Lizzy Halliday. The Worst Woman on Earth

Send Kris and Rob a Text Message!

Lizzie Halliday: The Worst Woman on Earth
In the late 1800s, the tranquil landscapes of the Catskills in New York became the backdrop for a series of horrific crimes that would shock the nation. The perpetrator? An Irish immigrant named Lizzie Halliday, whose life was marred by a trail of suspicious deaths, multiple husbands lost to mysterious circumstances, devastating fires, and eventually, the brutal murders of her own stepson and two unsuspecting women. Lizzie Halliday would go down in history as "The Worst Woman on Earth."

A Life Shrouded in Mystery and Death
Lizzie Halliday's life began in Ireland, but it was in the United States where her dark deeds would come to light. After immigrating with her family, Lizzie seemed to attract trouble wherever she went. She was married at least five times, and each marriage ended in disaster—either her husbands met untimely deaths, or they escaped—sometimes after mysterious circumstances. Although suspicions arose, Lizzie always managed to evade justice, often claiming insanity or simply moving on to another town to start over. Her criminal record was as complex as it was disturbing. Lizzie was arrested multiple times for crimes ranging from theft to arson, with the latter earning her several stints in jail. However, these brushes with the law did little to deter her from continuing her path of destruction.

A String of Unsolved Deaths
The true extent of Lizzie's crimes began to unravel when she moved to the Catskills with her latest husband, Paul Halliday, a Civil War veteran. Paul, much like Lizzie's previous husbands, would soon meet a tragic end—along with two other women and a stepson.

Insanity or Cunning?
When Lizzie was finally apprehended and brought to trial, she once again played the insanity card. Her behavior in court was erratic and unpredictable—she often flew into violent rages, attacking anyone within reach. Some believed she was genuinely insane, while others were convinced it was all an act to avoid the death penalty. The press of the time dubbed her "The Worst Woman on Earth," a title that seemed fitting for someone who could commit such heinous acts.

Ultimately, Lizzie Halliday was declared legally insane and sentenced to life in the Matteawan State Hospital for the Criminally Insane.  She wasn’t a model prisoner, trying to escape and commit suicide several times, but after 12 years, she settled in—mostly due to a young nurse named, Nellie Wicks. When Nellie decided to leave the hospital for another position, Lizzie stabbed her 200 times. Nellie died t hours later at the hospital. Lizzie would die there as well in 1918, taking the full truth of her crimes to the grave.

The Legacy of Lizzie Halliday
Lizzie Halliday’s story is a tragic mix of mental illness, unchecked violence, and a cunning ability to manipulate those around her. Whether she was truly insane or a cold-blooded killer who used insanity as a guise, Lizzie's actions left a lasting scar on the communities she touched.

Sources used for this podcast

Support the show

JOIN THE HITCHED 2 HOMICIDE IN-LAWS AND OUTLAWS

START KRIS CALVERT'S BOOKS TODAY FOR FREE

H2H WEBSITE
H2H on TWITTER
H2H on INSTA