Rattled & Shook

I’m a big fan when they actually post new episodes but the majority of the time they are on hiatus. We’ve had like one season and everything else is re-runs. They’re too new to the game to already be doing re-runs of episodes.

I’ve been a longtime fan of Rattled & Shook and have always loved Meredith Stedman’s storytelling—her natural personality, engaging delivery, and candid, conversational tone made the show feel like a true experience rather than just another spooky podcast. Of course, Aprile Ruha and Meredith’s dynamic was a big part of what made it special, and while Aprile stepping away was a huge loss, I had confidence that Meredith would continue to carry the show in her own unique way. However, since the rebrand (or whatever shift is happening), something feels really off. In fact before I’ve rated the show 5 stars! However it feels like the show has lost the authenticity and personality that made it so compelling. Meredith’s responses now feel scripted, overly polished, and at times even robotic—almost like she’s reading lines rather than actually engaging with the stories. The energy, the natural flow, and the feeling that she actually cares about the cases have all faded. It doesn’t even feel like her anymore. I don’t know if this change is due to Tenderfoot TV or something else behind the scenes, but if it is a production-level decision, I really hope they reconsider. The storytelling has become blunted and lacks the depth and personality that made this podcast stand out in the first place. The reason so many of us were drawn in was because Meredith felt real, like she was with us in the story. Now, it feels detached, cookie-cutter, and honestly, a little soulless. I truly hope this is just a temporary adjustment period and that we’ll see Meredith’s real voice and style return soon. I miss the energy, the conversational approach, and the genuine enthusiasm she brought to each episode. Rattled & Shook has always been a favorite of mine, and I’d love to see it thrive again—but in its original, authentic form, not this overly sanitized version.

My Dad has built Marriotts all over the country for 30 years. You will never find one with a 13th floor. LOVE THIS PODCAST! My complaint is, I always want this show to be longer!

I tried… I really did.. but I felt my brain turning to mush … just get it away from my ears…