Dark Poutine - True Crime and Dark History Curiouscast

Episode 259: After she’d been missing only one day, on the evening of May 7th, 2002, the body of 14-year-old Jessica Grimard was discovered by her father in a stream within a wooded area near her home in Rivière-des-Prairies, a suburban borough on the eastern tip of the city of Montreal, Quebec.
As her killer had placed Jessica in the water, washing away evidence, there was not much for the cops to go on. At first, police considered that Jessica had been killed by someone known to her. However, thanks to a few strange twists, the case would head in a new direction, eventually capturing a known sexual predator and suspected serial killer who had bragged about his crimes. The boasting included confessions of responsibility for two other 1993 deaths around Montreal, initially ruled accidental, that of 12-year-old Christine Speich and 20-year-old Anna Lisa Cefali. The killer had used water and fire to cover his crimes.
Sources:
Angelo Colalillo | Murderpedia, the encyclopedia of murderers
Une marche pour commémorer le triste événement | TVA Nouvelles
Meurtre de Jessica Grimard: un an plus tard, la douleur reste vive | TVA Nouvelles
Grimard (Jessica) - La Mémoire du Québec
2000 CanLII 6067 (QC CQ) | R. c. Paccione | CanLII
2003 CanLII 10002 (QC CQ) | R. c. Chalfoun | CanLII
2005 CanLII 49803 (QC CS) | R. v. Colalillo | CanLII
2005 CanLII 49804 (QC CS) | R. v. Colalillo | CanLII
2006 QCCS 274 (CanLII) | R. c. Colalillo | CanLII
2006 QCCS 7903 (CanLII) | R. c. Colalillo | CanLII
Search - Newspapers.com: Angelo Colalillo
The Man Behind the Letters | PressReader.com
Letters to be examined in Chalfoun trial | CBC News
Colalillo laisse derrière lui son testament criminel | TVA Nouvelles
Colallilo (Angelo) - La Mémoire du Québec
West Island man who sexually assaulted about 20 women denied parole | Montreal Gazette
Cold Careers and Occupational Hazards: The Occupational Preferences of Canadian Serial Killers
Accused Quebec serial killer dies in hospital | CBC
Quebec murder suspect took own life: report | CBC News
The sudden death of a man ‘like a wolf amongst the lambs’ - The Globe and Mail
The Murderer Who Used Water To Hide His Trace | Real Stories |YouTube
Cold North Killers: Canadian Serial Murder | Scribd
Angelo Colalillo (1964-2006) - Find a Grave Memorial
Lifeless in a Stream | Real Crime | By Real Crime
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Episode 258: On the morning of February 20, 1989, stay-at-home mother of two Janice Faye Johnson was found unconscious, gravely injured and barely clinging to life at the foot of a flight of basement stairs in the Shelburne, Nova Scotia home she shared with her family, Clayton Norman Johnson and daughters Darla and Dawn. Even though she was still alive when she was found by a neighbour, who called for an ambulance immediately, Janice died in the hospital just after noon that day.
More than three years after her death, police arrested Janice’s husband, Clayton, a high school industrial arts teacher, and charged him with first-degree murder. Consistently maintaining his innocence throughout subsequent proceedings, on May 4, 1993, Clayton was found guilty of the first-degree murder of his wife. He was later sentenced to life in prison — his appeals, citing spurious forensic evidence, were rejected. He spent the next five years in prison.
Sources:
Clayton Johnson - Innocence Canada
Crown Halts Clayton Johnson Murder Prosecution - Government of Nova Scotia, Canada
Clayton Johnson Settlement - Government of Nova Scotia, Canada
Clayton Johnson: Innocent man convicted by so-called experts
Clayton Johnson walks as Crown balks at new trial | CBC News
Shelburne man, wrongly convicted of wife’s murder, dies | CBC News
1998 NSCA 14 (CanLII) | R. v. Johnson | CanLII
1994 NSCA 79 (CanLII) | R. v. Johnson | CanLII
Clayton Johnson - Wrongful Conviction - Pyzer Criminal Lawyers
Clayton Johnson: obituary and death notice on InMemoriam
Clayton Johnson wrongful murder conviction: Tide of Suspicion (1998) - The Fifth Estate — YouTube
Wrongly convicted man cleared in wife’s death - The Globe and Mail
Accident or Murder? | Forensic Files Wiki | Fandom
“Forensic Files” Accident or Murder? (TV Episode 1999) - Reference View - IMDb
Obituary | Clayton Norman Johnson of Barrington, Nova Scotia | H.M. Huskilson’s Funeral Home
Scribd | Justice Miscarried: Inside Wrongful Convictions in Canada 
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Episode 257: In Victoria, B.C., on the rainy evening of Friday, September 29, 1899, on her way home from work alone, forty-four-year-old Agnes Bings walked across a railroad bridge, cutting through the Songhees Reserve as she did every other night without incident. This night, however, would be her last. Someone took her life somewhere during the 20-minute walk between her bakery on Store Street and the Bings family home on Russell Street. The next morning, Agnes Bing’s body was discovered. She’d been strangled, and her body mutilated. Her slaying has never been solved, although there have been a few suspects, interestingly including the world’s most famous serial killer, Jack the Ripper, whose 1888 crimes also remain unsolved.
Sources:
HISTORY OF DOWNTOWN VICTORIA | LIVE SITE
Home | Victoria
Canada’s Jack the Ripper
Pinkerton’s National Detective Agency Records Relating To The Murder of Agnes Bings | PDF
Historical police records give a glimpse into Victoria’s seamier side | Times Colonist
The British Colonist 1858-1961
Agnes Bings (1855-1899) - Find a Grave Memorial
Murder & Mutilation In Victoria - Jack The Ripper Forums - Ripperology For The 21st Century
Unlocking the Dark Secrets of Victoria - Monday Magazine
Coroner Inquests in BC around the time of Agnes Bings’ Murder
Seeing Dead People E23 — Mrs. Bings Meets a Madman
The History of Garrick’s Head Pub | Victoria, BC, Canada
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Episode 256: Colten Boushie was a 22-year-old Indigenous man from the Red Pheasant First Nation in Saskatchewan, Canada, who was shot and killed on a farm near Biggar, Saskatchewan, on August 9, 2016. His death received widespread attention and led to a national conversation in Canada about systemic racism and the treatment of Indigenous peoples in the criminal justice system. The trial and acquittal of the farmer who was charged with Boushie’s death, a man named Gerald Stanley, also sparked controversy and led to calls for reforms in the Canadian justice system.
Sources:
Red Pheasant Cree Nation – A prospering Nation
2017 SKQB 366 (CanLII) | R v Stanley | CanLII
2017 SKQB 367 (CanLII) | R v Stanley | CanLII
2018 SKQB 27 (CanLII) | R v Stanley | CanLII
Colten’s friend Eric talking about the shooting | Twitter
Victim, friends needed help with flat tire before farmyard shooting: witness | 650 CKOM
DocumentCloud | FSIN Media Release
The night Colten Boushie died | The Globe and Mail
The Legal Trial of Gerald Stanley - a second look at the case through the lens of law | CanLII Connects
CRCC Final Report on the Death of Colten Boushie
‘Have to keep talking about it,’ says Boushie’s mother, five years after Stanley acquittal | Star Phoenix
Colten Boushie, Gerald Stanley and a case that’s hard to defend | The Star
Read ‘The Rodney King of Western Canada’: Killing of Indigenous Man Heads to Trial Online
Who was Colten Boushie? | CBC News
Colten Boushie Archives - APTN News
‘White Lives Matter’ signs show up in North Battleford Saskatchewan
Debbie Baptiste | Canada’s National Observer: News & Analysis
Brad Wall - Racism has no place in Saskatchewan. | Facebook
We Will Stand Up | CBC Docs POV |YouTube
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Episode 255: On September 28, 2016, a police dog discovered the nude and decomposing body of a young woman on the grounds of Gabriola House, a famous and, at that time, abandoned mansion on Davie Street in Vancouver’s West End. The body was that of Natsumi Kogawa, 30, a Japanese woman who’d been in Canada on a Visa to study English since May that year. Natsumi’s friends and family had not heard from her since September 8, and she’d been officially listed as a missing person four days after that. 
On the same day as discovering Ms. Kogawa’s body, police arrested William Victor Schneider, a man from Vernon, B.C. Schneider’s brother Warren turned him into the police after William had told him where he’d put Natsumi’s body and that he ‘done something bad.’ Warren also recalled to police about overhearing a phone conversation during which he said he’d thought William had admitted to having killed Natsumi.
The legal proceedings that followed dragged on into the fall of 2022.
Sources:
Hirosaki – Travel guide at Wikivoyage
Tonari Gumi - Japanese Community Volunteers Association - Vancouver, Canada
FIND Natsumi Kogawa／古川夏好さん捜索情報 — Facebook
Search for Natsumi Kogawa - TokyoReporter
Japanese woman missing in Canada - Japan Today
Vancouver Shinpo - 古川夏好さん三回忌しめやかに
Vancouver Shinpo - その三十五　古川夏好（こがわなつみ）さんの一周忌
古川さん殺害、終身刑の男が控訴 | 日加トゥデイ/JC Today
Police Looking for Missing Woman | Vancouver Police Department
Update: Body of Missing Woman Found | Vancouver Police Department
EXCLUSIVE: Friends of murdered Japanese student, Natsumi Kogawa, speak out - BC | Globalnews.ca
A look at the troubled life of William Schneider, the killer of Natsumi Kogawa - Vernon News - Castanet.net
‘It’s my fault,’ court hears accused tell police in murder trial of Japanese student | The Star
Man gets life in prison for killing Japanese woman in Canada | The Japan Times
‘People listened’: Mother of murdered Japanese student grateful for guilty verdict | CBC News
New trial ordered for man found guilty of murdering Japanese student Natsumi Kogawa | Globalnews.ca
Murder conviction of B.C. man who killed exchange student restored: Supreme Court of Canada | Globalnews.ca
‘People listened’: Mother of murdered Japanese student grateful for guilty verdict | CBC News
1523 Davie St, Vancouver, BC • Vancouver Heritage Foundation | Vancouver Heritage Site Finder
YOU SHOULD KNOW: About The History Of “The Gabriola Mansion” In The West End – Scout Magazine
2021 BCCA 41 (CanLII) | R. v. Schneider | CanLII
2022 SCC 34 (CanLII) | R. v. Schneider | CanLII
Supreme Court of Canada - SCC Case Information - Docket - 39559
Supreme Court of Canada - 39559
Supreme Court of Canada - SCC Case Information - Webcast of the Hearing on 2021-12-10 - 39559
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Episode 254: On Saturday, June 23, 1990, three teenagers, Brigitte Grenier, 16, Kyle Unger, 19, and Timothy Houlahan, 17, all separately attended a music festival at a ski resort near Roseisle, Manitoba. The following morning, Brigette was discovered dead in a creek in a heavily forested area within the resort. She’d been sexually assaulted, beaten, tortured and strangled to death. As both had been seen with the victim during the hours before her death, police quickly targeted Kyle Unger and Timothy Houlahan as suspects in Brigette’s slaying. 
Forensic evidence pointed to Houlahan, and he, in turn, pointed to Kyle Unger as Brigette’s murderer, but Kyle was adamant he’d had nothing to do with Brigette’s death. The physical evidence against Kyle Unger was a single strand of hair found on Brigette’s sweatshirt. RCMP needed more, so they turned to their tried and true Mr. Big technique and, sure enough, acquired a confession from Kyle Unger. In February of 1992, both Unger and Houlahan were convicted of first-degree murder. Both appealed. Houlahan’s appeal was successful, and in July 1993, the Manitoba Court of Appeal ordered a new trial for him. Tim Houlahan completed suicide before his second trial. Kyle Unger’s conviction was upheld.
Did the justice system get it right? Unfortunately, we will see that it did not, at least not right away.
Sources:
Historic Sites of Manitoba: Roseisle Pioneer Monument (Roseisle, RM of Dufferin)
1992 CanLII 13202 (MB KB) | R. v. Unger (K.W.) and Houlahan (T.L.) | CanLII
1993 CanLII 4409 (MB CA) | R. v. Unger | CanLII
Kyle Unger settles wrongful murder conviction | CBC News
Kyle Unger — Innocence Canada
Kyle Unger | News, Videos & Articles — Global News
Real Justice: A Police Mr. Big Sting Goes Wrong: The Story of Kyle Unger by Richard Brignall

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices