Forever Fangirls Kimberly & Sheila Amato

Is my subject line too much? Maybe. But I really enjoyed your more nuanced review /podcast of Wynonna Earp'ds return. Too many fancasts make me feel like I'm crashing a teenage sleepover - inside jokes that are never explained, sweet gushing recaps of every element of the show, giggling effusive comments on the sexiness of actors, and an annoying tendancy to use the word "like" in every sentence. I love to hear enthusiasm, but I also prefer a podcast that makes me think about what I've watched and perhaps gives me some insight into the story and the filmmaking process. I didn't intend to write a critical review of other podcasts but I finally feel like I found hosts who I can relate to and who look at the show with a more detailed eye. I like hearing speculation on plot twists and that you're not afraid to point out elements of the show that are inconsistent or simply don't work. (Such as how exactly did Nedley get injured in season 4/episode 1). Keep up the good work.

This is one of the bests podcasts I’ve heard in a while! I look forward to every episode! Not only is the content great but the hosts are two genuine, amazing and funny women. If you’re not listening, you’re missing out!

Loved you guys, and you have a great back and forth. Would like if you guys continued doing episodes for Wynonna Earp. I hope for more of a favorite moments conversation though. Good, bad, and cute is a good concept but you didn’t really use the segment to talk about the content of the episode which was confusing. But maybe your intentions wasn’t to really dive into the episode. Thanks.