21 episodes

How do three friends go out for a night and only one is alive?? 17 year old Molly Miller and 22 year old Colt Haynes were picked up by their friend Conn Nipp on July 7, 2013...within minutes Conn led police on a high speed chase through the backroads of Oklahoma. After driving into the woods, Conn ran home but Molly and Colt were never seen again. As the case unravels we learn that this is more than just a missing person case, the sheriff was arrested for drug trafficking and harboring a fugitive and he's related to Conn... A deep dive investigation into this devastating and shocking missing person's case by the television producers who produced a show about this case for the Oxygen network.WHO WE ARE: We have produced some of your favorite true crime television shows for Discovery, Oxygen, A&E and now we are going to do a deep dive investigation into the unsolved cases that have haunted us. We are going to pick up where our television shows have left off. We give you the inside and behind the scenes of true crime cases that we are obsessed with.WHO YOU ARE: Obsessed with true crime and you have your own string theories with a glass of wine and a pile of notes. We know that you know these cases just as well as us and we want YOU to be our partner in true crime!

PARTNERS IN TRUE CRIME: WHO KILLED MOLLY MILLER AND COLT HAYNES‪?‬ Rob and Cindy Dorfmann

    • True Crime
    • 4.8 • 134 Ratings

How do three friends go out for a night and only one is alive?? 17 year old Molly Miller and 22 year old Colt Haynes were picked up by their friend Conn Nipp on July 7, 2013...within minutes Conn led police on a high speed chase through the backroads of Oklahoma. After driving into the woods, Conn ran home but Molly and Colt were never seen again. As the case unravels we learn that this is more than just a missing person case, the sheriff was arrested for drug trafficking and harboring a fugitive and he's related to Conn... A deep dive investigation into this devastating and shocking missing person's case by the television producers who produced a show about this case for the Oxygen network.WHO WE ARE: We have produced some of your favorite true crime television shows for Discovery, Oxygen, A&E and now we are going to do a deep dive investigation into the unsolved cases that have haunted us. We are going to pick up where our television shows have left off. We give you the inside and behind the scenes of true crime cases that we are obsessed with.WHO YOU ARE: Obsessed with true crime and you have your own string theories with a glass of wine and a pile of notes. We know that you know these cases just as well as us and we want YOU to be our partner in true crime!

    EPISODE 20: THE PHOTOS

    EPISODE 20: THE PHOTOS

    World renowned Adventures with Purpose entered into the Molly and Colt case in 2021 at the behest of Toby Thomas, the owner of Battle Springs Ranch to investigate Moxley Pond.  Moxley Pond has been a source of interest in this case since Colby Barrick dialed 911 from that location in March of 2014 eight months after Molly and Colt went missing.  Doug Bishop, diver and investigator for Adventures with Purpose reveals what he experienced while diving Moxley Pond and gives his thoughts on the investigation.  In addition, we drop a never before heard recording of someone who saw too much, heard too much, and almost ended up just like Molly and Colt.

    • 1 hr 2 min
    EPISODE 19: THE WELL

    EPISODE 19: THE WELL

    Colt Hayne's cousin, Amber Nicole, broke her 9 year silence on this case a few weeks ago giving us an inside look at what her family has been dealing with this since Colt's disappearance.  Now that she's broken the ice, she's ready to reveal more about how she feels about how this case was handled from the beginning.  Having been family friends with Sheriff Joe Russell and working with him at the Love County Sheriff's department Amber has had enough and she wants some resolution to this decade long mystery.  In addition, we reveal for the first time one of the first ever tips that Paula and her family received weeks after the high speed pursuit.

    • 52 min
    EPISODE 18: THE LAW

    EPISODE 18: THE LAW

    The case of Molly Miller and Colt Haynes has been going on for over 9 years.  In that time, both Paula and various law enforcement agencies have been hunting down leads and looking for witnesses.  There has also been some headway in routing out some of the bad actors associated with the case.  Joe Russell was removed from office and Conn Nipp was arrested for a second high speed chase.  These have been small victories in exposing in this epic investigation.  However, in order to find, catch, and prosecute the killers they will need the law to put them behind bars.  Gary Henry was the district attorney for the 20th district of Oklahoma from 1995 to 1999, which covers Love and Carter County.  Gary reveals some unique insight into the community and the legal landscape of Love County.

    • 52 min
    EPISODE 17: THE RANCH

    EPISODE 17: THE RANCH

    When Toby Thomas bought a 3000 acre ranch in Love County he had no idea that his property could possibly be a crime scene, but it didn't phase him at all.  Toby is an entrepreneur and philanthropist with a keen sense of solving problems and the case of Molly and Colt is pretty big problem.  When most people would run away from that property Toby leaned in and hard.  His perspective as an outsider looking in is super valuable and his quest to find answers to this mystery is driven by being a father and local citizen who wants to help.  Toby has some incredible stories to tell about this case and he has only been living there a few years.

    • 1 hr
    EPISODE 16: SPEECHLESS

    EPISODE 16: SPEECHLESS

    Over the years the mystery of what happened to Molly Miller and Colt Haynes has baffled everyone...As our investigation deepens and we are uncovering the layers of corruption and the shocking details of their murders...we have had to employ the skills of professional law enforcement who are not involved in this case to get their perspective. We have released some shocking court documents and evidentiary  material to veteran CSI and homicide detective Jodi Barth for her analysis...wait until you hear what she has to say!!

    • 50 min
    EPISODE 15: ROAD TO JUSTICE

    EPISODE 15: ROAD TO JUSTICE

    For almost a decade Paula Fielder has been fighting to get justice for her cousin Molly Miller  who went missing in 2014... State Representative Jenny Graham understands what it is like to fight the system- Jenny's sister was murdered by the infamous Green River Killer and she fought for 30 years to get justice. On this episode, we have brought these two extraordinary women together and Jenny shows Paula ways that she can rock the system to get justice for Molly and Colt.

    • 1 hr 8 min

Customer Reviews

4.8 out of 5
134 Ratings

134 Ratings

flasarah ,

Someone knows

Someone knows something I can’t believe nothing has come out…and conn nipp just roams free 🤦🏼‍♀️

Isaybadwordslol ,

Episode 19

I don't agree that the evidence in the case handled by mr diggs was misplaced. It was possible murder case evidence. H didn't just stick it in his underwear drawers or in the closet. You don't just put murder evidence somewhere and then forget where you put it, misplace it or lose it! Not buying it!

Gladson101 ,

:)

The Dorfmanns are doing an amazing job telling Molly & Colts story!

You Might Also Like

gone cold podcast
MurderSheet
Wondery
Trembling Leaf Media
KARK 4 News and FOX 16 News
Dark West Productions