169 episodes

Which Murderer talks about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer we would pick to kill us if we HAD to choose.
Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Gemma (the Scot) from Edinburgh, Scotland.
Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/)
Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer)
Explicit content and subject matter.

Which Murderer‪?‬ Which Murderer

    • True Crime
    • 4.9 • 28 Ratings

Which Murderer talks about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer we would pick to kill us if we HAD to choose.
Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Gemma (the Scot) from Edinburgh, Scotland.
Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/)
Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer)
Explicit content and subject matter.

    S4 Episode 2B: Journalists Who Are Murdered

    S4 Episode 2B: Journalists Who Are Murdered

    In Season 4 Episode 2 (Part Two) the girls finish talking about Journalists Who Are Murdered. Holly covers the twisty tale of Jake Lingle then there is a detailed debate.

    Mel kicks it all off by insulting an entire nation, Holly continues the mob theme from episode one despite hating mob murders, there is a big debate despite the method of murder being exactly the same in both cases, there is a discussion on all the mistakes in Hollys life and the girls are entering their seven year itch.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who asked Consulting Producer Craig to help with the big button machine but he didn’t respond. Maybe the fax machine is broken. CHECK YOUR FAXES CRAIG.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who as it turns out doesn’t own a fax machine. So rude.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 24 min
    S4 Episode 2A Journalists Who Are Murdered

    S4 Episode 2A Journalists Who Are Murdered

    In Season 4 Episode 2 (Part One) the girls talk about Journalists Who Are Murdered. Mel covers the sad story of Jill Dando in the first of this two part episode.

    Mel emphasises the best way to keep Holly happy, the girls decide gynaecologists are undatable, Mel makes a royal comparison, and Holly has to badly sum up this episode post-recording due to her being an idiot. EVERYTHING IS FINE.

    Production, recording and post production completed by Holly who despite thorough training from Consulting Producer Craig forgets everything the moment she’s learned it. EVERYTHING IS FINE.

    Holly edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who is programming his Craigbot to teach the unteachable Holly.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.

    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 24 min
    Season 4 Episode 1 Mob Murders

    Season 4 Episode 1 Mob Murders

    Welcome to Season 4 of Which Murderer!


    In Season 4 Episode 1 Mel and Holly cover Mob Murders - Mel's choice as Holly has terrible taste in TV shows. It all connects. Holly kicks off the episode with the story of Albert Anastasia before Mel tells you about Abe Reles.


    The girls discuss Holly's terrible brain, some new possible career options, an overview of Mel's extensive criminal history, there are some absolutely fabulous names and crazy case connections made between the two murderers.


    Production, recording and postproduction completed by Holly who has taken out a contract to have a microchip put into Consulting Producer Craigs head so she can talk to him at any given moment.



    Holly also edited this week. All complaints can be gently folded into origami as Consulting Producer Craig is more likely to open them then.



    www.whichmurderer.com



    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.




    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 29 min
    Season 4 Introduction

    Season 4 Introduction

    Welcome to Season 4 of Which Murderer!

    In the Season 4 Intro you finally get to meet this season’s new co-host – MEL!

    You’ll hear how she started off on this journey hating true crime and podcasts….look how that turned out. Almost as well as Holly saying she would never date again. There are loads of great cases lined up for this season so stay tuned!

    Production, recording and postproduction completed by Holly who is trying to convince Consulting Producer Craig to be on permanent Facetime.


    Holly also edited this week. You will find her shoving the complaints in the mail slot of Consulting Producer Craig’s door while whispering ‘help me’.


    www.whichmurderer.com


    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.



    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 4 min
    S3 EPISODE 52: Diagnosed Psychopath Murders

    S3 EPISODE 52: Diagnosed Psychopath Murders

    In the Season 3 Final Episode the girls cover Diagnosed Psychopaths Who Murder for Gemma’s final podcast appearance. Gemma chats through Robert Black before Holly talks about Jane Toppin.

    Holly has some nickname confusion, Gemma tells a horror story of note, Holly may be serving seconds when it comes to her murderer and the girls share a final tough choice at the end of this episode.

    Much love to Gemma and Producer Craig ss they start their next big project in life, we wish them all the very best and cheers to the last three years of murder.

    Production, recording and postproduction completed by Producer Craig who has finally gotten the union of neighbourhood cats to sign his petition resulting in his promotion to unpaid consulting producer.


    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who is under investigation for feline bribery. The girls will totally write to him in prison.


    www.whichmurderer.com


    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.



    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 35 min
    S3 EPISODE 51: Beauty Pageant Murders

    S3 EPISODE 51: Beauty Pageant Murders

    In Season 3 Episode 51 the girls talk about Beauty Pageant Murders with Holly kicking off her story of Svetlana Kotova before Gemma dives into her tale about Michaela McAreavey.

    Shoutouts for Sarah with a case suggestion and Woody over at Real Life Real Crime who helped solve a cold case murder recently. We are super impressed and proud and totally recommend you listen to him. And not just because of his melty voice.

    Time travel breaks Holly once again, the girls have a moment over Gemma’s second to last episode, there should be a thing called a cake passport according to Holly, Gemma totally misjudges a hitman, Holly finds out Gaelic football has nothing to do with speaking Gaelic during the game and THERE IS A HUGE APPEARANCE FROM PRODUCER CRAIG.

    Production, recording and postproduction completed by Producer Craig who has given up on flagging duties and is now misusing paper towels as flags.

    Gemma edited this week. All complaints should be sent directly to Producer Craig who is about to lose his paper towel sponsorship for not using it as THE GOOD LORD INTENDED.

    www.whichmurderer.com

    WARNING - Explicit language, content and themes (plus whatever else will cover us legally). All opinions stated are our own and case information was gathered from legitimate sources within the public realm.


    Pre-recorded in Scotland

    • 26 min

Customer Reviews

4.9 out of 5
28 Ratings

28 Ratings

jomya1989 ,

Which Murderer

I love the hosts! I could listen all day.

Dawgzout ,

Which Murderer is a hit!

I love Holly and Gemma and of course producer Craig. Very entertaining and well done?

SamKRN ,

My absolute favorite podcast!

I absolutely love these true crime ladies! As a nurse working during a pandemic, distractions are much needed. It’s the perfect length for my drive to work! I have been listening to this podcast for a while and I am caught up on all of the episodes, so this is my special treat every Friday! Thank you ladies for keeping me sane 😊

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Listeners Also Subscribed To