166 episodes

Storytelling is as old as time and for some of us, the darker the story the more the intrigue. Scary Stories We Tell navigates the muddy trails of true crime, supernatural frights, and horror culture. Let us be your storytellers on this bizarre journey.

Scary Stories We Tell Weirding Way Media

    • True Crime
    • 3.1 • 21 Ratings

Storytelling is as old as time and for some of us, the darker the story the more the intrigue. Scary Stories We Tell navigates the muddy trails of true crime, supernatural frights, and horror culture. Let us be your storytellers on this bizarre journey.

    Reel Talk: Mothman Prophecies

    Reel Talk: Mothman Prophecies

    • 1 hr 34 min
    Haunted Iowa

    Haunted Iowa

    Chris, Emma and Dustin journey back into the backlogs, files, and stories of these United States with a return to the Haunted States series all about the state that borders the one two of the hosts live in: Iowa!

    You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd.

    For more episodes of Scary Stories We Tell along with many more podcasts that are guaranteed to be your new favorite audio obsession, check out Weirding Way Media at weirdingwaymedia.com.

    • 1 hr 46 min
    Lost Tapes Chronicles Finale: Reptilian

    Lost Tapes Chronicles Finale: Reptilian

    Chris, Jess, and Maggie bring their rewatch of Lost Tapes to a stunning and somewhat underwhelming conclusion with a look at an over-meme'd "cryptid": reptilians.

    You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd.

    For more episodes of Scary Stories We Tell along with many more podcasts that are guaranteed to be your new favorite audio obsession, check out Weirding Way Media at weirdingwaymedia.com.

    • 46 min
    The Reddit Files: Demons, Possesions, Spiritual Interactions

    The Reddit Files: Demons, Possesions, Spiritual Interactions

    Join Chris and Emma as they delve into the spooky world of r/paranormal and other user-submitted content over at Reddit with The Reddit Files.

    You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd. Don't forget to check out our official Facebook and Instagram pages for news, upcoming episodes, and more!

    • 59 min
    SurrealTube: Salad Fingers Ep 9-11

    SurrealTube: Salad Fingers Ep 9-11

    Chris and Emma are joined by artist Dustin Rutledge continue their newest series SurrealTube, a look at surreal, weird, and strange YouTube content, with a look at David Firth's Salad Fingers.

    You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd.

    For more episodes of Scary Stories We Tell along with many more podcasts that are guaranteed to be your new favorite audio obsession, check out Weirding Way Media at weirdingwaymedia.com.

    • 1 hr 17 min
    Lost Tapes Chronicles: The Beast of Bray Road

    Lost Tapes Chronicles: The Beast of Bray Road

    Chris and Jess continue their look at Animal Planet's found footage horror anthology series that often misses but sometimes lands its cryptids subject matter: Lost Tapes. This episode focuses on the Beast of Bray Road.

    You can follow Chris Stachiw @Casualty_Chris, Jess Byard @writerjessbyard, and the podcast @ScaryStoriesWT. Alex Malnack of Blondo provides the music for the podcast; that track is "Stay Here." The album artwork is provided by Maggie the Odd.

    For more episodes of Scary Stories We Tell along with many more podcasts that are guaranteed to be your new favorite audio obsession, check out Weirding Way Media at weirdingwaymedia.com.

    • 25 min

Customer Reviews

3.1 out of 5
21 Ratings

21 Ratings

StillAwake45674 ,

What ghost stories?

In the episode I listened to, they ironically speak about how they research and prepare for the show so they don’t end up just talking. Well, that’s all the episode turned out to be: talking about nothing. No ghost stories. Solid pass.

rchtu ,

Boring

Tried about four episodes and they speak endlessly about nonsense.

sfulps007 ,

Horrible

Just another stupid podcast with NO HORROR STORIES just the typical boring chatter about horror.

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Beyond All Repair
WBUR
Dateline NBC
NBC News
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Three
Wavland
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery
Status: Untraced
Tenderfoot TV & Audacy

You Might Also Like

Unexplained Encounters
Eeriecast Network
True Scary Story
Scary Stories
Jim Harold's Campfire
Jim Harold
Richard Hatem's Paranormal Bookshelf
Astonishing Legends Productions