Scottish Murders Cluarantonn

In this episode, Dawn speaks with Naomi Channel about the latest developments in the Jodi Jones and Luke Mitchell case. Naomi reveals that newly obtained trial transcripts have surfaced, showing inconsistencies with previously released information. While Naomi hasn't fully reviewed the transcripts, she notes that some details may alter the context of the case. The discussion also touches on the divided opinions within the community, the impact of social media conflicts, and the upcoming parole hearing for Luke Mitchell.

For more details on the latest developments please visit to lmTranscriptdiscussion.blogspot.com

Call to Action:
Please consider subscribing, rating or reviewing this podcast as it really does help others find us. It's thanks to your ongoing support that we continue to be able to bring you Scottish Murders. 

00:00:00: Introduction and New Information on the Case
00:03:54: Divisions Within the Community
00:07:39: Potential Outcomes and Future Implications

Episode Credits
Hosted by Dawn
Special Guest: Naomi Channell
Produced by Erin Ferguson

TRIGGER WARNING - This episode covers the brutal murder of Jodi Jones and contains strong language, so listener discretion is advised. 

In this episode, Dawn and Naomi discuss the lack of a clear motive, the destruction of crucial evidence, and the public's divided opinion on Luke's guilt. Naomi shares insights from her extensive research, highlights what has kept this case in the public eye for over 20 years, and why there is a need for an independent review of this case.

Listen to Episode Four - Through The Wall: Seek Jodi, Find Jodi, Jodi's Hiding

Call to Action:
Please consider subscribing, rating or reviewing this podcast as it really does help others find us. It's thanks to your ongoing support that we continue to be able to bring you Scottish Murders. 

00:00:00: Introduction and Naomi's Initial Thoughts
00:01:02: Pathologist's Findings and Knife Details
00:02:45: Public Interest and Police Reluctance for Review
00:03:43: Luke's Decision Not to Testify
00:05:03: Jury Deliberations, Experiences and Majority Verdict
00:07:47: Luke's Alleged Motive
00:08:57: Luke's Behaviour in Prison
00:10:17: Length and Detail of Police Statements
00:16:03: Sandra Lean's Petition for Independent Review
00:21:14: Items Taken for Destruction
00:22:22: Essays by Local Drug Addict
00:25:10: Personal Feelings on the Case
00:27:12: Green Parka Jacket and Its Significance
00:28:10: Desire for Answers and Independent Review

Episode Credits
Hosted by Dawn
Special Guest: Naomi Channell
Produced by Erin Ferguson

TRIGGER WARNING - This episode covers the brutal murder of Jodi Jones, contains strong language and the topic of suicide is discussed, so listener discretion is advised. 

In this episode, Naomi reflects on the pivotal fifth episode, where new persons of interest emerged, adding depth to the investigation. Dawn and Naomi discuss the DNA evidence, including the presence of a local sex offender's DNA, and the overlooked peculiar behaviour of various individuals connected to the case,  raising questions about the thoroughness of the original investigation. The episode also touches on the psychological toll on Luke, and his resilience in maintaining his innocence.

Listen to Episode Five - Through The Wall: 'People of Interest
Listen to Episode Six - Through the Wall: 'Luke's Army
Listen to Bonus Episode - In Luke's Own Words

Call to Action:
Please consider subscribing, rating or reviewing this podcast as it really does help others find us. It's thanks to your ongoing support that we continue to be able to bring you Scottish Murders. 

00:00:00: Introduction and Episode Five Discussion
00:00:44: DNA Samples and Local Offender
00:02:05: James Faulkner and the Condom Evidence
00:03:10: Odd Behaviour and Admission
00:05:19: Crime Scene and Path Details
00:07:26: Joseph Jones and Mental Health Issues
00:09:24: Police Investigation and Persons of Interest
00:11:46: Jury and Circumstantial Evidence
00:14:20: Gordon Dickie and the Dogs
00:17:18: Cannabis in Jodie's System
00:19:29: Scrunchie and Clothing Description
00:21:20: Unsafe Conviction and Media Influence
00:23:43: Mark Kane and Similarities to Luke
00:25:48: Sandra Lean’s Involvement
00:28:20: Public Response to the Podcast
00:30:05: Matt Elliot's Documentary and Legal Issues
00:31:45: Luke's Prison Experience and Restrictions
00:33:29: Police Obsession with Luke
00:35:29: Luke's Early Prison Experience
00:38:38: Luke's Mental Strength and Support
00:41:13: Public Support and Podcast Impact
00:42:49: Comparison of Different Prisons

Episode Credits
Hosted by Dawn
Special Guest: Naomi Channell
Produced by Erin Ferguson

TRIGGER WARNING - This episode covers the brutal murder of Jodi Jones listener discretion is advised. 

In this episode, Dawn and Naomi go through some of the circumstantial evidence presented against Luke at his trial. They talk about the chaotic trial scene, the controversial decision to try Luke as an adult, the prosecution's reliance on eyewitness accounts and a missing knife, the questionable identification process, and the timeline discrepancies that cast doubt on the prosecution's case, and they discuss some of the lingering questions surrounding Luke’s conviction

Listen to Episode Three - Through The Wall: The Trial Begins

Call to Action:
Please consider subscribing, rating or reviewing this podcast as it really does help others find us. It's thanks to your ongoing support that we continue to be able to bring you Scottish Murders. 

00:00:00: Introduction and Overview of Episode Three
00:01:02: The Trial Begins
00:02:49: Details of the Trial and Charges
00:07:21: Eyewitness Account
00:13:48: Other Eyewitnesses and Timeline Issues
00:16:07: Jury's Verdict
00:22:17: Appeals and Potential Conflicts of Interest
00:22:38: Eyewitness Testimony and Its Reliability
00:24:57: Police Appeals and Investigation Gaps
00:26:11: Photo Lineup and Identification Issues
00:27:00: Burning Smell and Missing Evidence
00:28:33: Forensic Evidence and Its Absence
00:29:30: Parker Jacket and Its Significance
00:31:06: Discrepancies in Witness Testimonies
00:33:30: Shane's Testimony and Its Impact
00:34:02: Knife and Its Significance
00:36:24: Supporters' Views and Doubts
00:37:06: Police Investigation and Its Thoroughness

Episode Credits
Hosted by Dawn
Special Guest: Naomi Channell
Produced by Erin Ferguson

TRIGGER WARNING - This episode covers the brutal murder of Jodi Jones listener discretion is advised. 

In this episode, Dawn and Naomi talk about the controversial case of Luke Mitchell, a 14-year-old boy accused of murdering his girlfriend, Jodi Jones. They explore the details of Luke's arrest, the media frenzy that followed, and the ethical dilemmas surrounding the release of Luke’s name to the press. Dawn and Naomi discuss the police investigation, the handling of forensic evidence and potential motives. They also discuss the continued sensationalist media coverage the impacts this may have had on Luke, and the broader implications of trial by media.

Listen to Episode Two - Through The Wall: 'Scotland's Most Hated'

Call to Action:
Please consider subscribing, rating or reviewing this podcast as it really does help others find us. It's thanks to your ongoing support that we continue to be able to bring you Scottish Murders. 

00:00:00: Overview of Episode Two
00:00:19: Luke's Arrest and Initial Processing
00:00:33: Trial by Media and Release of Luke's Name
00:00:46: Luke's Movements on the Night of Jodi's murder
00:01:06: Ethical Concerns About Media Coverage
00:04:02: Police Search at Luke's Home
00:05:02: Early Suspicions and Labelling of Luke as a suspect
00:06:59: Luke's Involvement in the Search Party
00:07:27: Transcripts and Statements from Luke's Family
00:08:27: Changes in Statements Over Time
00:10:01: The Complexity of the Case and Human Nature
00:11:08: Police Focus on Luke as a Suspect
00:12:49: Delayed Interviews with Jodi’s Family
00:13:16: Lack of Clear Motive for Luke
00:14:31: Police Narrative and Media Sensationalism
00:16:45: Luke's Room and Personal Belongings
00:19:11: Knife and Other Items Found in Luke's Room
00:21:20: Prosecution's Evidence and Concerns
00:23:11: Time of Death and Forensic Issues
00:25:44: Luke's Time at the Police Station
00:27:10: The Talking Clock and Luke's Alibi
00:29:39: Credibility of Luke's Family's Statements
00:30:23: Disturbing Police Interrogation Tactics
00:34:12: Role of the Appropriate Adult During Interrogation
00:36:24: DNA Evidence
00:39:22: DNA on Jodi's Top
00:40:49: Luke's Interview with a Journalist
00:44:54: Luke's Visit to Jodie's Grave and Media Coverage

Episode Credits
Hosted by Dawn
Special Guest: Naomi Channell
Produced by Erin Ferguson

TRIGGER WARNING - This episode covers the brutal murder of Jodi Jones in detail, listener discretion is advised. 

In this episode, Dawn chats with Naomi, a seasoned TV producer and host of the Real podcast, about her extensive career in factual television and her foray into true crime podcasting. Naomi shares her journey from producing reality TV shows to creating compelling true crime podcasts, including a seven-part series on the controversial case of Luke Mitchell and Jodi Jones. Naomi discusses the complexities and uncertainties surrounding the case, highlighting the questionable police investigation and the fervent public support for Luke's innocence. The episode delves into the emotional and procedural intricacies of the case, setting the scene for a deeper exploration of justice and truth in subsequent episodes.

Listen to Episode One - Through The Wall: The Case Against Luke Mitchell

Call to Action:
Please consider subscribing, rating or reviewing this podcast as it really does help others find us. It's thanks to your ongoing support that we continue to be able to bring you Scottish Murders. 

00:00:00: Introduction and Welcome
00:00:14: Naomi's Background in TV Production
00:01:02: Balancing Multiple Roles and Teaching
00:01:52: Naomi's Interest in True Crime and beginning Podcasting
00:06:49: Naomi's Experience in Podcasting
00:09:01 Setting the Scene – Luke Mitchell and Jodi Jones
00:11:25: Trust in the Justice System
00:14:25: Questions About Jodie's Whereabouts
00:15:23: Luke's Alibi and Meeting Friends
00:18:21: Brutality of Jodie's Murder
00:20:03: Police Investigation and Handling of Evidence
00:22:42: Search Party, finding Jodie's Body and Police Treatment of Luke
00:31:03: Naomi's Reflection on the Case
00:32:29: Emotional Impact on Families
00:35:20: Conclusion of Episode One Discussion

Episode Credits
Hosted by Dawn
Special Guest: Naomi Channell
Produced by Erin Ferguson