- I Heart Wrestling Podcast
- I Know It's Not Real, But That Had To Hurt
- I Love `80s Wrestling Podcast
- I love wrestling podcast
- ICOPOD
- Idiot's Lists of Pro Wrestling
- If You Smell What The ARCH Is Cookin!!
- Igjjjk
- IHJW Wrestling Podcast
- IHWE Radio
- IkeTagon.com | Ike Feldman
- Illini Wrestling Podcast
- Immovable Objects: A Classic Wrestling Podcast
- Imp's LOP Radio Adventure
- Impact Oversell
- IMPACTful
- Impacto Estelar
- Imperial Wrestling Podcast
- Impressions of Wrestling with Jason Sensation
- In and Out of the Ring
- In The Cage MMA Radio
- In The Fight
- In The Hot Seat
- In The Kliq (Pro Wrestling Podcast)
- In The Ring With Christine
- In the ring with MADISON
- In The Ring With Pride
- In This Ring Wrestling Podcast
- In Your Head Wrestling
- In Your House Podcast
- In Your Howse
- Independent Waters
- InDepthProWrestling
- Indian Silverbacks
- Indie Wrestling Rules
- Indy Fanatics Podcast
- Indy Handshake: A Wrestling Podcast
- Indy Promotion Big League Budget
- Indy Wrestle Talk
- Indy Wrestling is Dead
- Indyhorsemen
- INF0R Wrestling
- Informações do Octógono
- Inside of the Squared Circle
- Inside Position
- Inside the Artists Studio
- Inside The Box
- Inside the Clinch : MMA Podcast
- Inside the Hexagon
- Inside The Maniac
- Inside the Promo
- Inside The Ropes
- Inside The Square: The wrestling podcast
- Inside Virginia Tech Wrestling
- Insiders Edge
- Insiders Pro Wrestling
- Insight with Chris Van Vliet
- Inspire A.D. – Behind The Curtain of the Texas Indie Pro Wrestling Standard
- Instant Classic Wrestling Podcast
- Instinct Culture by Denise Salcedo
- International Wrestling Impact
- Internet Phantoms Network
- Into The Danger Zone w/ Chris Denker
- Into the Nitroverse
- Into The Ropes: Your Pro Wrestling Escape Podcast
- Intro
- INVITACION ENTREVISTA ANUBIS
- Ipponcast
- Irish Whip Podcast
- Iron-On Wrestling with Gregory Iron
- Is It A Classic?
- Is It Shane Richie? The Adventures of a Wrestling Journeyman.
- It Doesn't Matter What We Call This!
- It Doesn’t Matter What We Call This!
- It Takes A Team Podcast
- It's All About Storytelling 🧐🧐
- It's All Wrestling
- It's Boss Time!
- It's Evolution, Baby!
- It's Hughezy, Hello!
- It's My House Podcast
- It's My Wrestling Podcast
- It's Our House Pod
- It's Real To Me with Tyler and Branden
- It's Time To Fight!
- It's Time To Fight!!
- IT'S TIME w/Bruce Buffer
- It‘s All Pro Wrestling Podcast
- IV Life Podcast
- IWTV Guide