So I have been listening to the 500 with JAM and friends for about 40 episodes. I love how the “discovery” of Josh goes along with the record being discussed. More importantly the discussion around what each record means to the people discussing is great. A great example is the Quicksilver Messenger Service episode. A band I have never heard of. But Josh with Morty and Wayne (two guests) go into depth about why this band is important in music and why it is on the list. NO famous guests (those are great too) but the interplay is awesome. I think you guys should go with the three (Josh, Morty, Wayne) plus a guest and maybe do an hour on history and an hour with a guest. Great Job!

The latest episodes on the birds was great. It reminded me of the way the Show used to be years ago. Love it. Keep up the great work Josh and Co.

I’d love to share a couple hoagies with Josh.

Long time listener, first time reviewer (of anything). Just wanna show love and express my support for the podcast and all the hard work that goes into it. Please keep it up. I’m a huge music & comedy nerd and it keeps both passions alive

I was really excited, when I heard about this podcast. It sounded like a great concept. Unfortunately, the host can’t seem to get out of his own way. Which given the caliber of guests he gets, is a shame. He constantly interrupts the guest. He also gets names and facts wrong way too much, for someone that is supposed to be such a fan of music. It seems like he doesn’t do a ton of research.

Decent podcast if you’re interested in what music your favorite comics dig and why, otherwise lots of tangents/riffing, and little dedicated album analysis. For that, I’d recommend Discord and Rhyme, or the 1001 Album Complaints podcast (both equal parts entertaining and insightful).

Been listening since the beginning and have loved the journey. Every week has been either a discovery of something new to me or a great homage to an album i already know and love. Josh and his guests and staff do a fantastic job of not only being informative but very entertaining and fun every episode.

An album book club. I just can’t keep the pace but I am following in chronological order Great companion to albums I love, albums I should know more about and newly discovered albums. Fleece is nice

I have enjoyed the first 300 episodes and really looking forward to the last 200! Keep rolling the awesomeness!

This show just gets better and better. Great guests. Great format. HIGHLY recommend