If you’re sick of contrarian, negative takes on comic book movies before they even release, this might be the pod for you. These guys actually like their toys AND have a critical eye/voice. Great community online, excellent subscription bonuses, & people I’m genuinely happy to support.

I listened to the show because a friend was being interviewed…that’s all it took to be sucked into the community here. Sometimes Kyle or Robby will say something that will drive me mad (as any good podcast should…that’s friend I mentioned…I have definitely been seen yelling in my car at her…when she can’t here me…because it’s just a podcast and I am a fool). However, most of the time it is a joy, hearing to friends banter about things they love and you love. And then you can join the community and continue the conversation respectfully (not everyone sticks the landing on this…despite their intentions). And the content aspect is either very informed or asks excellent questions. It is Marvel, Superhero, Film, Comics (they interview pros…like my friend) centric…but there is constant expansion beyond this niche. The community shapes what the content organically, while Kyle and Robby still maintain it as their thing in balance. They are friends from work. We are all friends from work. It’s not a new age California cult…I promise…though I am sure we have a few of those members in our community. You just get sucked in. -A Basic Friendly Neighborhood Californian

For the first time I think you all are overthinking Episode 4 of Agatha… with the song it makes sense saying that her fans were the coven. The “witches road” is supposed to give you what you want the most. Her mother wanted her safety and being unable to go to the actual road, she made it into a protection spell that became a hit song and traveled the world knowing that the song would live on forever being played somewhere in the world making sure her daughter was safe. Using the fans as the coven it would always keep her safe. So the thought of her being upset at her mother because she thought getting to the road was her goal was a great way to flip it. I think we have to not be so literally with the words being spoken understanding the meaning is never as simple as what is said. Love the show!

The pod went downhill when they started the FFW+ nonsense. They want you to pay a monthly subscription fee that is half the price of Disney plus to listen to their generic takes. They also hid previously free podcasts behind a paywall. That would be fine if they didn’t also include ads and paid partnerships all the time. This used to be a cool passion project and it has clearly turned into a side hustle for them. Disappointed because this used to be my favorite MCU pod but now is towards the bottom of the barrel.

Whether you’re a casual or passionate MCU fan this podcast is for you. I’ve been re-watching phases 1-3 with the podcasts to follow the movies... This has been such a FUN time getting to hear other passionate fans break down and talk about their emotion after each viewing. I look forward to hearing more in the future..I can do this all day. -Jesse⚡️ #T2DW

This podcast is wonderful! Not only is it great for someone like me who LOVES Marvel but it’s great for anyone who dose not have any friends who care. I can go on and on about all marvel projects and no one I know cares. This show filled that void. Also thank you for being positive and not haters. Even for the projects that don’t work for you you don’t go on and on about what you hate about it and spiral into a hate Marvel and women campaign. So thank you! ❤️That kind of grifter energy is getting so old. Keep up the good work.

You guys starting a cult? No free thinking allowed here! You must only praise Marvel and the great FfW leaders! Criticism will be censored and the perpetrators punished and banned! You guys must be fun at parties. Blind devotion and fanaticism has taken new heights with these delusional bums.

The excitement for this episode that you two had was exactly where I was. Solid takes on the whole review. “Remember it” WAS insane .. I’m with you 100% Love your show, huge MCU fan , this always plays on my road trips and my regular listening rotation when I can. I appreciate the honest takes on all things Marvel.. remember to drive it like you stole it

Long time listener and first time writing in. Big MCU fan here and Season 2 of What If is probably my favorite MCU thing since Endgame. I’m surprised that you guys had so much trouble with it! It’s animation! It’s a cartoon! You guys are thinking too hard about it, maybe as your roles as podcasters. As a casual viewer of this stuff, it was just fun and epic! I wouldn’t over analyze Saturday morning Transformers cartoons, and you guys shouldn’t overthink these What Ifs. I also think Captain Carter and Kahorti were awesome characters to connect through the various episodes and seasons. As a 53 year old man, even I recognize the need for female and now Native American female characters and representation in the MCU. Love these two characters and hopefully Kahorti shows up in live action soon. Maybe in Echo???? I love this podcast and typically agree with you guys 100%, but just wanted to share my thoughts about What If and your review.

I have listed to a FEW and I use the word few loosely about mcu and oh my God their all either monotone and with theories that r absolutely outrageous (cough-Mcu Fan show-cough) or they just don't even understand the concept and act like 5 year olds. Please keep this up , y'all r funny and have GOOD theories and get along and don't act like u hate each other (cough- Paul and Sean - cough) Thank you for making this masterpiece. 🙏🏻 you know have a knew listener and follower. Gen z approved.