Reluctant Idealist

Rahul Sharma
Reluctant Idealist

My podcast where I share my anecdotal views, experience and analysis drawing references from the books, films and/media that I read, follow or observe. All references to third-party sources are provided in Transcript to the audio, which is hosted on my blog.

Episodes

  1. Rhea Chakraborty-SSR, Moharram, Coronavirus, Pandating

    03/09/2020

    Rhea Chakraborty-SSR, Moharram, Coronavirus, Pandating

    Transcript of my first podcast, S1 E1 (August 29-30, 2020) वो लोग बहुत ख़ुश-क़िस्मत थे जो इश्क़ को काम समझते थे या काम से आशिक़ी करते थे हम जीते-जी मसरूफ़ रहे कुछ इश्क़ किया कुछ काम किया Hello there, this is Kabir Gandhi. Let's talk about the latest in the Rhea Chakraborty-SSR case. Well, Nidhi Razdan has written an article for NDTV in which she has said, “Grief and pain manifests itself differently for different people. One of my closest friends in college lost her father but didn't shed a single tear for two months. She was in shock and guess what, folks, if someone is calm and composed, it doesn't mean they are not in pain.” Reading Razdan’s article, I was immediately reminded of what the author Malcolm Gladwell calls ‘The Friend’s Fallacy’, or what he otherwise calls the issue of ‘transparency’, in his seminal work, ‘Talking to Strangers’. Gladwell explained with the example of the infamous 2007 Italian case of Amanda Knox in which Amanda Knox, an American student was convicted wrongly for her friend’s murder, only to be acquitted later on the basis of evidence that surfaced later. Amanda stood convicted by a ‘media trial’ of sorts we see in the SSR case, as she just didn’t convey the emotions people expected a person to convey typically soon after knowing of her friend’s murder, again, with eerie similarity to SSR’s case – that she just didn’t look the part! Gladwell surmised that most people commonly believe that the way a complete stranger looks and acts is a reliable clue to the way they feel, and that is where, they buy into the Friends’ Fallacy – Gladwell drew reference to the popular sitcom tv series Friends, in which, most characters played such parts that you could easily figure out from their rather simplistic facial expressions what they were feeling. Gladwell says that when dealing with complete strangers, that is often not the case. Razdan in her NDTV article went on to ask, “should Rhea have just lapped up the abuse and accusations she is facing from Sushant's family without hitting back? Why must women always bear the cross in a relationship? Indian families seem to think their sons are constantly brainwashed by their wives and girlfriends." I’ll conclude this topic with the appeal that we must wait and let law take its own course. We all deserve a fair trial, or whatever is left of it, in the current legal system of India. Just imagine if Rhea was your own sister, daughter or a close friend – how would you have felt? The second topic I wish to talk about is the disturbing news coming from Kashmir valley that dozens of mourners were injured, of whom several received pellet injuries, when police used pellet shotguns on Shia mourners in Srinagar, as reported on Outlook magazine's website. J&K Police said that Shia mourners violated prohibitory orders that barred all religious processions to prevent the spread of the Coronavirus. I’ll just say that with every such incident, India loses face, or whatever is left of it, before our Kashmiri brothers and sisters. How do you expect Kashmiri Muslims or Indians Muslims in general to make sense of such excessive and unwarranted use of brutal force when several Hindu religious processions at several major temples across India have been allowed by none other than the Supreme Court. Our Supreme Court will do itself and the nation great service if it let the Indian state keep at least a façade of secularism – howsoever, farcical that may be – in its national polity. I found a post on my FB wall that said, “We didn’t see Karbala. We have seen Kashmir” #Moharram 2020. I shared it on my wall too. Moving to the third, yet inter-related topic, India recorded 78,000+ new cases on August 29 (a day before recording of th

    12 min
  2. Bharat Ratna Former President Dr. Pranab Mukherjee passes away

    31/08/2020

    Bharat Ratna Former President Dr. Pranab Mukherjee passes away

    वो लोग बहुत ख़ुश-क़िस्मत थे जो इश्क़ को काम समझते थे या काम से आशिक़ी करते थे हम जीते-जी मसरूफ़ रहे कुछ इश्क़ किया कुछ काम किया   Hello there, this is Kabir Gandhi. Today, on the second day of my podcast, I will restrict myself to paying my respects to Bharat Ratna Former President Dr. Pranab Mukherjee who passed away a short while ago at the age of 84. I have been a huge fan of Dr Mukherjee, whom I had the great privilege of meeting personally during UPA-1. 'Pranab Da' as he was fondly called by friends and foes alike, he had a long and distinguished political career spanning over five decades, almost all of which he spent within the Congress Party. He was at the helm of almost every major ministry in Government of India, except for the top post, the Prime Minister-ship. One of the suavest politicians in post-Indira era, Dr. Mukherjee was often the chief-strategist, the chief trouble-shooter, and the fulcrum, on which the union government of the day revolved. His significance could be gazed from the fact that he once headed more than hundred all-powerful inter-ministerial committees. Of course, Dr. Mukherjee too had his fair share of controversies - but none stuck with him as much as the "canard that he had staked his claim to be sworn in as interim PM immediately after the assassination of former PM Indira Gandhi, and had to be persuaded with great difficulty to withdraw his claim." That allegation is further emboldened by the fact that soon after, Dr. Mukherjee quit the Congress and made his own party the Rashtriya Samajwadi Congress (RSC), in West Bengal. It's another matter that he merged his parry with the Congress only three years later only to stay loyal to Congress forever. Dr. Mukherjee, in his book 'The Turbulent Years' that is the second book, in his three-volume memoirs, Dr. Mukherjee recalls those exact days; Dr. Mukherjee was the one who broke the news of Indira Gandhi's "assault" on the fateful morning, to Rajiv Gandhi while both were in Contai (Kanthi) town of West Bengal to attend a political meeting. On their flight back, that had on board many other prominent Congress leaders such as Uma Shankar Dikshit, then Governor of West Bengal, his daughter-in-law Sheila Dikshit, Lok Sabha Speaker Balram Jakhar, Rajya Sabha Deputy Chairman Shyamlal Yadav, as well as the Secretary Generals of the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha, it was decided mutually that Rajiv Gandhi should succeed Indira Gandhi to the PM's throne. As soon as the flight landed, however, then Cabinet Secretary Krishnaswamy Rao counselled Dr. Mukherjee toe to take over as interim PM as Gulzari Lal Nanda had done in the past, to which, Dr. Mukherjee told him, promptly, that Rajiv Gandhi would be sworn in as a full time PM as there was no need of an interim-PM. However, this canard didn't die down, as Arun Nehru recommended that Rajiv Gandhi should be sworn in immediately by the Vice-President R. Venkataraman, instead of the President Giani Zail Singh who was not in country and was supposed to return at 5 PM the same day, as he feared that owing to his deteriorating relations with Indira Gandhi before her assassination, Giani Zail Singh might not agree to administer the oath to Rajiv Gandhi and instead insist on Pranab Mukherjee as the interim-PM. Dr.Mujherjee admits in his book, as well as quotes P.C. Alexander, from the latter's biography 'Through the Corridors of Power' that both of them counselled Rajiv Gandhi why such a haste would not only be constitutionally inappropriate as the Vice-President, in the absence of an express delegation by the President, had no power to administer path to PM, but also be deemed wrong by the world at large. Dr. Mukherjee again quotes from Alexander's biography and says that Rajiv happily agreed with their rationale. Pe

    8 min

About

My podcast where I share my anecdotal views, experience and analysis drawing references from the books, films and/media that I read, follow or observe. All references to third-party sources are provided in Transcript to the audio, which is hosted on my blog.

To listen to explicit episodes, sign in.

Stay up to date with this show

Sign in or sign up to follow shows, save episodes and get the latest updates.

Select a country or region

Africa, Middle East, and India

Asia Pacific

Europe

Latin America and the Caribbean

The United States and Canada