7 episodes

In 1974, a mass murder shook the sleepy waterfront town of Amityville, New York. One November night, police found the DeFeo family shot dead, face down in their beds. Only one survived: Ron DeFeo Jr., the eldest son with a troubled past. In this six-part series, host Donnie Wahlberg untangles the dark and complicated story of what happened that night, and unearths how these grisly murders sparked an infamous haunted tale.

 

Very Scary People HLN

    • True Crime
    • 4.7 • 2.5K Ratings

In 1974, a mass murder shook the sleepy waterfront town of Amityville, New York. One November night, police found the DeFeo family shot dead, face down in their beds. Only one survived: Ron DeFeo Jr., the eldest son with a troubled past. In this six-part series, host Donnie Wahlberg untangles the dark and complicated story of what happened that night, and unearths how these grisly murders sparked an infamous haunted tale.

 

    Episode 1: Small Town Murder

    Episode 1: Small Town Murder

    After Ron DeFeo Jr. finds his parents and younger siblings dead in their Amityville, New York, home, police begin to search for the killer. Host Donnie Wahlberg and local journalist Joel Martin revisit that horrific evening in 1974, the crime scene and the investigation — all in hopes of answering a question heavy on residents’ minds: “Who would murder an entire family in the dead of night?”

    To learn more about how HLN protects listener privacy, visit cnn.com/privacy

    • 27 min
    Episode 2: Meet The DeFeos

    Episode 2: Meet The DeFeos

    As the community reels from the shocking DeFeo murders, residents pack an Amityville church to mourn the loss of the family. Host Donnie Wahlberg dives deep into DeFeo history, only to find out that this picture-perfect family had very violent secrets.

    To learn more about how HLN protects listener privacy, visit cnn.com/privacy

    • 28 min
    Episode 3: Mob Ties

    Episode 3: Mob Ties

    As police continue their search for the killer of the DeFeos in Amityville, they discover the family’s connections to organized crime. Host Donnie Wahlberg reveals how these mob ties came to light. It’s a turning point in the case which brings police one step closer to their top suspect.

    To learn more about how HLN protects listener privacy, visit cnn.com/privacy

    • 28 min
    Episode 4: The Confession

    Episode 4: The Confession

    Amityville detectives shift all their attention to a single suspect in the murders of the DeFeo family: the oldest son, Ron DeFeo Jr. Following hours of intense interrogation, the sole surviving family member breaks. But Ron Jr.’s confession dredged up new details, complicated questions, and more secrets.

    To learn more about how HLN protects listener privacy, visit cnn.com/privacy

    • 39 min
    Episode 5: The People v. Ronald DeFeo Jr.

    Episode 5: The People v. Ronald DeFeo Jr.

    Nearly a year after the grisly Amityville murders, Ron “Butch” DeFeo Jr.’s fate would rest in the hands of a New York jury. But even in front of a judge, Ron Jr. was a chameleon; his story continued to evolve. One conflicted juror recounts the disturbing trial while host Donnie Wahlberg considers the question: Will the inconsistencies in Ron Jr.’s story spare him from life behind bars?

    To learn more about how HLN protects listener privacy, visit cnn.com/privacy

    • 42 min
    Episode 6: Everyone Loves A Good Ghost Story

    Episode 6: Everyone Loves A Good Ghost Story

    Found guilty of killing his parents and siblings in their home, Ron DeFeo Jr. is sentenced to six counts of second-degree murder. But the convicted killer finds new fame in prison. Back in Amityville, the story of the gruesome massacre at 112 Ocean Avenue is taking on a life of its own. Host Donnie Wahlberg untangles the story of how the Dutch colonial home that was once a bloody crime scene becomes a permanent piece of horror — and pop culture — history.

    To learn more about how HLN protects listener privacy, visit cnn.com/privacy

    • 35 min

Customer Reviews

4.7 out of 5
2.5K Ratings

2.5K Ratings

Katiecar88 ,

Seriously one of my favorites

The real question is when is season 2 coming out?! Seriously one of the best crime podcasts I’ve listened to, and would rank it close with Crime Junkies. 10 out of 10 would recommend.

Slewfootannie ,

Highly Recommend!

This was a fabulous series! Donnie Wahlburg is a stellar host and I’d love to hear more from him. I cannot recommend this enough!

omcortez ,

Amazing!

Perfect person to narrate!
Never would have guessed it was Donnie!

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Wondery
NBC News
audiochuck
NBC News
audiochuck
NJ.com

You Might Also Like

iHeartPodcasts
NBC News
iHeartPodcasts
audiochuck
ABC News
Cavalry Audio