7 episodes

A podcast about mysteries, hosted by Starlee Kine. From Gimlet.

Mystery Sho‪w‬ Gimlet Media

    • Personal Journals
    • 4.6 • 5.4K Ratings

A podcast about mysteries, hosted by Starlee Kine. From Gimlet.

    Case #6 Kotter

    Case #6 Kotter

    Jonathan has lunch in a cafeteria.

    • 1 hr 18 min
    Case #5 Source Code

    Case #5 Source Code

    While watching a movie, David notices a discrepancy.

    • 38 min
    Case #4 Vanity Plate

    Case #4 Vanity Plate

    Starlee and her friend Miranda get stopped at a red light and see something shocking.  

    • 42 min
    Case #3 Belt Buckle

    Case #3 Belt Buckle

    A young boy finds an enchanting object in the street.

    • 51 min
    Case #2 Britney

    Case #2 Britney

    Andrea's a writer no one reads. Then she makes a shocking discovery.

    • 49 min
    Case #1 Video Store

    Case #1 Video Store

    Laura rents a video. When she tries to return it the next day, the video store is gone.

    • 25 min

Customer Reviews

4.6 out of 5
5.4K Ratings

5.4K Ratings

Lillllll lõplik ,

Perfectly satisfying

I just found this in 2021 and I absolutely love every episode. I wish this had five seasons so I could keep listening! I love that each mystery has a solution. Each one is wonderful and I would honestly do alot of things to bring this podcast back.

Moocow14 ,

Listen again and again

I have just now listened to all the episodes in 2021. I imagine I will listen to these episodes again. My favorite has to be “Belt Buckle.” This is so well produced and Starlee Kine is a wonderful interviewer. Thank you for this gift.

touristinthecity ,

Light touch, sensitive investigations

Starlee was really a marvelous interviewer; she allowed the people she came across to be quite comfortable with her, even as I'm squirming in listening to it. I used to host a podcast and know how hard it is to get it done, and she did. If Mystery Show didn't have a sweet spot in that summer before Trump, it certainly hits it now.

Top Podcasts In Personal Journals

Listeners Also Subscribed To

More by Gimlet Media