Into The Dark

Payton and Garrett are hands down my favorite true crime podcasters! Their voices, chemistry, the way Payton constructs and delivers the stories to you.. scratches my brain the right way. Garrett’s witty commentary. I’m telling you, I’ve tried to listen to other true crime podcasters and I can never finish an episode because they lose me in one way or another. I only listen to the regular dropped episodes (because my hubby is too cheap to pay for subscription episodes lol) but I find myself looking forward to Monday mornings and seeing a new episode has dropped! Keep up the good work you guys!! You’re crushing it!!!

I like this show but the amount of ads that you have is crazy. I get that you need ads to keep the show running, but when you have a 35 minute episode and 3 breaks just to promote ads it gets old.

You mentioned coloring with alcohol markers in the latest episode and I laughed out loud because I listen to the podcast while coloring with alcohol markers! I recommend the Ohuhu brand if you’re interested in getting new ones. Pricey but high quality!

I get it she went through a lot during the holiday, but for us that are paying you to support YOUR podcast, it’s getting annoying when excuses come up when there isn’t an episode released because of an recording accidentally getting erased and you give the listeners an episode from into the dark on mwmh, or like recently not dropping any episodes since the middle of December on into the dark. I feel cheated out of my money.