145 episodes

Oh hi! Aimee and Aly here! We're just your "normal" midwest ladies who love true crime, the paranormal...and cats! On Horrific Heartland, we explore the creepy, the spooky, and horrific cases throughout the Heartland and beyond. Get your true crime fix wherever you listen to podcasts!

Facebook

Instagram

TikTok

Email us what case or ghost story we should cover next, horrificheartland@gmail.com

Horrific Heartland Horrific Heartland

    • True Crime
    • 5.0 • 1 Rating

Oh hi! Aimee and Aly here! We're just your "normal" midwest ladies who love true crime, the paranormal...and cats! On Horrific Heartland, we explore the creepy, the spooky, and horrific cases throughout the Heartland and beyond. Get your true crime fix wherever you listen to podcasts!

Facebook

Instagram

TikTok

Email us what case or ghost story we should cover next, horrificheartland@gmail.com

    The Murder of Marion Parker

    The Murder of Marion Parker

    TRIGGER WARNING!

    This episode is dark and depressing so listen with caution! December 15, 1927 was a normal day at Mount Vernon Junior High School in L.A. until a strange man walked in and convinced the school that he was there to pick up little Marion Parker.

    Who was this man and did he have connections to the Parker family? We discuss the timeline, the horrific events, and of course, the motive.

    Sources:

    Wikipedia
    LA Times
    Heathermonroe.medium.com
    Medium.com

    Follow us!
    Facebook, Instagram, Tik Tok

    horrificheartland@gmail.com

    • 38 min
    Love Triangles & Lies- The Murder of Forrest Teel

    Love Triangles & Lies- The Murder of Forrest Teel

    From the outside, Forrest Teel's life looked perfect. He's got a wonderful family, a nice car, and making good money as the executive for Eli Lilly. Not everything was perfect though, he was having a VERY long affair with not one, but two women.

    In 1958 his mistress, Connie Nichols, had enough and was ready to end her 15 year affair with him. That night, her gun accidentally went off killing Forrest Teel in his car. Was this really accident or was it self-defense?

    Sources:

    Indystar.com
    True Crime Discussions
    "In the Eyes of the Law" by Tom Faulconer


    Follow us!
    Facebook, Instagram, Tik Tok
    horrificheartland@gmail.com

    • 33 min
    The Storyville Slayer

    The Storyville Slayer

    This one is a doozy so listen with caution!

    Between 1991 and 1996 over 24 women were murdered and discovered years later in New Orleans. When the alledged killer, "Clay," calls in to the Howard Stern show in 1997, that's when pieces of this 24 year-old cold case starts to come together. Listening to the timeline, it will still make you question if "Clay" was the person who killed all of these women or was someone else involved.

    Sources:

    Wikipedia

    Cracked

    Reddit

    Huffpost

    CriminalMinds.Fandom


    Follow us!
    Facebook, Instagram, Tik Tok


    horrificheartland@gmail.com

    • 50 min
    The Murder of Heidi Firkus

    The Murder of Heidi Firkus

    Usually when you're struggling financially, you ask for help. That was not the case for Nick and Heidi Firkus. Heidi was a sweet and caring person who was very active in her church. On the morning of April 25th, 2010 in St. Paul, Minnesota, Heidi didn't make it to church. She was murdered. This week on Horrific Heartland, we discuss the timeline of what happened to Heidi. Her husband, Nick, says an intruder murdered her....but was that actually what happened?

    Sources:

    ABC

    CBS

    TwinCities.com

    20/20 "Stranger in the House" Season 45, Episode 27


    Follow us!
    Instagram, Facebook, Tik Tok

    horrificheartland@gmail.com

    • 48 min
    The Slave Master Murderer- John Edward Robinson

    The Slave Master Murderer- John Edward Robinson

    TRIGGER WARNING!

    It's a heavy episode this week as we talk about John Edward Robinson, aka The Slave Master. Between 1984 to 2000, he had over 8 victims in Kansas City, MO. We talk about his past, his MO, and how he used the internet to murder.

    Sources:

    Wikipedia

    Investigation Discovery

    The Crime Wire

    ABC News


    Follow us!

    Facebook, Instagram, Tik Tok

    horrificheartland@gmail.com

    • 39 min
    The Case of Kristin Smart

    The Case of Kristin Smart

    We're heading out of the Heartland this week and into California to cover a case Aly has been watching for a long time!

    On May 25, 1996 Kristin Smart, a student at Cal Poly in San Luis Obispo, CA, goes to a party off-campus. She appears to be intoxicated and one person at the party offers to help her back to the dorms. That person was Paul Flores. We talk about the timeline of the case and what led to Paul's arrest.

    Sources:

    Your Own Backyard Podcast

    FBI.gov

    ABC News

    NY Times

    Wikipedia


    Follow us!

    Facebook, Tik Tok, Instagram

    horrificheartland@gmail.com

    • 35 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
1 Rating

1 Rating

Top Podcasts In True Crime

The Price of Paradise
Wondery
Dateline NBC
NBC News
Status: Untraced
Tenderfoot TV & Audacy
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Island Crime
Laura Palmer / Frequency Podcast Network
Murder in the Hollywood Hills
NBC News

You Might Also Like

Scandal Sheets
Scandal Sheets
Your Spooky Neighbors
Your Spooky Neighbors
Unsolved Mysteries Rewind
Unsolved Mysteries Rewind
Going West: True Crime
Dark West Productions
Crime Salad
Weird Salad Media | QCODE
True Crime Garage
TRUE CRIME GARAGE