164 episodes

Sameerah Blue and Jeanne Mahaffey come to you every week to talk deadly to you with a new true crime case. Smart, irreverent, and never victim-blamey, they will have you horrified by the basest of human nature and laughing at the sheer absurdity of it all.

Talk Deadly To Me Jeanne Mahaffey

    • True Crime
    • 3.3 • 23 Ratings

Sameerah Blue and Jeanne Mahaffey come to you every week to talk deadly to you with a new true crime case. Smart, irreverent, and never victim-blamey, they will have you horrified by the basest of human nature and laughing at the sheer absurdity of it all.

    Girly Chew Hossencofft and the Lizard People, Part 1 of 3

    Girly Chew Hossencofft and the Lizard People, Part 1 of 3

    We revisit an old case. In part one we meet Girly Chew Hossencoft, a wonderful human being who gets entangled with a nutjob, Diazien Hossencofft, who thinks his blood is magic and the Lizzard People are visiting the us.

    • 2 hr 29 min
    The Bergna Marriage, Part 2 of 2

    The Bergna Marriage, Part 2 of 2

    The end comes swiftly for a greedy little man.

    • 1 hr 23 min
    The Bergna Marriage, Part 1 of 2

    The Bergna Marriage, Part 1 of 2

    The tale of a very bad marriage starts with a very bad accident.

    • 3 hr 4 min
    We'll Be Right Back With A Whole New Season of TALK DEADLY TO ME!

    We'll Be Right Back With A Whole New Season of TALK DEADLY TO ME!

    • 46 sec
    Amy Bishop: The Horror From Harvard, Part 3 of 3

    Amy Bishop: The Horror From Harvard, Part 3 of 3

    The Bishops' selfish grief-fueled act of saving their daughter from accountability for the murder of her brother has devastating consequences for six other families.

    • 2 hr 27 min
    Amy Bishop: The Horror From Harvard, Part 2 of 3

    Amy Bishop: The Horror From Harvard, Part 2 of 3

    Amy begins a campaign of terror through Harvard and greater Massachusetts.

    • 2 hr 28 min

Customer Reviews

3.3 out of 5
23 Ratings

23 Ratings

LadyJayne59 ,

Bad Sound Quality

Sounds like you’re talking in another room. Listen to any other podcast ever then listen to yours.

Elizad111 ,

Too much laughter!

One of the worst true crime podcasts I have ever listened to. I was interested in the Elizabeth Haysom story because of the Netflix series. BUT the laughter with these two takes you out of the story. For example, the hosts are speaking of Elizabeth being raped 6 times and on drugs and then turning herself into the consulate while traveling Europe. Bahahahahahaahah uncontrollable laughter. Hilarious to them. There are so many more examples of obnoxious laughter. Hint: that’s not funny!!!
I’m out, can’t listen. Peace.

Pimento? ,

Something way off

I stumbled on this Pod because they cover some cases that I’m interested in. Sameerah is pretty solidly entertaining as a storyteller and puts in her research. Her sidekick, however, is so off-putting that it makes the pod physically uncomfortable to listen to. She laughs and “mmm-hmmm”’s in the most random places, as though she’s only half paying attention, and her comments and side remarks come off as insensitive, insecure, and victim-blamey.
There is something way off in the “voice” of this pod and the public chemistry between these two hosts as co-narrators.
I love a true crime podcast that makes me laugh, as long as we’re laughing at the criminals and bad behavior, not the victims (including their backgrounds, names, appearances, etc).
This one misses the mark HARD.
I hope that the hosts can take the reviews into account and improve it.

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Status: Untraced
Tenderfoot TV & Audacy
Beyond All Repair
WBUR
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Dateline NBC
NBC News
The Price of Paradise
Wondery
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery

You Might Also Like

Grim Tales from the Garden State
Mrs. B
True Crime Brewery
Tiegrabber Podcasts
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery
20/20
ABC News
Dateline NBC
NBC News
The Daily
The New York Times