Weird Darkness: Paranormal & True Crime Stories

Darren Marlar | Weird Darkness

Award-winning podcast of true stories of the paranormal, supernatural, legends, lore, the strange and bizarre, true crime, conspiracy, mysterious, macabre, unsolved and unexplained -- seven days a week! Hosted by professional voice actor Darren Marlar, named one of the “Best Storytellers in Podcasting” by Podcast Business Journal.

  1. 14h ago

    THE GREENBRIER GHOST: She Came Back To Tell Her Mother Who Killed Her

    In January 1897, blacksmith Edward Shue washed and dressed his bride of three months for burial before the coroner ever reached their log house in Greenbrier County, West Virginia, and at her funeral he kept fussing with her head and neck, propping it on a pillow and wrapping a scarf around her high collar. Her mother, Mary Jane Heaster, had never liked him, and for weeks afterward she prayed every evening for her daughter to come back and tell her what had really happened. FEATURED STORIES IN THIS EPISODE: This Weird Darkness episode runs from the Greenbrier Ghost, the 1897 West Virginia murder victim whose mother said she came back to name her killer, to a bottomless pit in Washington, a wave of Mothman sightings over Chicago, and a London tomb rumored to be a time machine. Elva Heaster was dead – but that didn’t stop her ghost from solving the murder. *** In Stephen King’s “Pet Semetery”, beloved family pets could come back from the dead. *** In Washington there is a hole that some say brings animals back to life – for real. *** In the middle of the Brompton Cemetery grounds, shrouded by trees stands a mausoleum… and what some believe is a time machine. *** The Mothman is apparently no longer bound to Point Pleasant, West Virginia – in 2017 he appeared 55 times in Chicago. CHAPTERS & TIME STAMPS (All Times Approximate)… 00:00:00.000 = Show Open 00:01:15.097 = The Ghost Who Helped Solve Her Own Murder 00:09:24.382 = The Monster of Mel’s Hole 00:20:07.025 = The Chicago Mothman Sightings 00:26:13.008 = London’s Time-Traveling Mausoleum *** 00:39:45.750 = Show Close*** = Begins immediately after inserted ad break SOURCES and RESOURCES: “The Ghost Who Helped Solve Her Own Murder”: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/2p98d8pu “The Monster of Mel’s Hole”: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/1xpq30ql “The Chicago Mothman Sightings”: (link no longer available) “London’s Time-Traveling Mausoleum”: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/7pgczqce(Over time links may become invalid, disappear, or have different content. I always make sure to give authors credit for the material I use whenever possible. If I somehow overlooked doing so for a story, or if a credit is incorrect, please let me know and I will rectify it in these show notes immediately. Some links included above may benefit me financially through qualifying purchases.) WeirdDarkness® is a registered trademark. Copyright ©2026, Weird Darkness. *No AI Voices Are Used In The Narration Of This Podcast* EPISODE SYNOPSIS: This Weird Darkness episode runs from the Greenbrier Ghost, the 1897 West Virginia murder victim whose mother said she came back to name her killer, to a bottomless pit in Washington, a wave of Mothman sightings over Chicago, and a London tomb rumored to be a time machine. It opens in Greenbrier County, West Virginia, in January 1897, when a neighbor boy found Elva Zona Heaster Shue dead at the foot of her stairs, and her husband, blacksmith Edward Shue, had washed and dressed her for burial by the time Dr. George W. Knapp arrived, then grew agitated when the doctor tried to examine her neck. Her mother, Mary Jane Heaster, said Zona's ghost came to her four nights running to say Shue had broken her neck, and after prosecutor John Preston had the body exhumed, an autopsy in a one-room schoolhouse found the neck dislocated and the windpipe crushed. A jury convicted Shue in an hour and ten minutes, and a historical marker in Greenbrier County calls it the only known case in which testimony from a ghost helped convict a murderer. From there it moves to Mel's Hole on Manastash Ridge in Washington, a bottomless pit nine feet wide and lined with hand-placed bricks that a caller named Mel Waters described to Art Bell on Coast to Coast AM, saying 80,000 feet of weighted fishing line never hit bottom. Waters claimed a neighbor's dead dog thrown into the pit was later seen running in the woods still wearing its collar, that a sheep he lowered came up cooked from within, with something like a fetal seal with human eyes moving inside it, and that government agents paid him $250,000 to leave the country. Listeners who searched the local records found no trace of a Mel Waters or any sale of the land, and geologist Jack Powell, who first took it for an old mine shaft he knew from childhood, said a hole that deep isn't physically possible. Next, the Mothman, the winged creature tied to Point Pleasant, West Virginia, in 1966, turns up over Chicago, where researcher Lon Strickler logged 55 sightings in 2017. One witness who stepped outside a popular Chicago hangout late at night saw a creature with a slender head, muscular legs, and no feathers or fur flying awkwardly beneath a plane, and other reports describe it landing on cars and swooping down at people. University of Chicago psychologist David Gallo, who studies how people reconstruct memories, points out that the count rests on self-reports and that the mind can fill the gaps in a strange experience with a scenario it has already heard. The episode closes in London's Brompton Cemetery, where a 20-foot granite mausoleum with a pyramid top, a bronze door, and a band of Egyptian hieroglyphs holds Hannah Courtoy and two of her daughters. Courtoy, a housekeeper who inherited most of moneylender John Courtoy's fortune after a will dispute that dragged on until 1827, befriended Egyptologist Joseph Bonomi and was laid in the tomb in 1853. After its key went missing around 1980, a 1998 Associated Press story spread Howard Webster's claim that Bonomi and the inventor Samuel Alfred Warner had built a time machine inside. In 2011, musician Stephen Coates of The Real Tuesday Weld blogged that it was a teleportation chamber linked to London's Magnificent Seven cemeteries, an idea he says began as background for a short story, and he and a London storyteller began leading night gatherings at the tomb in 2015, while a replacement key was being made. More episodes, additional podcasts, books, original music, in-depth paranormal and true-crime articles, and much more at https://weirddarkness.com.

    THE GREENBRIER GHOST: She Came Back To Tell Her Mother Who Killed Her
  2. 1d ago

    THE HORRIFIC CRIMES OF ALBERT FISH: The Werewolf of Wysteria. The Vampire of Brooklyn. The Gray Man.

    In the early 1900s, children's worst nightmares became reality when Albert Fish stalked New York as a real-life boogeyman who tortured, murdered, and cannibalized his young victims over a decade-long reign of terror. READ or DOWNLOAD the full transcript of this episode: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/2p984xdu FEATURED STORIES IN THIS EPISODE: Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Raven” *** A UK woman sees a little sailor boy… a dead one. *** A 15-foot high B-25 bomber goes missing – in just 20 feet of water. *** A woman wakes up twice in the middle of her own surgery… but that’s not the scariest part. *** A rocking chair mysteriously moves itself to a completely different room. *** Two Romanian climbers found a strange yellowish object and as soon as they touched it something unexplained happened. *** Is teleportation impossible – tell that to Major Tudor Wellesley Pole. *** A new member joins a new age group – and she creeps everyone out. But they soon realize the feeling is warranted. *** September, 1952… was it a cryptid? An alien? We look more closely at what has become known as “The Flatwood Monster” from Braxton County, West Virginia. *** What began as a practical joke on some friends in a Revolutionary War cemetery backfires on the perpetrator. *** He’s been known by a few different names: “The Werewolf of Wysteria,” “The Gray Man”, even the “Brooklyn Vampire”. No matter the alias, Albert Fish is a murderer whose attacks took place over the span of ten years, causing terror in New York and throughout the United States. CHAPTERS & TIME STAMPS (All Times Approximate)… 00:00:00.000 = Disclaimer & The Foreboding 00:00:40.411 = Show Open 00:01:56.729 = “The Raven” by Edgar Allan Poe 00:10:37.576 = “Little Sailor Boy” *** 00:12:03.373 = “The Pennsylvania Ghost Bomber” 00:16:41.758 = “Operation Horror” 00:19:19.136 = “The Rocking Chair” 00:20:04.463 = “Bizarre And Unexplained Disappearances In The Bazau Mountains” 00:23:19.705 = “Mysterious Teleportation Case of Major Tudor Pole” 00:27:23.180 = “The Thing That Follows Her” 00:29:34.802 = “Meeting With The Flatwoods Monster” *** 00:37:17.650 = “The Scare That Backfired” 00:41:41.866 = “The Boogeyman Albert Fish” 00:51:11.185 = Show Close*** = Begins immediately after inserted ad break SOURCES and RESOURCES: “The Raven” by Edgar Allan Poe: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/1kzyvu38 “Little Sailor Boy” by Anthonly Michael Eyre for MyHaunteLifeToo.com: (link no longer available) “The Pennsylvania Ghost Bomber” by Troy Taylor: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/1f3gn5ly “Operation Horror”: (link no longer available) “The Rocking Chair” by Samantha Bradley for MyHauntedLifeToo.com: (link no longer available) “Bizarre And Unexplained Disappearances In The Buzau Mountains” by Nicolescu Vlad for MysteryToEagle.com: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/59j95292 “Mysterious Teleportation Case Of Major Tudor Pole” by Cynthia McKanzie for MessageToEagle.com: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/ht3psqr5 “The Thing That Follows Her” submitted anonymously to Weird Darkness: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/1k87qnvb “Meeting With The Flatwoods Monster”: (link no longer available) “The Scare That Backfired” by Gigakhan for YourGhostStories,com: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/4nu9b9z8 “The Boogeyman Albert Fish” Audrey Webster for The-Line-Up.com: https://weirddarkness.tiny.us/8j6vx8u4(Over time links may become invalid, disappear, or have different content. I always make sure to give authors credit for the material I use whenever possible. If I somehow overlooked doing so for a story, or if a credit is incorrect, please let me know and I will rectify it in these show notes immediately. Some links included above may benefit me financially through qualifying purchases.) WeirdDarkness® is a registered trademark. Copyright ©2026, Weird Darkness. *No AI Voices Are Used In The Narration Of This Podcast* EPISODE SYNOPSIS: This Weird Darkness episode runs from Edgar Allan Poe's "The Raven" to Albert Fish, the child killer called the Gray Man and the Brooklyn Vampire, with a B-25 bomber lost in Pittsburgh's Monongahela River, the Flatwoods Monster, climbers who vanished on a Romanian mountaintop, a teleportation case in Sussex, and listener encounters from Aberdeenshire to the Yorktown battlefield. It opens with a reading of "The Raven", Poe's 1845 poem about a grieving man visited at midnight by a raven that answers every question with "Nevermore". From there, a listener describes a summer morning on a mountainside across from the Macbeth Arms near Alford, Aberdeenshire, when a glowing boy in a Victorian sailor suit skipped past without touching the ground, and the co-worker driving fence posts beside the listener saw nothing. Next comes the ghost bomber of the Monongahela. On January 31st, 1956, Major William Dotson ran short of fuel on a training flight from Nellis Air Force Base in Nevada and ditched his B-25 in the river near the Homestead High-Level Bridge, now the Homestead Grays Bridge. Captain Jean Ingraham and Staff Sergeant Walter Sosey drowned swimming for shore, and the Coast Guard cutter Forsythia snagged the sunken plane's wing before the line slipped free. Neither a 14-day search by the Coast Guard and the Army Corps of Engineers nor a later volunteer sonar hunt with Pittsburgh's Heinz History Center found it, and the theories about its cargo run from a nuclear bomb to Soviet agents to Las Vegas showgirls bound for Washington. A cancer patient who'd been through 13 surgeries then describes waking twice during a 3 a.m. operation at a hospital in downtown Denver, the second time alone in a dark room beneath a laughing, hairy figure with two small horns and red eyes, wearing a bloody mask. Another listener, staying overnight at a family friend's house, woke at 3:30 a.m. to a huge thump, found a heavy rocking chair moved from the living room into a spare bedroom, and turned around to see a young boy who waved and vanished. In Romania's Buzău Mountains in 1981, a climber touched a yellowish, chain-like object on top of a rock carved with worn symbols and vanished in front of his brother. Their father climbed up to search for him and vanished the same way while ten people watched from the ground, and the rock was later demolished with dynamite. That leads into teleportation, the word Charles Fort coined, and two cases of it: Gil Pérez, a 16th-century soldier said to have been carried from Manila to Mexico, and the mystic Wellesley Tudor Pole, who wrote in The Silent Road that he found himself in the hall of his Sussex home as the clock struck six, about a mile and a half from the rail station where he'd been stranded, with his shoes still dry. Physicists have since teleported the information carried by particles of light and single atoms. A listener whose group meets at a new-age shop saw a bald, gray, Gollum-like creature crouched in a gift-shop aisle as a new member, a woman nobody in the group could warm to, walked through. A medium friend who saw it too said the thing always followed her. Then it's Braxton County, West Virginia, on September 12th, 1952, when a group of children chased a fallen light onto Bailey Fisher's farm with Kathleen May and her two sons and met the Flatwoods Monster, a figure about ten feet tall with a glowing red face, green clothing, and a head shaped like the ace of spades. Braxton Democrat reporter A. Lee Stewart found strange tracks on the hill the next morning, a doctor compared the witnesses' symptoms to mustard gas exposure, and Ivan Sanderson and John Keel both investigated before CSICOP's Joe Nickell concluded in 2000 that the group saw a meteor, an aircraft's flashing lights, and a barn owl. Flatwoods now holds a festival for its monster every year. A listener from York County, Virginia, ignored the family elders' warnings and took college classmates on a night ghost tour, starting at an uncle's grave that bore the listener's own name. At the Revolutionary War trenches from the Battle of Yorktown, two black silhouettes that the flashlight beam passed straight through ran at the group on two legs without a sound and stopped at the edge of the road. The episode closes with Albert Fish, the real-life boogeyman of New York, born Hamilton Fish and known as the Werewolf of Wysteria, the Gray Man, and the Brooklyn Vampire. He's tied to the 1924 murder of Francis McDonnell and the 1927 disappearance of Billy Gaffney, whose friend Billy Beaton told searchers, "The Boogeyman took him." Fish lured Grace Budd away from her family by answering her brother Edward's job ad while posing as a farmer, and later wrote the Budds a letter describing what he'd done to her. At his ten-day trial, jurors saw an X-ray of more than 20 needles he'd pushed into his own pelvis, then found him sane and guilty, and he went to the electric chair at Sing Sing. More episodes, additional podcasts, books, original music, in-depth paranormal and true-crime articles, and much more at https://weirddarkness.com.

    THE HORRIFIC CRIMES OF ALBERT FISH: The Werewolf of Wysteria. The Vampire of Brooklyn. The Gray Man.
  3. 2d ago

    THE BERMUDA TRIANGLE OF SPACE: A Smuggler's Last Shortcut | #RetroRadio

    Space smuggler Roger Thorpe swore he'd never fly through the hole in the sky again, a twisted stretch of space where ships go in and never come out, but a fixer offers him half the take on a load of contraband and only six days to deliver it. He goes through, and he comes out over a world whose stars he doesn't recognize. CHAPTERS & TIME STAMPS (All Times Approximate)… 00:00:00.000 = Show Open 00:01:30.028 = CBS Radio Mystery Theater, “The Hole In The Sky” (September 05, 1979) ***WD 00:45:48.973 = Suspense, “A Friend To Alexander” (June 15, 1944) ***WD 01:15:05.742 = Tales of Tomorrow, “The Other Now” (January 22, 1953) 01:45:54.351 = The Saint, “Music Murder” (June 18, 1950) ***WD 02:15:14.241 = Theater 10:30, “The Pedestrian” (1968-1971) ***WD 02:41:57.759 = 2000 Plus, “Worlds Apart” (November 29, 1950) ***WD 03:11:40.165 = The Unexpected, “Fool’s Silver” (1947-1948) ***WD 03:27:18.063 = Unsolved Mysteries, “The Witch Doctor” (1936) ***WD 03:43:18.010 = Columbia Workshop, “Carmilla” (July 28, 1940) (LQ) 04:14:40.035 = The Weird Circle, “William Wilson” (1943) 04:43:17.988 = The Whistler, “Pattern For Terror” (July 16, 1945) 05:12:44.205 = Show Close (ADU) = Air Date Unknown (LQ) = Low Quality ***WD = Remastered, edited, or cleaned up by Weird Darkness to make the episode more listenable. Audio may not be pristine, but it will be better than the original file which may have been unusable or more difficult to hear without editing. More episodes, additional podcasts, books, original music, in-depth paranormal and true-crime articles, and much more at https://weirddarkness.com.

    THE BERMUDA TRIANGLE OF SPACE: A Smuggler's Last Shortcut | #RetroRadio
  4. 2d ago

    BEING A MURDERER MYSELF: He Wants You To Know Exactly How He Did It | #MidnightInTheMacabre

    In 1957, “Being A Murderer Myself” turned up in an anthology with Alfred Hitchcock’s name on the cover and a title built to sell it: Stories They Wouldn’t Let Me Do On TV. The book was billed as a collection of tales too grisly for his television show, though a ghost editor named Robert Arthur actually put it together, and I couldn’t find any record of a network or sponsor turning this particular story down. Whatever the reason it landed in that book, it didn’t stay off TV for long. On September 27th, 1959, Hitchcock opened the fifth season of Alfred Hitchcock Presents with this very story, renamed “Arthur” and moved from South Africa to New Zealand, and he directed it himself. In the story Alfred Hitchcock personally directed for Alfred Hitchcock Presents in 1959, a South African farmer who considers himself a perfectly ordinary, civilized man writes down how he murdered his former fiancée, Susan Braithwaite, the night she showed up at his back door with a suitcase asking for help, and he isn’t the least bit worried about who reads it. The police searched every corner of his farm for her, and he’s glad to tell you what they missed. SOURCES and RESOURCES: “Being a Murderer Myself” by Arthur Williams, from the anthology “Alfred Hitchcock Presents Stories They Wouldn’t Let Me Do On TV”: https://amzn.to/2U59cIY WeirdDarkness® | Copyright ©2026, Weird Darkness | Midnight In The Macabre™ More episodes, additional podcasts, books, original music, in-depth paranormal and true-crime articles, and much more at https://weirddarkness.com.

    BEING A MURDERER MYSELF: He Wants You To Know Exactly How He Did It | #MidnightInTheMacabre
4.6
out of 5
3,859 Ratings

About

Award-winning podcast of true stories of the paranormal, supernatural, legends, lore, the strange and bizarre, true crime, conspiracy, mysterious, macabre, unsolved and unexplained -- seven days a week! Hosted by professional voice actor Darren Marlar, named one of the “Best Storytellers in Podcasting” by Podcast Business Journal.

You Might Also Like