30 episodes

Scary mysteries, creepy folklore, and supernatural events with your storytellers Michelle Newman and Edwin Covarrubias

Scary Mystery Surprise Scary FM

    • Society & Culture
    • 4.8 • 43 Ratings

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Requires subscription and macOS 11.4 or higher

Scary mysteries, creepy folklore, and supernatural events with your storytellers Michelle Newman and Edwin Covarrubias

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Requires subscription and macOS 11.4 or higher

    Here Come the Men in Black

    Here Come the Men in Black

    Who are the Men in Black? Michelle tells the very real story of a man who offered them hot cocoa. Oh, and Edwin talks about his own alien encounter. 

    DM us on Instagram @ScaryMysterySurprise or email at hello@scarymysterysurprise.com - You can find Michelle on Instagram @michellealexis and Edwin at edwin.fm

    Scary FM's free newsletter is available at Scary.fm/newsletter and you can listen AD-FREE by going to scaryplus.com and testing it out!

    Production by Newman Media

    • 27 min
    It's Time to Pay the Piper

    It's Time to Pay the Piper

    The Pied Piper of Hamelin is based on real disturbing events in a Medieval town. Michelle knows all about it. Edwin thought life was all fairy tales.

    DM us on Instagram @ScaryMysterySurprise or email at hello@scarymysterysurprise.com - You can find Michelle on Instagram @michellealexis and Edwin at edwin.fm

    Scary FM's free newsletter is available at Scary.fm/newsletter and you can listen AD-FREE by going to scaryplus.com and testing it out!

    Production by Newman Media

    • 25 min
    Attack of the Killer Clowns

    Attack of the Killer Clowns

    As two survivors of the Clown Panic of 2016, Michelle and Edwin talk about how deep the clown sightings actually went, causing changes to law regulation and how it was responsible for violent attacks. 

    DM us on Instagram @ScaryMysterySurprise or email at hello@scarymysterysurprise.com - You can find Michelle on Instagram @michellealexis and Edwin at edwin.fm

    Scary FM's free newsletter is available at Scary.fm/newsletter and you can listen AD-FREE by going to scaryplus.com and testing it out!

    Production by Newman Media

    • 32 min
    The Ghost in the Machine

    The Ghost in the Machine

    Michelle started diving deep into the machine to get it to write a story for us using artificial intelligence. It told us stories live during our recording. Is this how it starts?

    ...or how it ends?

    DM us on Instagram @ScaryMysterySurprise or email at hello@scarymysterysurprise.com - You can find Michelle on Instagram @michellealexis and Edwin at edwin.fm

    Scary FM's free newsletter is available at Scary.fm/newsletter and you can listen AD-FREE by going to scaryplus.com and testing it out!

    Production by Newman Media

    • 28 min
    Top 10 Early Internet Scary Stories of All Time

    Top 10 Early Internet Scary Stories of All Time

    Do you remember your first encounter with the internet? For Edwin, this meant reading creepy stories that he thought were real.

    DM us on Instagram @ScaryMysterySurprise or email at hello@scarymysterysurprise.com - You can find Michelle on Instagram @michellealexis and Edwin at edwin.fm

    Scary FM's free newsletter is available at Scary.fm/newsletter and you can listen AD-FREE by going to scaryplus.com and testing it out!

    Production by Newman Media

    • 36 min
    Vampire for My Valentine

    Vampire for My Valentine

    Michelle argues that not all vampires are sexy. Then again, that depends on what you're into. Happy Valentine's Day!

    DM us on Instagram @ScaryMysterySurprise or email at hello@scarymysterysurprise.com - You can find Michelle on Instagram @michellealexis and Edwin at edwin.fm

    Scary FM's free newsletter is available at Scary.fm/newsletter and you can listen AD-FREE by going to scaryplus.com and testing it out!

    Production by Newman Media

    • 24 min

Customer Reviews

4.8 out of 5
43 Ratings

43 Ratings

ZeusOwnsMe ,

Hilarious and informative (at times)

This is a very funny and sometimes educational podcast. Highly recommended.

LoLoSmirnoff ,

Childhood fears

Michelle, Edwin thank you!! Honest sharing your fears made your whole audience think. I made a quick list of my top childhood fears. List doesn't go in order 1. The Blob- I didn't sit in back of movie theater till 16 2.zombies! Zombies!

secope1282 ,

So much fun!

This is a great show! Large Marge scared me too!!

Top Podcasts In Society & Culture

Kelly Ripa
Jennifer Welch and Angie “Pumps” Sullivan
iHeartPodcasts
Michelle Obama
The Free Press
This American Life

You Might Also Like

Scary FM | Sonoro
Scary Stories
Scary Stories
Cynthia Seer
3AM Scary Stories & Sound Talent Media
Max Ablitzer narrating scary stories from today's horror authors