94 episodes

We are two "mama's" who love true crime. Come laugh with (and at) us as we bring you new and interesting cases each week!

Not Your Mama's True Crime Jody & Caryn

    • Comedy
    • 5.0 • 9 Ratings

We are two "mama's" who love true crime. Come laugh with (and at) us as we bring you new and interesting cases each week!

    Ernest Christie

    Ernest Christie

    This episode was based on the story that Sam Christie told about his father, many years after it happened. Don't judge... this guy lived a nightmare none of us could imagine.

    Jody's book recommendation! Playing With Fire by John Glatt https://www.amazon.com/s?k=playing+with+fire+john+glatt&crid=3PO1X9VF088XL&sprefix=playing+with+fire+john%2Caps%2C1145&ref=nb_sb_ss_ts-doa-p_1_22
    Support the show

    • 43 min
    Herbert Baumeister

    Herbert Baumeister

    This week Caryn tells us about Herbert Baumeister, a killer that was never charged or punished for his crimes.Support the show

    • 23 min
    Ottis Toole

    Ottis Toole

    Jody covers Henry Lee Lucas' BFF... Ottis Toole. These men were cut from the same cloth.Support the show

    • 37 min
    Random Headline Crime f@cke3ry

    Random Headline Crime f@cke3ry

    Caryn gives us some really ridiculous crimes that are ripped right from the headlines. These shorties will have you saying WTF.Support the show

    • 38 min
    Henry Lee Lucas

    Henry Lee Lucas

    Jody discusses Henry Lee Lucas, the man who falsely confessed to over 600 murders.Support the show

    • 47 min
    Mary Ann Cotton

    Mary Ann Cotton

    Caryn discusses Mary Ann Cotton, the woman for some reason, had no luck keeping people alive... Or was it something else?Support the show

    • 45 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
9 Ratings

9 Ratings

DVilla813 ,

Can’t wait for NYMTC Thursdays!

I love listening to Jody and Caitlin’s podcast! They have such a great chemistry and they crack me up! Love that they cover varied topics and aren’t afraid to tell you how they feel! It’s awesome!

MissPink_22593 ,

Great Stories and Hosts!

I am loving this podcast! The hosts are sweet and entertaining and cover a diverse range of cases. Definitely a new favorite! :)

uselesstrivia1 ,

Up beat and entertaining

I enjoyed listen to the two host who both bring different perspectives to their respective cases!! It’s unique to get both a U.S. and Canadian take in different crimes. Can’t wait to hear more!!

Top Podcasts In Comedy

Morbid Network | Wondery
Jason Bateman, Sean Hayes, Will Arnett
YMH Studios
Team Coco & Earwolf
Full Send

You Might Also Like

Erin Fleming
Serial Killing
Rachael O'Brien | Morbid Network | Wondery
Big Mad Media
Our True Crime Podcast