336 episodes

What happens when a double homicide case lands in your lap? What if it is the oldest active cold case in the history of American true crime? What if your father held a family secret for fifty years before he confided in you that one of the victims was your great-great uncle and that your grandfather had been held as a suspect? What if the murders happened during the most corrupt era our nation has ever known? And what if you are a retired detective, like me, with the unique skill set needed to figure out an 87-year-old family mystery? Well, you put everything else on hold and set out to solve it. This is my story.
Shattered Souls: The Car Barn Murders is presented by CrimeOnline and iHeartPodcasts.
Music by Sam Johnson

Shattered Souls iHeartPodcasts and CrimeOnline

    • True Crime
    • 4.3 • 4.2K Ratings

What happens when a double homicide case lands in your lap? What if it is the oldest active cold case in the history of American true crime? What if your father held a family secret for fifty years before he confided in you that one of the victims was your great-great uncle and that your grandfather had been held as a suspect? What if the murders happened during the most corrupt era our nation has ever known? And what if you are a retired detective, like me, with the unique skill set needed to figure out an 87-year-old family mystery? Well, you put everything else on hold and set out to solve it. This is my story.
Shattered Souls: The Car Barn Murders is presented by CrimeOnline and iHeartPodcasts.
Music by Sam Johnson

    Episode 17: "Fait Accompli"

    Episode 17: "Fait Accompli"

    Karen wraps up this part of the Car Barn Murders series with her assessment of accomplices Walter Oliver and Robert Janney along with a breakdown of the statement of Francis Gregory. Please go to the Shattered Souls Facebook page for insider details and to render your verdicts on the case. Stay tuned for future episodes and a few surprises! Thank you for listening!
    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    • 41 min
    Episode Sixteen: "DC Unconfidential"

    Episode Sixteen: "DC Unconfidential"

    After handing off her findings on William Clarke to you, the public jury, Karen details every factor and Clarke's criminal intent to put the final pieces together. She also uncovers the identity of Captain Vollten's confidential informants. 
    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    • 31 min
    Episode Fifteen: "We, the Jury..."

    Episode Fifteen: "We, the Jury..."

    Karen makes her opening argument against her primary suspect, William Clarke, based on the information provided in the 1935 reports and from Captain Vollten's confidential informants from 1954....but, who were the informants? 
    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    • 43 min
    Episode Fourteen: "The Greene Nexus"

    Episode Fourteen: "The Greene Nexus"

    Karen's friend, Stephanie White, cracked the identity of  DC Metro Police 'ex-Sergeant Greene", named numerous times in Captain Vollten's 1954 Addendum report. Who was this man and how did he play a role in the murders of Emory Smith and James Mitchell? 
    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    • 43 min
    Episode Thirteen: "Confidential Squared"

    Episode Thirteen: "Confidential Squared"

    The 1954 Addendum report written by Captain Vollten provided all of the details needed to crack the case, but there were still unidentified persons involved in the murder that Karen has to identify to come to a conclusion. 
    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    • 39 min
    Episode Twelve: "Beauty School Dropout"

    Episode Twelve: "Beauty School Dropout"

    As Karen continues putting the pieces together, she finds out about an addendum report that was not included in the original files. She also discovers that there may have been evidence tampering by one of the original detectives. William Clarke's friend and alibi, James Weir, goes on the run. 
    See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

    • 36 min

Customer Reviews

4.3 out of 5
4.2K Ratings

4.2K Ratings

Kjhar ,

Addictive and Suspenseful!

I’m a huge fan of true crime podcasts and this one is high on my list of favorites! I love how Karen unpacks the technical details but doesn’t forget to tell the story… and the story is so good! Completely hooked and can’t wait for more!

History Buff AZ ,

Go back to the old format of the show

The Car Barn Murders version of the podcast is dull. And will it ever end!? She’s gone on and on with a narrative that’s difficult to follow sometimes. She’d have been better off making this a book; it would be very successful. I’m on the episode after she’s handed it off to the listeners for a verdict. At this point I’m just listening to see how it ends. I lost interest in the case long ago. Why am I still listening? Curiosity mostly.

I prefer the old format when she discussed her Jacksonville cases. I lived there for 20 years and I guarantee there are 20 years worth of podcasts with all the crime that happened there.

Jbltmum ,

True Crime must listen

I’m obsessed with this podcast. When do you get a crime investigator researching to solve an old crime in their own family?! I wish this didn’t happen but I’m totally cheering Karen and her family on and hoping so much that this case comes to be solved by Karen in this podcast. I love the professionalism and the personal family connection that Karen brings to this story. Thank you for sharing with us! It’s so hard to wait for the episodes!

You Might Also Like

CrimeOnline and iHeartPodcasts
iHeartPodcasts and CrimeOnline
Wondery
Wondery
Nina Innsted
Steven Pacheco