6 episodes

In 2002 a young woman named Jamie Stickle, a popular bartender and beloved member of the LGBTQ+ community in Pittsburgh was tragically, violently killed in her car parked outside her home. Despite evidence indicating a homicide, Jamie's case was never classified as such, and remains unsolved to this day.

22 years later: Jaime Stickle, an actor, a writer, and podcaster who has been haunted by the association of their shared name, has made it her mission, along with her team, to tell Jamie's story, explore the many reasons her case went cold, and discover what has happened since.

The Girl With the Same Name The Girl With The Same Name Podcast

    • True Crime
    • 4.9 • 35 Ratings

In 2002 a young woman named Jamie Stickle, a popular bartender and beloved member of the LGBTQ+ community in Pittsburgh was tragically, violently killed in her car parked outside her home. Despite evidence indicating a homicide, Jamie's case was never classified as such, and remains unsolved to this day.

22 years later: Jaime Stickle, an actor, a writer, and podcaster who has been haunted by the association of their shared name, has made it her mission, along with her team, to tell Jamie's story, explore the many reasons her case went cold, and discover what has happened since.

    4. A Suspicious and Undetermined Death

    4. A Suspicious and Undetermined Death

    In the fourth episode, we dive into the Pittsburgh Police Department's investigation of Jamie Stickle's "suspicious death," and the Allegheny County Coroner's conclusion that her manner of death was "Undetermined."


    ---

    Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/thegirlwiththesamename/message

    • 31 min
    A Personal Message

    A Personal Message

    In this special "mini-sode" of the show, listen to an unedited direct message from Julie, Jamie Stickle's younger sister.



    Learn more, and engage with us at www.TheGirlWithTheSameName.com.


    ---

    Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/thegirlwiththesamename/message

    • 16 min
    3. Person of Interest

    3. Person of Interest

    In the third episode of The Girl With The Same Name, we explore the accusations made toward Sunny Varasso, create a timeline of Jamie Stickle's last night, and talk to witnesses who saw her that night.



    Learn more, and engage with us at www.TheGirlWithTheSameName.com.


    ---

    Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/thegirlwiththesamename/message

    • 31 min
    2. Rumors, Theories, and the Facts

    2. Rumors, Theories, and the Facts

    In the second episode of The Girl With The Same Name, your host, Jaime Stickle reviews a number of theories and allegations made about how Jamie Stickle may have come to her untimely end in 2002. She discusses these theories with the experts, and works toward eliminating some of the possibilities.



    Learn more, and engage with us at www.TheGirlWithTheSameName.com.


    ---

    Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/thegirlwiththesamename/message

    • 29 min
    1. A Life Interrupted

    1. A Life Interrupted

    In the premiere episode of The Girl With The Same Name, meet your host, Jaime Stickle and hear how she learned about the story of Jamie Stickle, and was compelled to tell her story. You will get to know who Jamie was, meet some of her family and friends, and hear the story of how she died, as well as the mystery that followed.



    Learn more, and engage with us at www.TheGirlWithTheSameName.com.


    ---

    Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/thegirlwiththesamename/message

    • 42 min
    OFFICIAL TRAILER! The Girl With The Same Name: The Cold Case of Jamie Stickle. Reported by Jaime Stickle.

    OFFICIAL TRAILER! The Girl With The Same Name: The Cold Case of Jamie Stickle. Reported by Jaime Stickle.

    On the eve of the premiere of the greatly anticipated podcast, this is the Official Trailer for the show.



    www.TheGirlWithTheSameName.com


    ---

    Send in a voice message: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/thegirlwiththesamename/message

    • 1 min

Customer Reviews

4.9 out of 5
35 Ratings

35 Ratings

MargoInEagleRock ,

Definitely a murder!!

I just fell all the way down the rabbit hole of Jamie’s bizarre murder. Totally perplexed, but absolutely certain she was murdered and I’m pretty sure the cops covered it up. So many twists and turns in this crazy story, and they did a really good job telling it. Can’t wait to hear how it ends! Definitely recommend to all my TC peeps!

brjsekhh ,

Riveting.

Been listening from the start and have been hooked since episode 1. I had no idea when I started how crazy this story would get. I don’t know if it’s a cover up or what, but I really hope they figure out who killed Jamie. She deserves justice. Great show. Worth subscribing.

UpstateEd ,

Instant fan!

This show absolutely took me by surprise. I knew nothing of either of the Jamies or about this story at all. But the story is so compelling and passionate and just so well done. I can’t wait to see where it goes, and I really hope they figure out who is responsible!

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Status: Untraced
Tenderfoot TV & Audacy
Beyond All Repair
WBUR
The Price of Paradise
Wondery
Dateline NBC
NBC News
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery

You Might Also Like

Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery
Southern Fried True Crime
Erica Kelley
Unraveled
discovery+
Texas Monthly True Crime: Shane and Sally
Texas Monthly
The Letter Season 2: Ripple Effect
Lemonada Media
What Was That Like - a storytelling podcast with amazing stories from real people
Scott Johnson & Glassbox Media.