23 episodes

On June 9th, 2009, in a sleepy suburban neighborhood, beloved family man, Matt Stewart, was viciously attacked in his own bedroom by an unknown intruder.

To date, there have been no arrests made, suspects named, or meaningful updates provided from the official investigation.

Nearly a decade later, an independent podcast series, UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart, began surfacing suspicious, never-before-reported, details about this brutal crime.

Through firsthand accounts from friends, family, and neighbors of the victim, and with commentary from nationally renowned experts, UNFORGOTTEN dives headfirst into a bizarre and complicated mystery that has never received the attention in deserves; the Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart.

UNFORGOTTEN : The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart BOLD-ERA

    • News
    • 4.4 • 412 Ratings

On June 9th, 2009, in a sleepy suburban neighborhood, beloved family man, Matt Stewart, was viciously attacked in his own bedroom by an unknown intruder.

To date, there have been no arrests made, suspects named, or meaningful updates provided from the official investigation.

Nearly a decade later, an independent podcast series, UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart, began surfacing suspicious, never-before-reported, details about this brutal crime.

Through firsthand accounts from friends, family, and neighbors of the victim, and with commentary from nationally renowned experts, UNFORGOTTEN dives headfirst into a bizarre and complicated mystery that has never received the attention in deserves; the Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart.

    The Third Circle

    The Third Circle

    Sheryl McCollum of the Cold Case Investigative Research Institute chats with Freddie about the importance of keeping cold case murders in the media. Amanda, Matt's former supervisor at the hospital, discusses Matt’s work life. Freddie reveals unsettling comments Matt's mother-in-law made to him over the phone.




    UNFORGOTTEN: the Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

    • 32 min
    Shephard Hill

    Shephard Hill

    Freddie and Steve(moderator of Unforgotten.FreeForums.Net) visit Gabriel Estates, the neighborhood where the murder took place. Freddie tracks down a former TV anchor who reported on the murder in the immediate aftermath. After months of failed attempts, Freddie finally connects with a woman who had lived down the street from Matt Stewart... who claims to have gotten a knock on her door in the early hours of June 9th, 2009.




    UNFORGOTTEN: the Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

    • 26 min
    Mirror Image

    Mirror Image

    Danielle, a woman who lived down the street at the time of the murder, dicsusses her experiences on June 9th, 2009, beginning with her hearing a knock at her front door.
    UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009\. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

    • 35 min
    Doorway

    Doorway

    Freddie explores an old family feud, and interviews Michelle, the neighbor whose house Matt's oldest daughter was staying on the night of the murder.  

    UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

    • 25 min
    In Confidence

    In Confidence

    Freddie speaks with a neighbor on Northland Ave, a few houses down from Matt and Angel, who claims to have had his window open on the evening of the incident. A family friend discusses her experience at Jean's house, in the wake of Matt's murder.

    UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

    • 31 min
    The Hutch & The Headboard

    The Hutch & The Headboard

    Freddie discusses 2 guns which were turned over to police in April of this year, as well as the gun's prior owner, who was questioned by investigators in the wake of Matt's murder. 

    We continue with “Lucy’s” testimony, and also hear from another of Matt’s co-workers at Lake Norman Regional Medical Center, as well as one of his first cousins.

    UNFORGOTTEN: The Unsolved Murder of Matt Stewart is an independently produced podcast series which takes a detailed look at the still unsolved homicide of Matthew Ryan Stewart; a 31 year old father of three who was murdered inside his Mooresville, NC home during the early hours of June 9th, 2009. The series dives into the strange facts of the crime and features exclusive interviews with the victim's friends, family, and neighbors, as well as commentary from experts.

    • 32 min

Customer Reviews

4.4 out of 5
412 Ratings

412 Ratings

Mob3dick ,

Just my opinion!!!

The mother in law is WAAAAYYYY to sketch.

I have never heard of this case or researched it so I do not know where the case currently is or if it’s been solved as of yet. But In my opinion I think the mother in law drove the killer (possibly the hunter friend) to the home, she took the milk inside or whatever just for a reason to have a reason to enter the home and then once she saw everyone was asleep gave the green light and went back outside to “sleep” in the car.. once it was done they were able to casually drive out of the neighborhood without suspicion. She dropped the killer off somewhere and then headed back. She had way too much information before information was able to be gained.
This would explain her reasoning to deep clean and discard things.. of course there was no forced entry because the mother in law had access to the home.
As for motive... I do not know. But it doesn’t take much of one I suppose.

The “dream”
The $300 phone call
The cleaning
The kill Matt but please don’t harm my daughter... shoot her stab her in a non lethal area so it’s not too obvious is sus.
Leaving the other child in the home is not only incredible but either selfish, irresponsible, careless, or not even concerned of the danger because it could have been an inside job.

No one knows how theyll act or react to these kind of situations but I never heard any remorse or anything from angel or her side of the story.. also don’t understand why the family wouldn’t want this solved and in the media.

Slbydt ,

Not great reporting

Freddie comes off as biased, as if he wants a certain outcome. Asks leading questions to people he interviews. Why was the wife not looked into on the first episode?

rioookjikod ,

I Lived two houses away

I actually lived two house away from this and remember it. There was also an incident at my neighbors home around the same time period. A described Latino male was discovered in the kitchen of my neighbors house in the early morning hours. He fled upon discovery and the police never found a suspect. Was that ever look into? I lived on Uberly Ct.

Top Podcasts In News

The New York Times
The Daily Wire
NPR
Law&Crime
CBC Podcasts
Serial Productions

You Might Also Like

Tenderfoot TV
discovery+
Without Warning Podcast®
Wondery
Mandy Matney
iHeartPodcasts