Impossible Tradeoffs with Katie Harbath

Katie Harbath
Impossible Tradeoffs with Katie Harbath

Technology and democracy are at a crossroads. Technology can potentially empower people and make our democracies more responsive. Or technology can be used to manipulate and divide us. Welcome to Impossible Tradeoffs. I’m Katie Harbath. In this weekly podcast, we’ll talk about and analyze the most fascinating headlines. We’ll make predictions about where things are going. And we’ll talk to experts about the challenges we face and how we might look for solutions. anchorchange.substack.com

  1. 3 DAYS AGO

    The Long Tail Election

    Twenty years ago, Wired editor Chris Anderson wrote “The Long Tail” - a story about how “the future of entertainment is in the millions of niche markets at the shallow end of the bitstream.” Also, twenty years ago, the term “podcasting” was coined thanks to the introduction of the iPod and RSS feeds that could carry audio files. Today, in these final days before the election, we can confidently say that this prediction has become a reality—not just for entertainment but also for news and politics. I’ve been pondering this newsletter for a while, and Chris’s piece popped into my mind as I was thinking about how 2024 is being called the TikTok/Influencer/Podcast/Clipping/Shards of Glass election. What these all have in common is the theme that our information environment is more fractured than ever before, and influencers/creators across numerous platforms have proven their power to reach voters. I won’t be shocked if, for the 2028 cycle, we have a candidate announce for president on a podcast (DeSantis did technically announce on Twitter spaces, but that’s different.) Ben Thompson makes this point in his excellent column from Monday, “I think, though, that the ability to hold one’s own on a podcast is, in the long run, going to be a greater selection effect for President than people might expect.” The ground is shifting beneath our feet and will continue to do so as we increasingly use artificial intelligence to help us create and curate the information we consume. I will have much more to say on this as I try to figure out how to recap these last two years. Since January 2020, I’ve been talking about this historic year of elections around the globe, and it is almost over. The amount we’ve all gone through during this time is massive—and it’s only accelerating. Anchor Change with Katie Harbath is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. With only a week left until Election Day, I wanted to share five things to remember as we enter this new phase. * The information environment is shifting, which presents an excellent opportunity to shape this new reality. I’ve talked to a few folks wondering if their work since 2016 has been for naught because of the amount of disinformation online. It most certainly has not, but this work will need to change. I’m excited about digging into this new ecosystem and how we can mold how it evolves. What strikes me in re-reading Chris’ article 20 years later is that we can predict where things will go; it just takes us a long time for the technology and people to adapt, to accept the new reality, and to grieve the loss of the old one. Where we are today will not be where we will be in four years, as AI will do much more to curate the information we consume. We know this will happen, just not exactly how. That presents a lot of opportunity to start helping shape the future we want. Just look at this paper about how AI is helping to prebunk election misinformation. * A side thing to watch here is where people go to follow along as results start to come in. Cable channels usually shine here, but Amazon is doing its own Election Night special, as are TikTok users like V Spehar from Under the Desk News. Will people go there instead? * The tech CEO election. A side story of this election will inevitably be the role of the tech CEO. From Zuckerberg trying to pull back on politics and news to Elon leaning in and Bezos killing the Washington Post editorial, these CEOs are now political players whether they want it or not. Podcasting and newsletter platforms - and thus their CEOs - will become more critical. These CEOs are not the enemy, nor will they save us, but we must work with them - and hold them accountable. We can lament that they operate first and foremost as a business, or we can accept that and figure out how to impact them through those incentives. * AI isn’t as bad as feared

    6 min
  2. 24 OCT

    AI and the Election - What To Watch

    In this episode, Tim Harper discusses his extensive background in election administration and technology, focusing on the intersection of democracy and technology. He elaborates on his work with the Bipartisan Policy Center's task force aimed at improving election processes, as well as his current role at the Center for Democracy and Technology (CDT), where he addresses the challenges posed by generative AI in elections. (You can find all of CDT’s reports on elections here.) Tim shares insights from a recent report on AI chatbots and their impact on voting accessibility, highlighting the risks of misinformation and the need for better policies from tech companies. He also reflects on his experience at Facebook, where he managed political advertising policy during a tumultuous election period. In this conversation, Tim Harper discusses the complexities of managing online platforms during elections, focusing on policy development, crisis response, and the impact of generative AI. He highlights the challenges faced by tech companies in combating misinformation and ensuring election integrity, while also addressing the need for better communication and coordination among stakeholders. The discussion emphasizes the importance of preparation for both election day and the critical period following it, where misinformation and potential political violence could arise. Anchor Change with Katie Harbath is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to Anchor Change with Katie Harbath at anchorchange.substack.com/subscribe

    47 min
  3. 10 OCT

    Fusion Analysis to Identify Political and Tech Trends

    Welcome to fellow newsletter writer, Bruce Mehlman who has long been a fixture in DC for his smart graphs and quarterly reports on where the trends are going, not just in politics but also in the economy, tech, national security, and more. I highly recommend you sign up for his newsletter, Bruce Mehlman's Age of Disruption. In our conversation, Bruce discusses his journey from a political lawyer to a prominent figure in tech policy, sharing insights on the evolution of technology and its intersection with politics. He reflects on the early 2000s tech issues, the lessons learned from the rise of social media, and the current political landscape. Mehlman emphasizes the importance of trust in information, the future of media consumption, and the need for long-term thinking in politics and technology. He also highlights the significant advancements in health innovations and their potential impact on society. Some of the readings he recommends include: * The Storm Before the Calm: America's Discord, the Coming Crisis of the 2020s, and the Triumph Beyond by George Friedman * Stratechery by Ben Thompson * Noahpinion * Slow Boring by Matthew Yglesias Please support the curation and analysis I’m doing with this newsletter. As a paid subscriber, you make it possible for me to bring you in-depth analyses of the most pressing issues in tech and politics. Get full access to Anchor Change with Katie Harbath at anchorchange.substack.com/subscribe

    36 min

About

Technology and democracy are at a crossroads. Technology can potentially empower people and make our democracies more responsive. Or technology can be used to manipulate and divide us. Welcome to Impossible Tradeoffs. I’m Katie Harbath. In this weekly podcast, we’ll talk about and analyze the most fascinating headlines. We’ll make predictions about where things are going. And we’ll talk to experts about the challenges we face and how we might look for solutions. anchorchange.substack.com

To listen to explicit episodes, sign in.

Stay up to date with this show

Sign in or sign up to follow shows, save episodes and get the latest updates.

Select a country or region

Africa, Middle East, and India

Asia Pacific

Europe

Latin America and the Caribbean

The United States and Canada