300 episodes

Lifelong fans of true crime stories Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark tell each other their favorite tales of murder and hear hometown crime stories from friends and fans.

My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark Exactly Right

    • True Crime

Lifelong fans of true crime stories Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark tell each other their favorite tales of murder and hear hometown crime stories from friends and fans.

    MFM Minisode 159

    MFM Minisode 159

    This week’s hometowns include a badass great-grandma and a very close call.

    • 18 min
    206 - Spatula City

    206 - Spatula City

    Karen and Georgia cover Laurie Dann, the Winnetka School shooter, and Leopold and Loeb.

    • 1 hr 27 min
    MFM Minisode 158

    MFM Minisode 158

    This week’s hometowns include an Alaskan mystery and an Edmund Kemper-related possession. 

    • 21 min
    205 - Everyone Gets A Horse

    205 - Everyone Gets A Horse

    Karen and Georgia cover the Blackout Murders and Scott Scurlock, the Hollywood Bandit.

    • 1 hr 37 min
    MFM Minisode 157

    MFM Minisode 157

    This week’s hometowns include serial killer connections and a thieving uncle.

    • 21 min
    204 - Periodical Time Tables

    204 - Periodical Time Tables

    Karen and Georgia cover The Butcher Baker Robert Hansen and the mysterious murder of Dorothy Jane Scott.

    • 1 hr 23 min

Customer Reviews

Har_Har_Harvey ,

Amazing podcast! I can’t wait to listen to more episodes! :)

I’ve been meaning to listen to this podcast for a while since I heard about it online(in what I think was a tumblr textpost of all things) and I finally got around to it about a week or two ago. I like to listen during the boring and repetitive parts of my day(like my math and tech theater classes), also on the drive to and from school and all my practices. I’m only nine episodes in and I’m hooked! This has basically become my new hyperfixation.

There’s never a dull moment on this podcast-which I will admit, may not be everybody’s thing, but by gosh it sure as hell is mine! You can’t zone out for one second or you’ll miss something, which was a pivot for the conversation and now instead of talking about the JonBenet Ramsey murder they’re talking about how small towns really just don’t think about the out of the box theories and how they might not have the money to run DNA.

I love how off the wall these ladies are and how generally they’ll just say what pops in their head. It’s really a good springboard for me when I just can’t seem to think of an idea for a project, or I’m stuck on one specific math problem. The ladies also somehow manage to keep difficult issues in mind when talking on some subjects and know how to broach the subjects with that in mind while still voicing their opinion, even if it doesn’t match up with other people’s(i.e. the general(as far as I know) public’s) views.

All in all this is an amazing podcast, the hosts are hilarious and just the perfect amount of laid back and casual, and I’m just itching to listen to more episodes. My commendations to Georgia, Karen, and all the others involved in making this podcast possible and available to people like me!

~Sincerely, Shelby H.

klhm39 ,

It’s the best podcast for the right people

If you are into murders but you aren’t a podcast snob this is the podcast for you. I personally love that this show has personality and feels real. I like that it is not scripted and pre planned. I’ve listened to other murder podcasts and it can be annoying to hear people take themselves too seriously. I like the banter and the chit chat but I would understand if someone else didn’t. Keep up the good work. This podcast isn’t for everyone, but it is still a 5 star cast. SSDGM

makeupmaskingmurderpodcast ,

Makeup Masking & murder

Where it all began 😭 I love you Karen and Georgia and how relatable you are and real! I love the stories you tell and I got so into your podcast that 1.5 years later I’ve started my own ❤️ thanks for all of the content you’ve put out there

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Listeners Also Subscribed To

More by Exactly Right