Schmelk is the best analyst/podcaster working the Giants beat. Respected as a peer by draft and NFL experts. Informed, enthusiastic, good interviewer, able to control his pro-Giant sympathies.

John Schmelk is consistently one of the best sports interviewers I’ve listened to—well researched, smart questions, good at drawing guests out. Never thought I’d be a year-round football content consumer but am now due to GiantsTV offerings like this, Eli Manning Show, Draft Season, and BBKL.

I preferred it much better when Papa‘s perspective actually gave us Bob Papa‘s perspective on the team and the previous or upcoming week instead of rehashing with former players individual games from the past. I like more Contant on the current team.

Thank you John and Giants media team. You guys work so hard to keep the fans engaged. I have friends that aren’t Giants fans and I beg them to listen to the Huddle and Big Blue Kickoff to get all of the draft news and all of the college journalists. You guys do it better than anyone.

Really appreciate the knowledgeable hosts of this podcast and the professional qualities. Schmeelk holds his own against anyone in the business.

Great podcast. Love the different interviews you have

Best podcast for NY Giants fans 💙🤍

The same commercial plays 4 times in a 15 min podcast. This is embarrassing, just horrendous

Would’ve given a higher rating if not for the multiple Grub Hub commercials they just throw in at the most in opportune times when like when guests are in the middle of a sentence during an interview. And ironically the commercial starts “is there anything more annoying”. And every single time all I can think there is nothing more annoying than how and when they run the commercials. I listen to a lot of podcasts and get that commercials pay the bills. No problem with commercials. But this podcast runs them at worst possible time…in middle of a sentence. And can’t make people want to use GrubHub. This review meant to be constructive so they fix this obvious problem

Please please please stop saying John John John John John in the middle of any sentence speaking to John Schmeltz. It is unbelievably annoying. Thanks