96 episodes

YOUR true crime book club. Join Jill each month where she reads a book centered around your favorite true crime obsession and take a deep dive into the case and discuss the story from the author’s point of view.

Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast murdershelfbookclub

    • True Crime
    • 4.5 • 47 Ratings

YOUR true crime book club. Join Jill each month where she reads a book centered around your favorite true crime obsession and take a deep dive into the case and discuss the story from the author’s point of view.

    Episode 87: “Seventeen Nails”- Levi’s Eyes, by Aphrodite Jones, Pt 1

    Episode 87: “Seventeen Nails”- Levi’s Eyes, by Aphrodite Jones, Pt 1

    Meet the Karlsens, Christina, Karl and their 3 small children. Living in Murphys, California, Christmas 1990 was filled with mistletoe, ribbons and home-made cookies. But the joy was cut short, with tragedy striking. Grieving, the Karlsens move across the country to Romulus, NY, trying to settle into a new life. But back in California, investigators dig into the events of New Year’s Day 1991, where Christina Karlsen lost her life in a devastating fire. With question unanswered, suspicions rise, as Karl moves forward with his life.
    Sources, photos, diagrams, snack & wine pairing information is found on Jill’s blog at www.murdershelfbookclub.com 
    Use Jill’s code  murdershelf to save 10% on your Crimecon 2024 badges at https://www.crimecon.com/CC24   Look for Jill on Podcast Row! Check out the new designs on Jill’s Spreadshop! 

    • 1 hr 7 min
    Episode 86 2ndCast: "Lesser of Two Evils"- Murder on Elm Street- a true story by Jeremy L. Luberts Pt 3

    Episode 86 2ndCast: "Lesser of Two Evils"- Murder on Elm Street- a true story by Jeremy L. Luberts Pt 3

    Charged with 1st degree murder, Byron Smith’s trial beings for shooting Nicholas Brady and Haile Kifer to death in his basement on Thanksgiving 2012. Armed with damning evidence, the Prosecution presents its case of calculated revenge, as the Defense presents the Defendant as a fearful man, who only wanted to defend himself against violent intruders.  The wheels of justice turn, with some stunning decisions, as debates erupt over the Castle Doctrine vs homicide, with very real consequences for lead investigator, Jeremy L. Luberts. Where is Byron Smith today? Jill updates the case since publication, filling you in on his appeals.
    Sources, photos, diagrams, snack & wine pairing information is found on Jill’s blog at www.murdershelfbookclub.com  CRIMECON is coming- check out the new designs on Jill’s Spreadshop- free shipping April 11-April 15, 2024! 
    Use Jill’s code   murdershelf   to save 10% on your Crimecon badges at https://www.crimecon.com/CC24

    • 1 hr 1 min
    Episode 85: “The Mother Lode” Murder on Elm Street- a true story by Jeremy L. Luberts Pt 2

    Episode 85: “The Mother Lode” Murder on Elm Street- a true story by Jeremy L. Luberts Pt 2

    In Pt 2, with two teenagers dead, the Byron Smith investigation heats up, focusing on the rash of burglaries that had occurred recently, including those at Smith’s previously, with damning conclusions.  Accomplices and witnesses are interviewed, arrests are made, and another search warrant unearths the ‘mother lode’ of evidence that turns this case upside down, causing huge media surge and dividing the town, state and country in this divisive, emotional case of self-defense vs homicidal rage.
    Sources, photos, diagrams, snack & wine pairing information is found on Jill’s blog at www.murdershelfbookclub.com .
    Check out the new designs on Jill’s Spreadshop- make your favorite Murder Bookies SMILE.
    CRIMECON is COMING!  Use Jill’s code   murdershelf  to save 10% on your Crimecon badges at https://www.crimecon.com/CC24

    • 1 hr 6 min
    Episode 84: “The Deer Stand” - Part I on Murder on Elm Street- a True Story by Jeremy L. Luberts

    Episode 84: “The Deer Stand” - Part I on Murder on Elm Street- a True Story by Jeremy L. Luberts

    Enjoying a day with the family, Lead Investigator Jeremy Luberts is called into work at the Morrison County Sheriff’s Office to look into a concerning call. Arriving at the Elm Street residence, a retired Byron Smith meets him, telling him two burglars had broken into his house, and he’d defended himself, shooting them.  With 2 dead bodies, Jeremy Luberts begins an investigation that would change the small town of Little Falls, Minnesota and spark contentious debate across the country, changing his life forever.
    Sources, photos, diagrams, snack & wine pairing information is found on Jill’s blog at www.murdershelfbookclub.com 
    CRIMECON 24 is coming- check out the new designs on Jill’s Spreadshop.  Use Jill’s code   murdershelf  to save 10% on your Crimecon badges at https://www.crimecon.com/CC24

    • 59 min
    Episode 83: “Survivor Thriver”- Frozen in Fear: The True Story of Surviving the Shadows of Death by Jane Carson-Sandler Pt 4

    Episode 83: “Survivor Thriver”- Frozen in Fear: The True Story of Surviving the Shadows of Death by Jane Carson-Sandler Pt 4

    In Part 4 on Frozen in Fear, Jill chats with our author and survivor of the East Area Rapist, Jane Carson-Sandler.  Jane went from being a victim to a ‘Survivor-Thriver’, taking back control over her life, an extraordinary life of service, giving, and caring for others.
     
    You may want to listen to Ep 1 & 2 on Michelle McNamara’s book on the Golden State Killer, I’ll Be Gone in the Dark in conjunction with this trilogy.
     
    Donation Opportunity: Hope Haven of Lowcounty - Child Advocacy & Rape Center,
    Beauford, S.C.
     
    Sources, photos, snack & wine pairing information is found on Jill’s blog at www.murdershelfbookclub.com . Check out the new designs on Jill’s Spreadshop- make your favorite Murder Bookies SMILE!

    • 38 min
    Ep 82 2ndCast: ‘Sister Survivors” Frozen in Fear: The True Story of Surviving the Shadows of Death by Jane Carson-Sandler, Pt 3

    Ep 82 2ndCast: ‘Sister Survivors” Frozen in Fear: The True Story of Surviving the Shadows of Death by Jane Carson-Sandler, Pt 3

    Part 3: In this uplifting conclusion of the Frozen in Fear trilogy, the voices of the survivors of the East Area Rapist are raised, allowing us to see how these brave souls overcame adversity, trauma, and worse, taking back control, rejecting fear Updating what’s happened since the 2018 arrest of EAR-the Golden State Killer, Jane Carson-Sandler and her sister survivors reflect on his arrest, and what’s happened since, as they enjoy the best revenge- living productive, satisfying lives.
    You may want to listen to Ep 1 & 2 on Michelle McNamara’s book on the Golden State Killer, I’ll Be Gone in the Dark in conjunction with this trilogy.
     
    Donation Opportunity: Hope Haven of Lowcounty - Child Advocacy & Rape Center,
    Beauford, S.C.
     
    Sources, photos, snack & wine pairing information is found on Jill’s blog at www.murdershelfbookclub.com  Check out the new designs on Jill’s Spreadshop- make your favorite Murder Bookies SMILE!

    • 40 min

Customer Reviews

4.5 out of 5
47 Ratings

47 Ratings

AngieR1010 ,

Love the content BUT....

The audio is just not good. Please please upgrade your equipment.

CampCrystalLake79 ,

You will be glad you took a listen.

Great podcast, well presented. I enjoy the relaxed way the story is told with compassion for the victims. I really enjoy the book club feeling. Keep it up.

Whit0523 ,

Top Notch!

Great analytical breakdown of the case with a sense of humor and also compassion for the victims and their families.

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Beyond All Repair
WBUR
Status: Untraced
Tenderfoot TV & Audacy
The Price of Paradise
Wondery
Dateline NBC
NBC News
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery

You Might Also Like

True Crime Garage
TRUE CRIME GARAGE
The Trail Went Cold
The Trail Went Cold
LOVE MURDER
Jessie Pray and Andie Cassette
Real Crime Profile
Real Crime Profile / Wondery
The Generation Why Podcast
Wondery
Women and Crime
Cloud10