The Political Orphanage

Worth noting that it’s plural, not singular as the hosts kept saying. Textual support for the originalist notion that the 8th amendment prohibits certain methods and practices of punishment (ie “punishments”) rather than abstract categories of criminalization and “punishment.” Robinson (1962) would have been better decided on due process grounds.

I thoroughly enjoyed your debate musical. As usual, you were evenly critical and ever balanced. Thank you for the laughs.

Started following the show probably 6 months ago and have become a huge fan! Heaton routinely brings in diverse voices and construct hypotheses to take difficult problems. That being said, on the campus protest episode his guest Kaplan starting the discussion saying the protest was about dressing up as Hamas and supporting the Oct 7th massacre, which is disingenuous at best. There’s nothing wrong with letting someone voice that opinion on your podcast, but Heaton seemed to just go along with it in agreement. Might avoid these “round table” episodes in the future.

Andrew is a master interviewer who is happy to listen to all sides of a topic. Funny, smart, and informative.