31 episodes

Tales lost to time about crime, mischief, and strange occurrences as told by sisters Cathryn and Elisabeth. Tune in and buckle up because things might get weird along the way.

Forgotten Stories: Historical Crimes and the Unusual Cathryn and Elisabeth

    • True Crime

Tales lost to time about crime, mischief, and strange occurrences as told by sisters Cathryn and Elisabeth. Tune in and buckle up because things might get weird along the way.

    #16 Redpath Murders

    #16 Redpath Murders

    This week Cathryn takes us out of the United States for the first time, to Canada! Join us as we seek the truth in the mysterious Redpath family murders. This story has elements of large creepy mansions and socially elite circles. At the end you'll have...

    • 30 min
    Honorable Mentions: Animals and Meat

    Honorable Mentions: Animals and Meat

    Elisabeth's honorable mentions follow a weird theme: animal and meat. She discusses a rare breed of cat-rabbits, a jealous poodle owner in Paris, a meat rain in Kentucky, and dog bacon. Cathryn tells the tales of strange deaths: a self-inflicted bladder rupture, a needle to the breast, and a shot off belly. Listen in for these strange and unusual stories.

    • 16 min
    #15 Jailhouse Murder of Annie Chaplin

    #15 Jailhouse Murder of Annie Chaplin

    This week Elisabeth discusses the case of Annie Chaplin. Young Annie tried to cash a forged check, but after being caught was sent to jail. In jail, things went from bad to worse and the people of Warsaw, Indiana could not believe the outcome of this crime.

    • 30 min
    The Prohibition Series: Part One

    The Prohibition Series: Part One

    This week's short episode is an Honorable Mentions spin-off where Cathryn and Elisabeth party like it's Prohibition. The episode starts with the making of a vintage cocktail, the French 75, then the girls discuss some Prohibition-era stories.

    • 19 min
    #14 Emma Crawford and her Moving Coffin

    #14 Emma Crawford and her Moving Coffin

    We are back in Colorado this week and Elisabeth tells the life story of a young Victorian woman, Emma Crawford. Emma died young and unfortunately she did not rest in peace. Manitou Springs still celebrates her life annually with a bizarre Halloween festival. Tune in to hear more!

    • 30 min
    Honorable Mentions: Wrenches for Wrenching

    Honorable Mentions: Wrenches for Wrenching

    This week Cathryn tells us about a boy who swallows an unfortunately large object, a decomposing body discovery and a man who battles a rattlesnake in a curious way. Elisabeth lightens things up with tales of several unusual people and a life-saving...

    • 17 min

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Listeners Also Subscribed To