Three Batter Rule 3 Batter Rule podcast

This episode was recorded on Bob Dylan’s birthday. It’s difficult to call him the favorite son of Hibbing, Minnesota, when you consider that it’s also the hometown of Chi Chi Larue, Robert Mondavi, and Kevin McHale, but we admire his contribution to the American tapestry nonetheless.

The public’s interest in seeing sports return cleaves pretty cleanly along partisan lines, as does so much else in our life. Is an objective understanding of anything possible these days? As we move deeper into the next normal, the fact that we are in fact at least two Americans on top of each other, each jockeying to be regarded as the real America.

We’re all in this together, as they say. But who is “we”? And what exactly are we in?

The beautiful thing about America’s game is the way that it keep reforming itself around what America is -- and who Americans are. African-Americans a generation ago, Latinx players today, Americans always, one and all. The sport has always been part of the “next normal” in this country and could be again.

But is even this fact too controversial to acknowledge right now? What are not allowed to talk about right now? When we’re among polite company, can we not mention the killing of unarmed black men? When we’re talking about sports, can we not discuss politics? Its often said that there’s no crying in baseball, which is obviously true. In an era where stadia are empty and hearts are breaking, how can we not talk about the obvious, deafening silence all around us?

David, Tom, and Tom fill the air with more questions than answers.

If South Korean baseball games rely on the noise of fake crowds, is the excitement real? Do the Yankees have real fans? Is Anthony Fauci one? Who gets to (or has to) go to work at crowded places like ballgames, college campuses, and prisons? Coronavirus has done a lot to us. What has it done for us? These and other questions will go asked, and some answered, by David, Tom, and Tom on this week's episode.

A plan to eliminate dozens of teams from the minor league system is a troubling development for many American communities already reeling from the coronavirus pandemic, among other ailments. Who is really calling the shots around here? 

Clayton Kershaw would like to be home with his firstborn while most Americans would give theirs for a chance to see some baseball. Can the country survive a year with out its great pastime? What do we get in return? Temperature checks and facemasks with our beer and peanuts? David, Tom, and Tom start to think about what we've lost and what we might get back when start to get back to normal, whatever that is.

This week, we mourn the passage of John Prine and are beginning to reckon with how a great many things are changing all around us, both on the baseball diamond and in the arena of politics. As the coronavirus crisis enters its second month, it's clear that "normal" isn't something we'll get back to -- it's something we'll have to create. Our batters discuss the response so far, and what it means for what's next.