Not Holier Than You

Karla and Craig Morton, Emmaus Christian Fellowship
Not Holier Than You Podcast

Underneath all the roles and identities we carry, at least from the standpoint of our faith, we believe that as human beings, we are all a part of God’s family. And in being human, understanding what it means to be human, we can deepen our relationships, work toward healing our broken communities and world with justice and compassion, and share in the story of God’s reconciling the world to God’s peace.

  1. episode 9: all in the family (of God)

    26/03/2021

    episode 9: all in the family (of God)

    episode 9: all in the family (of God) One of the aspects that is lost when begins to consider a theology that asserts that God’s love wins in the end, is the promise of heaven and the threat of hell are changed. If one leans toward universal salvation, hell is removed from consideration as a significant threat. And, if heaven becomes a gift of grace from God, why does it matter how we live now, especially if Jesus has paid the debt for our sin so that we do not have to? Many of the traditional motivations become obsolete and religion itself seems unnecessary. And if that were the case, announcing the good news of Jesus may be thwarted by disinterest, that is, if anyone remained motivated to speak the good news of God’s realm and reign. Humans have a religious impulse In Brian McLaren’s latest book, Faith After Doubt, McLaren poses two interesting ideas to contemplate. According to Jonathan Haidt and other teachers of moral foundations theory, whatever our religion or politics, we all use the same six basic lines of moral reasoning to defend our beliefs and opinions: justice, compassion, purity, loyalty, authority, and liberty.5 People of a conservative temperament, theorists explain, often feel morally superior because they emphasize all six. Liberals or progressives, however, focus on two: justice and compassion (pg 84). And later, McLaren describes his experiences while at the rally countering the Unite the Right march in Charlottesville, VA. After describing what he saw and did, Brian goes on to state: In the days after the event, I was given access to screenshots of the private communications among the fascist and white supremacist groups who organized the event (and who were called “very fine people” by the president). These communications convinced me that when people leave traditional religious identity behind, or subordinate it to a political or racial ideology, they don’t advance to a blissful secular harmony. No: we humans just as easily shift the sense of identity we once found in a passionate Stage One or Stage Two religious faith into what we might call quasi-secular religions like racism, nationalism, fascism, classism, and other -isms. (pg 110). Humans, it would seem are religion-making social organisms. So the question may not be faith or no faith, religion or no religion, but rather which religion? One primarily motivated by love and justice; or, one guided by the exercise of authority, purity, liberty, and loyalty? Ephesians 314-19 Every ethnic group in heaven or on earth is recognized by him (whom every family [πατριὰ] in heaven and on earth takes its name, NRSV). I ask that he will strengthen you in your inner selves from the riches of his glory through the Spirit. I ask that Christ will live in your hearts through faith. As a result of having strong roots in love, I ask that you’ll have the power to grasp love’s width and length, height and depth, together with all believers.  Questions for consideration: 1.       What is the good news of God (that’s the way Mark’s gospel says it)? 2.       Is there any motivation to or fear of consequences associated with not accepting the God’s gift of Jesus and the reign and realm he inaugurates? 3.       What do you make of the idea that we are religion-making creatures? 4.       What might it look like to announce a gospel of love and justice?

  2. episode 8: empathy is not a sin

    20/03/2021

    episode 8: empathy is not a sin

    No one should have to tell you that empathy is not a sin. But in case you were wondering, we don’t think so. A blogger on a popular evangelical website has the gall to try to write in the voice of CS Lewis’ Screwtape Letters, addressing these remarks to Uncle Screwtape’s nephew, Wormwood: “Now, sufferers have been placing such impossible demands on others from time immemorial. In response, our armies have fought for decades to twist the Enemy’s virtue of compassion into its counterfeit, empathy. Since we introduced the term a century ago, we’ve steadily taught the humans to regard empathy as an improvement upon compassion or sympathy. Compassion only suffers with another person; empathy suffers in them. It’s a total immersion into the pain, sorrow, and suffering of the afflicted. Under our influence, we’ve taught the humans to think, ‘Only a heartless and unfeeling beast could oppose such a total immersion, such a generous act of ‘love.’’ Our recent success in this conceptual migration has given us ample opportunity for mayhem” (by Joe Rigney). Intersectionality Here’s a quote from Womankind.org that proves a basic definition of the concept of intersectionality. Among other benefits, the theory of intersectionality can prevent us from shallow, one-dimensional assumptions about another’s identity. “Put simply, intersectionality is the concept that all oppression is linked. More explicitly, the Oxford Dictionary defines intersectionality as “the interconnected nature of social categorisations such as race, class, and gender, regarded as creating overlapping and interdependent systems of discrimination or disadvantage”. (from https://www.womankind.org.uk/intersectionality-101-what-is-it-and-why-is-it-important/). People are complicated and multi-layered. The additional layers, roles, and identities, while complex, can also allow for ways to connect and build relationships for equity, justice, and friendship. These roles are social identities, that is, they are defined by the ways culture defines these identities and become the opportunities for connection, or the differences that lead to rejection. These social intersections were continually identified by Jesus, and can be seen as a subplot in many of his interactions with others, especially with those who are suffering. In one story, a victim is suffering from disregard. In another story, a victim is suffering by being isolated and seen as the focus and center of attention and the locus of the problem. Luke 10.25-37 John 7.50-8.11 1.       How do we see Jesus crossing boundaries to enter into the pain, sorrow, and suffering of others? How do we hear Jesus’ “go and do likewise”? 2.       Consider the stories of the beaten man by the road and the woman accused of adultery. Discuss the ways intersecting roles combine with suffering and injustice. Are there other stories of Jesus where he crosses boundaries to enter into the suffering of others to rescue the image of God with each person.

  3. episode seven: We'll leave the light on for you

    04/03/2021

    episode seven: We'll leave the light on for you

    Episode Seven: We’ll leave the light on (Disclaimer: During the recording of the conversation, there were some issues with Internet quality. It may be annoying but suffer through it and you’ll be rewarded with enlightenment.) We still want to be a part of God’s project of reconciling the alienated human family of God. Rather trying to teach the techniques of becoming a better listener, we wondered about going deeper into understanding God’s intention of human beings as co-humanity, working on strategy more than tactics, foundations and not just practices. Humans are fully human in relationship. Genesis 1.26-27 continues to be the touchstone and the counter-myth of Babylonian gods and highlight God’s original intention for humankind. Over the past couple weeks, during our conversations, we became curious about the tradition of the inner, or inward light that is central to the Society of the Friends, more widely know as Quakers, or just Friends. This week, Karla and I sat down for a conversation with a couple of friends, Dr Carole Spencer, and Dr Colin Saxton. And both of these friends are Friends. Carole is a retired, but still teaching, professor of Christian Spiritual Formation. Colin is a recorded Friends minister having served in domestic and international roles, and now is a stewardship consultant for Everence. Both reside in Oregon. What we are curious about: 1) what is the inner light? 2) is this from creation or only for Jesus’ followers? 3) Is there scripture that provides foundation for this interpretation? 4) does understanding the inner light affect practices of pastoral care, spiritual formation, justice and equity, human rights, empathy and compassion, as well as engaging in the missio dei? Some ideas for consideration: View the following video on Youtube about this Friends’ distinctive, the inward light. Then consider this statement from one the early founders of the Society of Friends, James Nayler. Art thou in the Darkness? Mind it not, for if thou dost it will fill thee more, but stand still and act not, and wait in patience till Light arises out of Darkness to lead thee. Art thou wounded in conscience? Feed not there, but abide in the Light which leads to Grace and Truth, which teaches to deny, and puts off the weight, and removes the cause, and brings saving health to Light. (James Nayler, ca. 1650) Scriptures Light: Isaiah 42.6; Isaiah 49.6 John 1.4-5; 9 “That of God” Romans 1.16-20

About

Underneath all the roles and identities we carry, at least from the standpoint of our faith, we believe that as human beings, we are all a part of God’s family. And in being human, understanding what it means to be human, we can deepen our relationships, work toward healing our broken communities and world with justice and compassion, and share in the story of God’s reconciling the world to God’s peace.

To listen to explicit episodes, sign in.

Stay up to date with this show

Sign in or sign up to follow shows, save episodes and get the latest updates.

Select a country or region

Africa, Middle East, and India

Asia Pacific

Europe

Latin America and the Caribbean

The United States and Canada