Dead End: A New Jersey Political Murder Mystery WNYC

On a quiet cul-de-sac, a husband and wife of 47 years are stabbed to death in the stillness of dawn. Honest and unassuming, John Sheridan, famous for never raising his voice, played against type in the rough-and-tumble world of New Jersey politics. Could the Republican lobbyist have killed his wife Joyce—a veteran public school teacher and no-nonsense mother of four sons—then set their bedroom on fire before knifing himself? That’s the version of events authorities say happened in the early morning hours of September 28, 2014. But, in more ways than one, the theory doesn’t add up.
Key voices interviewed in episode:
Christine Todd Whitman, former Governor
Chris Stevens, Joyce Sheridan’s best friend
Bob Stevens, husband of Chris’ Stevens
Mark Sheridan, eldest of the Sheridans’ four sons, lawyer for Governor Chris Christie's campaign and for the state Republican party for more than a decade
Peter Sheridan, John’s younger brother and federal judge in Trenton since 2005
Mary Kay Roberts, hired by John Sheridan at Riker Danzig, a New Jersey law firm. Worked with him closely for a decade in the Trenton office
John Farmer, a former state Attorney General and friend of John Sheridan who runs a political research center at Rutgers University

The Sheridans’ eldest son Mark is consumed with getting to the bottom of what happened to his parents. As the lawyer for Governor Chris Christie’s election campaign, Mark is in a unique position to uncover answers. Instead, he’s met with roadblock after roadblock. The questions really pile up when he learns that detectives haven’t even interviewed several key witnesses or completed a thorough investigation of the crime scene. Not only that, a key piece of evidence is missing.
New voices interviewed in episode:
Barry Jansen, retired forensic technician for the Somerset County Prosecutor's Office
Tom Draper, Sheridans’ neighbor
Michael Baden, medical examiner hired by the Sheridan brothers

The knife used to kill John Sheridan is just the first of many clues casting doubt on law enforcement’s conclusion of murder suicide. A newspaper crime reporter, a veteran homicide detective out of Philly, and a whistleblower point to significant pieces of evidence that have been disregarded—even thrown into a dumpster. Although Mark has the state attorney general and the county prosecutor on direct dial, he still gets stonewalled. The authorities assure the political insider that his parents had a dark secret, which will eventually come to light. Mark isn’t convinced. Instead, as he goes through his parent’s papers, he stumbles into a different fight.
New voices interviewed in episode:
• Barbara Boyer, reporter from the Philadelphia Inquirer
• Eddie Rocks, veteran homicide detective, retired from the Philadelphia police.
• Lawrence Kobilinski, professor emeritus, department of sciences at John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New York
• Professor Keith Taylor, professor, Department of Law, Police Science and Criminal Justice Administration, John Jay College of Criminal Justice (and a former NYPD detective)

After it becomes clear the Somerset county prosecutor’s office couldn’t have done a worse job (unless their goal was to destroy the crime scene), some 200 prominent citizens send a letter to the state attorney general asking for his office to intervene in the investigation. Despite the letter signed by the biggest names in New Jersey legal circles—including two former attorneys general and three former governors—the attorney general never gets involved. The quest to find out why takes us through a brief history of problems in New Jersey's criminal justice system.

John Sheridan’s decision to go work at Cooper University Hospital came at a curious time. It was just months after news about the Palmyra tapes came out. The tapes caught George Norcross bullying and offering a favor to a small town official; they are a rare instance where evidence emerged of the rough and tumble side to the south Jersey political machine. An email shows Norcross' control over the state legislature and city council members in Camden explain what it means to be a "yes yes" person.
• Kelly Francis, union organizer and Camden activist
• Kevin Riordan, Philadelphia Inquirer reporter who has covered south Jersey off and on for the past 45 years
• Micah Rasmussen, director of Rebovich Institute for New Jersey Politics at Ryder University
• Tom Knoche, lecturer at Rutgers University in Camden
• Matt Katz, reporter at WNYC
• Shaneka Boucher, Camden City Councilwoman
• Marilyn Torres, Camden City Councilwoman
• Jeffrey Brenner, doctor who worked and lived in Camden during its worst years

A couple months after his parents’ deaths, Mark Sheridan comes across a paper trail: extensive email exchanges, dated memos, and handwritten notes detailing a real estate deal on the Camden waterfront. His father, John Sheridan, wrote himself a note on an envelope: “I have a duty of loyalty and good faith and I need to act in a way consistent with that responsibility." How did John act and what impact did it have?
New voice interviewed in episode:
• Jeff Pillets, an investigative reporter who spent a year at the Bergen Record looking at George Norcross and his insurance business