Nina instead’s podcast “Already Gone” was my intro into the world of true crime podcasts back in 2015, and I like her straight facts and signature voice. I love this podcast because I am hearing new cases (to me) that haven’t been rehashed a thousand times in the true crime stratosphere. I’ve tried to listen to the sister podcast UK version, but I like Nina’s style and cases better. I hope new podcasts come out, but haven’t seen anything new in my feed since 2023. Keep at it Nina!

Extended quotes and background material from family and friends of the victims, mar the narrative. The podcast makes me feel lousy for my fascination with True Crime. Just give me the facts and not protracted sentiment. The UK version is infinitely superior.

... she ruins it with her unnatural speaking voice. She doesn't sound the way someone would sound in normal conversation. She gets to the end of a sentence and accents the last couple of syllables in an unnatural fashion as if she were a news/weathercaster or something – whatever it is, it's absolutely unlistenable. I suggested to her to listen to Mr. Casefile or Benjamin but she maintains "this is just my voice" and would take no constructive criticism. Too much background noise and the taped narration by other speakers like in the courtroom or from the police or whatever are often very hard to hear. I just can't get my mind around the fact that she would not consider trying to improve her podcast and cops out by saying "it's just my voice." What a waste of great material.

Please

It took a little to adjust to the style, I think largely because it’s so different from other true crime podcasts- but, once I adjusted I found myself enjoying it. I really like that there are stories shared on here that I haven’t heard before.

I hope so! I was really enjoying listening to this one.

But just can’t get used to narrator’s voice… please bring back Ben!

I’ve heard of smear campaigns but after reading these reviews I’m still shocked! I love it’s sister podcast (oh please don’t smear it too!) and I was throughly accustomed to the “voice” and straight facts. There’s no fluff here; just facts. And I’ve never heard a recording played on this podcast, so go figure since I’m an avid fan and listened to every episode. Smear campaign? Absolutely!

Thank you for sharing your amazing talent as a storyteller with us. All of your stories are factual and told without bias. You are truly an advocate for the victims so eloquently described in your stories.

I don't mind Nina's style of storytelling. I find the cases interesting, but what I cannot tolerate are the constant audio clips where it is so hard to understand what is being said. This springs my rating down. If it is necessary to the story, please just read it rather than play audio clips of such poor sound quality.