
- Investigation Hour
- Investigation Station
- Investigação Criminal
- Invisible Chains