This is an all-time favorite podcast for me. As a lifelong Swiftie (here since Debut), I don’t always agree with all of Nathan and Nora’s takes, but I genuinely love their warmth, opinions, and intense love for Taylor as an artist. They are a joy and a pleasure to listen to. I would listen to anything they made together, but I’m especially happy they chose to make this! Edit: I still really love this podcast, but Nathan, while usually lovely, says the strangest, most out-of-touch things at times. I was just warming back up to him recently, and the phrase “racehorses have great lives” exited his mouth. Why are you guys spending 60 seconds of fans’ listening time on Nathan saying insensitive things? I just don’t get it. Not every thought is meant to be heard by tens of thousands of people, so perhaps stronger editing is needed.

I enjoy this podcast for the most part, but please stop making it the "Taylor Alison Swift's Fingerprints are on Everything" podcast, I beg. Her impact is undeniable, but most of the comparisons y'all make are a stretch at best and can really do a disservice to both an artist's work AND the far clearer influences behind it. Up the ante - $20 in the jar per mention! ;)

I adore this podcast and literally count down the days to new episodes. I feel like the content is a perfect balance and it’s introduced me to so many great artists and songs! Nora and Nathan are the best and their different takes are so interesting! They discuss culture amazingly. This is definitely my favorite podcast, and I feel so validated by Nathan standing up for Call Me When You Break Up, that song is fantastic lol!

I know this is meant to be an opinion-based show, but they don’t always feel grounded with their perspectives. Biases are apparent (especially with Taylor Swift and Gaga) after listening to this podcast for the last year.

Loved the original format of going thru old albums of artists but now a gossip show with Nora going full Hannah and Sara in her Sunday best. It’s about music not your fashion or restaurant entrance choices, keep that for your text chats.

I’ve really enjoyed this podcast. Would love a series on Lana’s albums!

Thank you for the rec Nora I totally agree with your take on JADE, I listened right after the pod. Angel of My Dreams is so weird and great!

Nora and Nathan have great chemistry. Nora’s joy for the music she loves is contagious! Whether I agree or disagree with their hot takes, I always enjoy it.

You both are so thoughtful and fun- I love hearing your takes. Thank you for bringing light to my week with your episodes!

Long time listener, first time reviewer. I wish they would stop talking about Beyoncé and the AOTY category. Asserting that a mother of three in her 40s who has been atop the music industry for decades hasn’t “done enough” for the white voting academy to understand the CC album and for it to deserve an award she should’ve been given on several other occasions emphasizes the hurdles black women have to navigate daily in white spaces. Something that they clearly don’t comprehend. It’s fine that they believe a lifetime achievement award is deserved for a Jamie Lee Curtis but not for their favorite celebrity’s celebrity, I just wish they would stop bringing it up. The same people that are the first to talk about how it is not good enough will be the same that are making sure they secure tickets to the concert over people that do get it and think it’s good enough. Just stick with praising Taylor and leave decades of blatant racial discrimination off the docket — as it seems impossible for them to discuss Beyonce without speaking Taylor’s name in the same sentence anyway.