The Guest House

The Guest House

How do Muslim New Zealanders make sense of the Christchurch mosque attacks?

Season 1

  1. EPISODE 1

    Stage 1: Denial

    Mohamed Hassan works through the five stages of grief felt by Muslim New Zealanders after the March 15 attacks. Stage one is denial; he talks to Hassan Raslan, who spent three days helping with the burials. "This being human is a guest house, every morning a new arrival. A joy, a depression, a meanness, some momentary awareness comes as an unexpected visitor." - Rumi It is a normal part of trauma to experience dissociation in the face of an overwhelming crisis. A body can shut down, or shut out key pieces of information so that you are able to function. Sometimes that means delaying an emotional response to a tragedy - feelings of pain, loss and sadness are pushed to the back - replaced by a numbness. A denial. "It felt unreal, you know? Like you were watching a movie or something," saysHassan Raslan, a biomedical engineer from Auckland. "The more I realised how serious it actually was, it just made me sick to stomach." This is how many of us felt in the wake of the Christchurch attacks. Dazed. Unable to accept that our tiny Muslim community had been suddenly and violently ripped open, and our places of worship deprived of their safety, we pushed all our feelings aside and got to work. Within days, a bustling volunteer centre was set up at a local school, and hundreds of Muslims from across the country flew down to lend a hand with food distribution, visiting families and survivors, and most importantly, assist in the mammoth task of washing and burying the 51 victims. "It hit me really hard on that first day, when there were only three or four people being buried. My friend was there, burying his father, and it was so difficult seeing him in that state. It was just a wrecking ball." Hassan Raslan was one of them. The first dozen bodies were buried over three days, in a large cordoned section of land at the Memorial Park Cemetery, where 51 empty graves lay side by side. Volunteers wore yellow vests and ushered each body, and its family, to the allocated grave. Then they led hundreds of people from the Muslim community to walk past one by one, pray, pay their respects, and empty a fistful of dirt into the grave. On the first Friday after, the remaining 40 victims were buried, one after another, across three hours. "It's not an easy task to bury 40 people. I'm not talking emotionally, I mean physically," he says… Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

    15 min
  2. EPISODE 2

    Stage 2: Anger

    After denial comes anger. Guled Mire became a spokesperson for his community after the mosque attacks, but when he showed anger at the death of innocents, he found the tide shifting. Guled Mire is a firecracker by nature, driven by an unyielding sense of justice. It often gets him into trouble. After the March 15 Christchurch attacks, he suddenly found himself a voice for his broken community, sifting through his own emotions and figuring out what he could say out loud, and what he couldn't. Like many other young Muslims he felt angry at what had happened. Angry at the immeasurable loss of life. Angry that warnings from the community about rising levels of hate and Islamophobia had being ignored for years. When he started to express this anger though, he quickly found himself facing intense public backlash. "Most negative feedback I've received is when I've been the most angry, speaking my mind and saying how it is," says Mire, a community advocate. "I think when people see me on TV or on the radio they don't really understand the balancing act that goes into it. I have to talk to myself again and again, in the shower or in the bathroom, going over my key messages. Making sure I don't fit into that angry black man stereotype." After March 15, Mire wanted to speak about the racism he saw directed towards Muslims in New Zealand, and ask questions about whether the government had failed to protect his community. Initially he felt he was allowed to speak his mind freely in interviews and on social media, but within a few days he felt the tide shifting against him. Suddenly, the comments sections, letters to editors and personal emails were calling him an "outsider", an "ungrateful refugee" who should be thankful for New Zealand having "given him a new home". "It was like I wasn't even allowed to have a say as a Kiwi. I was being critical of my own country, but that wasn't afforded to me." Then things began to spiral out of control. When The Crusaders announced they were considering a name change because of the historical connotations of their brand, journalists began asking Mire what he thought. He gave his opinion, supporting a change, and thinking nothing of it. But overnight, he found himself become a lighting rod for angry comments, hateful personal messages and eventually, death threats. "There have been instances where I've had to report things to keep my own safety in check, people talking about 'this is just the beginning'." he says. "You can't take your safety for granted especially after Christchurch."… Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

    14 min
  3. EPISODE 3

    Stage 3: Bargaining

    After anger comes bargaining. 'If only we had taken better care of our Muslim neighbours'. But we hadn't and many Māori stepped up, drawing on their own experience of exclusion. Some of the most remarkable and deliberate responses to the Christchurch attacks stemmed from Māori culture. In the week following March 15, not a day would pass without a high school, a community group or even a chapter of a local gang showing up outside the mosques and singing, crying and performing a haka. There was an earnestness and beauty in the way different Māori groups went out of their way to be seen, and to make the Muslim community feel supported and safe. Students from Cashmere High School, who'd lost two of their own in the shootings, Sayyad Milne and Hamza Mustafa, visited the mosques each day and sang in their hundreds. Māori churches gathered their congregations, families and children and performed resounding haka, many of which were recorded and went viral worldwide. Many people abroad had never seen haka outside of All Blacks games. They didn't realise it could be a tool for mourning. The Waikato chapter of the Mongrel Mob spent days camped outside Hamilton mosque to guard Muslims as they prayed. In Christchurch, they brokered a truce with their historic rivals, Black Power, to share a message of love and unity. Rewa Worley, a high school teacher of Te Reo and science at St Paul's College, says it was important for Māori to be present and extend their sense of kaitiaki, or guardianship, over a fellow New Zealand community that was in pain. "People were trying to find a way to release that pain. It wasn't a regular pain. It was a national tragedy," he says. "It was important for Māori to come alongside the Muslim community, but also figure out, what do we do in this situation?" There was also another reason many Māori felt so connected to Muslims after the Christchurch attacks. They saw a community being targeted, misrepresented and attacked, and reflected on their own experiences with racism and white supremacy in New Zealand. "The two-sided or the two-faced nature of New Zealand and its interaction with Māori people has always been one of ostracism and colonisation and exclusion or limited and convenient inclusion." He remembers the stories his grandfather told him about his own upbringing, when he was forced to attend a 'native school'. There, students were only taught trade skills and carpentry because of a belief that Māori were only suited for using their hands. "All of these crazy ideas that have required over time Māori to rebut and overcome and rebuke. It's strange where they come from, but it's not a surprise."… Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

    14 min
  4. EPISODE 4

    Stage 4: Depression

    After bargaining, the depression. It was felt by Muslims even half a world away, who experienced the 'vicarious trauma' and thought maybe they were right to worry about their safety after all. This year a study out of Sussex University referenced the term 'vicarious trauma' to describe how Muslims react to events that happen in different parts of the world. Because of a shared sense of community, a brotherhood, Muslims often feel a deep sense of sadness, even a personal grief, when they hear or read about the suffering of others. These days, it's hard to escape. When looking at the headlines of events taking place around the world, it often feels to many in the community as if Muslims are a constant target for those with far-right ideologies, populist political figures growing in popularity by focusing on immigrants and refugees, and demagogues scapegoating Muslim minorities to expand their control. As Muslims, we watch with a sense of growing dread and helplessness the ethnic cleansing of Rohingya in Myanmar, the millions of Uyghurs held in concentration camps in China, the lynch mobs hunting Muslims in India and the millions of Syrians fleeing for their lives only to face cruel and unsympathetic borders. It often gets overwhelming. On the day of the Christchurch attacks a year ago, Muslim communities around the world felt a very similiar shock to Muslims in New Zealand. The sudden and calculated attack on worshipers during Friday prayers felt to millions worldwide like it had struck the heart of their own neighbourhoods, their own mosques. Poet and activist Suhaiymah Manzoor Khan remembers the day very well, and how she felt attending Friday prayers in London only hours after hearing the news. "In the women's section of my mosque, there's a very narrow set of stairs. I've always thought 'oh God, this badly needs renovating', because it takes so long for everyone to get out," she says. "It took on a more sinister meaning on that day, and I kind of thought 'wow, there are no escape routes in here'. Then you suddenly start thinking of fears you used to brush off before and think 'gosh, I'm so paranoid'." Those fears included imagining scenarios where her local mosque would be attacked, or if members of her community and family were targeted on their way back home from prayers. "It was this sudden realisation that it's not absurd, it's not crazy, it doesn't make us insane to imagine an incident like what happened (in Christchurch), happening."… Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

    14 min
  5. EPISODE 5

    Stage 5: Acceptance

    And finally, hopefully, acceptance. Sheikh Gamal Fouda, the imam of Al Noor mosque, traveled the world offering a message of peace. But he found his own inner peace here at home. It wasn't until November that Sheikh Gamal Fouda really came to terms with what happened to his small community. The imam of Al Noor Mosque spent the weeks and months after the attack travelling around the country and the world, at the invitation of governments, kings and religious institutions wanting to give a platform for the victims of Christchurch. He was speaking at the United Nations, at Islamophobia forums in the US, at the royal court of Saudi Arabia. What he wasn't doing was dealing with his own trauma. When he finally got a chance to return home to his wife and daughters, away from the politicians and media, the emotions came flooding to the surface. "I woke up one day and I started to process what happened and realised that yes, there was a terror attack in our mosque, and lots of people were killed. I couldn't comprehend it." Sheikh Gamal was in the middle of giving his weekly sermon on Friday March 15, when a stranger entered his mosque and started shooting. He watched as the people he had intimately known and served for 17 years were killed. "We used to think that New Zealand is one of the safest places in the world, and for a while I thought that this is no longer a safe place." Leaning on his faith and prayer for guidance and stability, he also began seeing a psychologist over the last few months to help process and unpack the traumatic events he witnessed, and the pressure it heaved onto him as a community leader. He admits to never having heard terms like 'white nationalism' and 'white supremacy' before the attack. It was strange to him, and he didn't understand where their ideology came from. What he did understand was the Islamophobia targeting Muslims, and the toxic hatred that had led to the horrendous act of violence that struck his community. "I put these people in the same basket as Al Qaeda and ISIS and the Taliban, because terrorists are terrorists, whether they're using Islam or using Christianity or anything else. But I think religions must be part of the solution, not part of the problem." Just one week later, he stood defiantly on a podium in the middle of Hagley Park, across the road from his cordoned mosque where forensic examinations were still underway, and gave a sermon to the world. "We are determined to love one another and to support each other. This evil ideology of white supremacy did not strike us first, yet it has struck us hardest," he said on March 22… Go to this episode on rnz.co.nz for more details

    14 min

About

How do Muslim New Zealanders make sense of the Christchurch mosque attacks?

More From RNZ Originals

To listen to explicit episodes, sign in.

Stay up to date with this show

Sign in or sign up to follow shows, save episodes, and get the latest updates.

Select a country or region

Africa, Middle East, and India

Asia Pacific

Europe

Latin America and the Caribbean

The United States and Canada