5 episodes

Marcello and Margo do a deep dive into J. K. Rowling's iconic novels, discussing plot holes, inconsistencies, and general literary shortcomings- from a place of love!

The Critical Potheads Marcello Musumeci

    • Arts
    • 5.0 • 10 Ratings

Marcello and Margo do a deep dive into J. K. Rowling's iconic novels, discussing plot holes, inconsistencies, and general literary shortcomings- from a place of love!

    The Goblet of Glossing Over Inconsistencies, Part II

    The Goblet of Glossing Over Inconsistencies, Part II

    Margo and Marcello continue their foray into the fourth novel, discussing topics like wizard hygiene, government hierarchy, and whether or not J. K. Rowling is a fat-shamer.

    • 1 hr 26 min
    The Goblet of Glossing Over Inconsistencies, Part I

    The Goblet of Glossing Over Inconsistencies, Part I

    Margo and Marcello delve into the logistics of the Quidditch world cup, and debate whether or not Ron knows what a French person is.

    The Prisoner of Asinine Character Motivations

    The Prisoner of Asinine Character Motivations

    In this episode, Margo and Marcello discuss everyone's favorite episode, covering such important topics as galleon-to-dollar exchange rates, Sirius Black's questionable judgment, and Harry's limitless stupidity.

    The Chamber of Tropes

    The Chamber of Tropes

    In this episode, Margo and Marcello ask the important questions about everyone's second- or third- or fourth-favorite Harry Potter novel: the Chamber of Secrets. Topics include magical currency exchange, Wizarding justice, and many more.

    The Philosopher’s Plot Holes

    The Philosopher’s Plot Holes

    Marcello and Margo begin their journey into a deep and critical dive into the Harry Potter series. In the Philosopher's Stone episode (yeah, we used the British title) they cover such important topics as Wizarding educational standards, socioeconomic class, and more!

    • 1 hr 29 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
10 Ratings

10 Ratings

Stan G ,

Great fun

Easy listening and good fun (and funny) content. I had a great time listening and discussing with my girlfriend. A definite recommend for Potter fans.

officialLukeYoung ,

A Must for any Potterheads!

This podcast is fantastic!
It is a great mix of humor, insight and and true must for anybody that grew up reading and watching Harry Potter!
You won’t regret it!
Hilarious!

Top Podcasts In Arts

Fresh Air
NPR
The Moth
The Moth
99% Invisible
Roman Mars
The Magnus Archives
Rusty Quill
Snap Judgment Presents: Spooked
Snap Judgment
The Cutting Room Floor
OMONDI