10 min
19 - Panpsychism: "Show me the evidence!" Walden Pod
-
- Philosophy
We answer one of the more common challenges issued to panpsychists: some variation of “Show me the evidence.” We discuss whether panpsychism can be tested, our theory of mind module, emergence, Descartes's conception of matter, Occam’s Razor, and the fact that consciousness is always inferred, never observed.
“We can but infer sentience rather than verify it, and people will differ in their guessed inferences: some might stop sentience at the lobster limit, others might stop at the beetle border – but why stop at all? If one demands a stop, the determining criterion must be established.”
- Peter Sjöstedt-H
“How do the combined material objects that make up a human body change from a state of being non-conscious to a state of being conscious? There are three possible answers: i) They don’t. Human beings are not conscious. ii) A miracle happens. A conscious state ‘emerges’ from non-conscious matter. iii) They don’t. Consciousness already exists within the matter our brains are made from.”
- Tim Bollands
Can Panpsychism be tested? - Philip Goff [Conscience and Consciousness]
Emerson Green and Aaron Rabinowitz debate panpsychism on The Right to Reason podcast: https://player.fm/series/the-right-to-reason-2362355/panpsychism-debate
New music used with permission from ichika nito
ichika Nito’s YouTube channel
Transcripts available at emersongreenblog.wordpress.com
Rate the show on iTunes here
Support on Patreon here
or if you prefer to give a one-time donation, you can do so with Venmo (@emersongreenpodcast)
Listen to our sister show Counter Apologetics here
Subscribe to CA and Walden Pod on YouTube here
Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook
We answer one of the more common challenges issued to panpsychists: some variation of “Show me the evidence.” We discuss whether panpsychism can be tested, our theory of mind module, emergence, Descartes's conception of matter, Occam’s Razor, and the fact that consciousness is always inferred, never observed.
“We can but infer sentience rather than verify it, and people will differ in their guessed inferences: some might stop sentience at the lobster limit, others might stop at the beetle border – but why stop at all? If one demands a stop, the determining criterion must be established.”
- Peter Sjöstedt-H
“How do the combined material objects that make up a human body change from a state of being non-conscious to a state of being conscious? There are three possible answers: i) They don’t. Human beings are not conscious. ii) A miracle happens. A conscious state ‘emerges’ from non-conscious matter. iii) They don’t. Consciousness already exists within the matter our brains are made from.”
- Tim Bollands
Can Panpsychism be tested? - Philip Goff [Conscience and Consciousness]
Emerson Green and Aaron Rabinowitz debate panpsychism on The Right to Reason podcast: https://player.fm/series/the-right-to-reason-2362355/panpsychism-debate
New music used with permission from ichika nito
ichika Nito’s YouTube channel
Transcripts available at emersongreenblog.wordpress.com
Rate the show on iTunes here
Support on Patreon here
or if you prefer to give a one-time donation, you can do so with Venmo (@emersongreenpodcast)
Listen to our sister show Counter Apologetics here
Subscribe to CA and Walden Pod on YouTube here
Contact me at emersongreen@protonmail.com or on Facebook
10 min