Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer vs. Henry Lee Lucas | 229 Closed Cases, Three Real Victims, and a Strawberry Milkshake

Georgetown, Texas. Williamson County Jail, 1983. A small man sits in an office he is not supposed to be in. Fifty pounds underweight, bad teeth, a glass eye under a drooping left lid. In front of him: coffee, a fresh pack of Pall Malls, and a strawberry milkshake. Across the table, a sheriff. Behind the sheriff, file boxes full of photographs of dead women from twenty six states.

The sheriff slides a photo across. The man looks at it a while. Then he says yes. Yes, that one was mine.

By the time they stopped asking, police in 26 states had closed 229 murders. Families were told it was over. Detectives got commendations. The Texas Rangers who ran the tour were received like visiting royalty in every jurisdiction they landed in. Almost none of it was true.

This is the Season 3 premiere of The Fear Archive, and it is the story of a man who killed at least three people, confessed to six hundred, and in doing so became the single most useful person in American law enforcement. It is also the story of a film made for one hundred ten thousand dollars that frightened the Motion Picture Association so badly they buried it for four years.

Amanda and Mike walk the whole mechanism. The one room cabin in Blacksburg, Virginia. Viola Lucas. The eye, the dress, the 87 IQ. Otis Toole, the Jacksonville soup kitchen, and the Hand of Death, a satanic murder for hire cult in the Everglades that police searched for by helicopter and never found. Adam Walsh, and the grief that built America's Most Wanted. Becky Powell. Kate Rich. The arrest that started all of it: a weapons charge, nothing more.

Then the Lucas Task Force, and the detail that broke the entire thing. They did not interview him. They briefed him. Crime scene photos, autopsy photos, case files walked through in front of him, sometimes while he was medicated, and then the question. He could repeat specific, accurate, brutal detail back at them, and nobody in the room was tracking that they had put it in his mouth twenty minutes earlier. The number climbed from one hundred to three hundred to six hundred, and at the far edge, three thousand, which would require a murder a day for eight years in a thirteen year old station wagon.

The unraveling came from Waco. Vic Feazell, a young district attorney who actually read the file and convened a grand jury on the confessions themselves. Hugh Aynesworth at the Dallas Times Herald, the reporter who had stood in Dealey Plaza, who took the case apart with time cards and jail records instead of psychology. Feazell was later indicted on federal corruption charges and acquitted. The Attorney General called the investigation of him retaliatory.

And then Orange Socks. A young woman found in a culvert off Interstate 35 on Halloween 1979, strangled, naked except for a pair of orange socks. Lucas was convicted and sentenced to death on his confession alone, while a Jacksonville roofing company paycheck placed him in Florida. In June 1998, Governor George W. Bush commuted the sentence 48 hours before the execution date, the only commutation he granted across 152 executions. In August 2019, DNA gave her back her name: Deborah Louise Jackson, born September 20, 1956, twenty three years old. Her killer has never been identified.

On the film side: John McNaughton, a Chicago 20/20 broadcast, and a wrestling documentary that collapsed when the footage owner doubled his price, leaving MPI's Waleed and Malik Ali sitting on a budget. Twenty eight days in 1985 on 16mm. Michael Rooker in his first feature, in character on set and off for the entire shoot. Tom Towles. Tracy Arnold. The videotape sequence, and the rewind, and what it does to the person in the chair. The X rating, and Roger Ebert's observation that there was nothing to cut, because the problem was tone. Four years on a shelf, a lawsuit against the MPAA, a hand in the creation of NC-17, and then Scorsese handing McNaughton a De Niro picture.

Plus the sequel almost nobody has seen, Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer Part 2: Mask of Sanity, with Kate Walsh years before Grey's Anatomy. And Netflix's The Confession Killer, the docuseries that floats confabulation as the most persuasive explanation anyone has offered.

The episode closes with a thirteen point list of what is actually on paper, and with the arithmetic nobody wants: roughly twenty of the cases Lucas closed have since been resolved by DNA. Every one of those means there was a real killer, and he was left alone.

Hosted by Amanda Kagiwada and Michael Ryan Assip. Executive produced by Cassie Jozefov. A Violet Hour Media production.

LISTENER WARNING: This episode contains detailed discussion of homicide, sexual violence, child abuse, the murder of a child, animal cruelty, necrophilia, coerced and false confession, and capital punishment. It also describes a prolonged sequence of filmed home invasion, sexual assault, and murder. If you are in a bad place today, sit this one out.

Popular Topics Include: Fear Archive podcast, Fear Archive Season 3, Henry Lee Lucas, Henry Portrait of a Serial Killer, John McNaughton, Michael Rooker, Otis Toole, Hand of Death cult, Adam Walsh, John Walsh America's Most Wanted, Lucas Task Force, Texas Rangers Lucas, Sheriff Jim Boutwell, Williamson County Jail, Vic Feazell, Hugh Aynesworth Dallas Times Herald, Jim Mattox investigation, Orange Socks murder, Deborah Louise Jackson, George W Bush commutation, false confession cases, confabulation, The Confession Killer Netflix, Becky Powell, Kate Rich, Viola Lucas, Mask of Sanity, Chuck Parello, Kate Walsh, MPAA X rating, NC-17 origin, Roger Ebert Henry, Wilson Chouest, Shirley Ann Soosay, cold case DNA, true crime horror, horror podcast, Amanda Kagiwada, Michael Ryan Assip, Violet Hour Media

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices