25 episodes

What do a Muslim activist and a Catholic monk have in common? It’s not a joke, it’s a podcast.

We are two men with wildly different religious, political, and social convictions seeking mutual understanding. The point is dialogue--with some silliness thrown in.

DISAGREEMENT Umar Lee and Augustine Wetta

    • Religion & Spirituality
    • 5.0 • 23 Ratings

What do a Muslim activist and a Catholic monk have in common? It’s not a joke, it’s a podcast.

We are two men with wildly different religious, political, and social convictions seeking mutual understanding. The point is dialogue--with some silliness thrown in.

    Season 2 Episode 1: Umar Goes to Priory

    Season 2 Episode 1: Umar Goes to Priory

    Umar visits Father Augustine's Sexual Ethics Class and answers questions:



    What is Truth?What is Reality?What is evil?What is sin?Can god change the “rules” of ethics if he wants to?Are human beings basically good or basically bad?What is a human being/What does it mean to be human?Does the world need a code of sexual ethics?What is the role of women in Islam?How does the Koran define chastity and how does a Muslim man approach it?How does Islam approach the topic of artificial contraception?How does Islam advise homosexuals to be chaste?Do you believe that homosexuals should have the option of being legally married?How does Islam/the Koran address the topic of homosexuality?Are there elements of Catholic sexual ethics that you find off-putting or just plane wrong?Why did you convert to Islam?How do most Muslims think of Catholics (in your opinion)?Where (in your opinion) did Catholicism (and/or Christianity) go wrong?Is there anything you admire about the Catholic Church?What should America learn from Islam?Do Muslims believe in Hell?  If so, what sort of sins can land you in HellDo you believe that living with your intended spouse before getting married is justifiable?Why do human beings have bodies?

    • 38 min
    Disagreement Theme Song

    Disagreement Theme Song

    Father Augustine downloaded royalty-free Gregorian Chant (The Dies Irae) and Ramadan music, spliced them together on Garage Band, and here it is: the complete theme song--beginning to end.

    • 2 min
    Season Finale 3 (of 3)

    Season Finale 3 (of 3)

    In the exciting finale to the finale to the first season...the boys discuss great books, the World Cup, and America's lost moral authority.

    • 24 min
    Season Finale 2 (of 3)

    Season Finale 2 (of 3)

    The guys discuss the archaeology of Israel, how to eat dog, and inter religious dialogue.

    • 31 min
    Season Finale 1 (of 3)

    Season Finale 1 (of 3)

    Auschwitz, Antisemitism, and Israel

    • 34 min
    12.3 Umar Becomes a Traditionalist Catholic

    12.3 Umar Becomes a Traditionalist Catholic

    Umar and Augustine talk liturgy...and other things.

    • 31 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
23 Ratings

23 Ratings

Annie &Nate ,

Best podcast ever

I am thoroughly enjoying this. Educational, fun, enlightening, engaging, and entertaining. I am learning about Islam, but also more Dee my Catholic faith. Worth listening to from start to finish. Thank you Fr. Augustine for making this happen.

Dontgetthehate ,

A very fun, insightful listen

Found these guys because of Father’s appearance on Pints With Aquinas. Happy to have found the same thoughtfulness and sense of humor from him here, and enjoying hearing from Umar too! It’s really a blessing to listen to true dialogue in such a polarized, foolish time.

Mccordg86 ,

Great conversations!!

I’m on the second podcast and already love it! As an African American Catholic, I love that I can listen to the two points of view and identify with aspects of both men!!

Top Podcasts In Religion & Spirituality

The Bible in a Year (with Fr. Mike Schmitz)
Ascension
The Bible Recap
Tara-Leigh Cobble
Girls Gone Bible
Girls Gone Bible
In Totality with Megan Ashley
Megan Ashley
Standard of Truth
Dr. Gerrit Dirkmaat
BibleProject
BibleProject Podcast

You Might Also Like