Closed Primaries, Open Rebellion and The Supreme Court with Chad Peace

If nearly 50% of Americans identify as independent voters, why does our government keep getting more partisan? The answer, according to Chad Peace, isn’t apathy — it’s architecture.

Chad is the founder of IVC Media, a partner at Peace & Shea LLP, and the legal advisor behind the Independent Voter Project. He’s taken election reform cases all the way to the Supreme Court. And in this episode, he breaks down exactly how the system is rigged — and what we can actually do about it.

Key Takeaways

* Closed primaries are the root of the problem. In states with closed primaries and gerrymandered districts, a candidate can win with as little as 3% of the electorate. That’s not democracy — that’s a controlled outcome.

* Independent voters aren’t wishy-washy — they’re the majority. Nearly 50% of Americans now identify as independent. That’s not indecision. That’s a rejection of being told that every position you hold must fit inside one of two boxes.

* Political parties are private organizations — but they control public elections. The legal core of Chad’s work: if primaries are publicly funded and integral to our elections, can the state legally exclude voters who choose not to join a private party? He’s asked the Supreme Court three times.

* The system benefits from your disengagement. When you tune out, the pool of voters shrinks — and it becomes even easier for well-funded, well-organized factions to control outcomes with a tiny slice of the electorate.

* Competition is the antidote to money in politics. Chad’s counterintuitive argument: you don’t just need to get money out of politics — you need to make every dollar less effective by forcing candidates to compete for a broader, less predictable electorate.

* What’s next: a Top Four Primary for California. The Independent Voter Project is preparing to introduce a top-four nonpartisan primary for California — modeled on Alaska’s system — that would advance four candidates to the general election regardless of party affiliation.

Quotes Worth Sharing

“We’re simply asking the courts a question on behalf of individual voters: if primaries are an integral stage of the election process, can you exclude me from that process — that we fund — because I chose not to join a private association?” — Chad Peace

“The Republican and Democratic parties are like mom and dad saying, ‘kids, you can have whatever you want for dinner — as long as it’s from Burger King or McDonald’s.’” — Chad Peace

“They’ve devised a system that is literally designed not to represent you.” — Chad Peace

“Don’t get upset with the folks in the system — focus on the system you’re trying to change.” — Chad Peace

“When we don’t vote, when we don’t get involved — not only are we not putting our voice in, but we’re strengthening the opposition.” — Molly Ruland

“The system is like a gym membership where they actually want the people who sign up and never show up. You’re paying $29 a month and getting nothing — and they’re getting richer.” — Molly Ruland

Resources & Links

* 🌐 Independent Voter News: ivn.us

* 🌐 Independent Voter Project: independentvoterproject.org

* 🌐 IVC Media: ivcmedia.com

* 📱 Follow Chad: @chadpeace | @ivn

* 📱 Follow Molly: @mollyruland | @heartcastmedia

* 📬 Subscribe to this Substack for new episodes every week

🎧 Support the Show

What Do We Do Next? just hit 38,000 downloads — thank you! Every dollar from Substack memberships goes directly toward paid advertising to grow the show and get these conversations in front of more people.

https://substack.com/@whatdowedonext

Get full access to What do we do next? at whatdowedonext.substack.com/subscribe