Host Jimmy Smagula invites a guest to guide him through the stress of eating a food he has never tried before.
Jennifer Tilly Feeds Jimmy Grits
Jennifer Tilly feeds Jimmy grits for the first time. They also discuss being "stuck" in poker, performing in secret cabaret shows together and her love of theatre. Jimmy's mom struggles to remember what polenta is.
Baron Vaughn Feeds Jimmy Chicken Jalfrezi
Baron Vaughn feeds Jimmy Chicken Jalfrezi for the first time. They also discuss living In New York, the Spider-Man video game and Baron's bean experience. Jimmy's mom comes clean on her casino visits and her messy garage.
Shoshana Bean Feeds Jimmy Caesar Salad
Shoshana Bean feeds Jimmy caesar salad for the first time. They also discuss Shoshana's return to Broadway In "Waitress", her aversion to nuts and her mom's caesar salad dressing recipe. Jimmy's mom talks about her fear of dogs and airplanes.
Lizzy Cooperman Feeds Jimmy a Hard Boiled Egg
Lizzy Cooperman feeds Jimmy a hard boiled egg for the first time. They also discuss Kabbalah, reincarnation and The Ground Round. Jimmy's mother weighs in on eggs and a tornado watch.
Matt Ingebretson Feeds Jimmy Pad Thai
Matt Ingebretson feeds Jimmy Pad Thai for the first time. They also discuss, ABBA, what to do when Covid is over and how to act in a crisis. Jimmy's mother gives her opinions on her favorite treats and lo mein.
Melissa Fumero Feeds Jimmy Figs
Melissa Fumero feeds Jimmy figs for the first time. They also discuss growing up in Lyndhurst, NJ, getting a musical theatre education at NYU and Melissa's audition for Brooklyn 99 . Jimmy's mother tells us about her favorite soap operas and figs on a...
Customer ReviewsSee All
So much fun
This show is so much fun to listen to. Jimmy’s a really funny guy and listening to his conversations with friends about his picky eating habits are hilarious! I can’t get enough of his mom too, but I can’t believe how much she shielded him from so many foods!
Love this and can’t wait to keep listening!
A slice of wonderful every week
Waiting anxiously every week to see what other foods Jimmy has not eaten. A delightful and fascinating podcast.